- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PhysioDyT, a JEPA-style ECG and PPG pretraining method, in which each ECG token is softly matched to PPG tokens one to five tokens ahead, through unbalanced optimal transport with a "dustbin" state. Subsequently only PPG is used for downstream. Using paired ECG for pretraining is very reasonable, and have of course, been used in a lot of sota work. However, this paper does not demonstrate much improvement in terms of downstream performance, when comapred with exsiting encoders.
Critical strengths
- The comparison protocol is solid and reasonable.
- The usage of ECG for pretraining on PPG is valid.
Critical weaknesses
I am mainly concerned that the paper does not show a clear downstream advantage, and that none of the proposed components is ablated.
Clarity and Presentation
- the paper reads more like a progress report than a finished paper, e.g. "archived summary", "run-level verification is pending" (L435), and the test set "remains sealed" (L225).
- Neither the pretraining corpus nor CWPC is described. Supplementary materials L390 said "will provide" configurations, so it is very hard to reproduce as submitted.
- The related work could be benefited from more comprehensive and thorough discussion, currently on 10 references (!)
Methodology
- None of the core components (positive delays, delay scoring, etc) is ablated.
- I am not convinced by the physiologically directed claim. The learned delay barely agrees with pulse arrival time (Spearman ~0.022, MAE 256 ms), and a 160 ms token is far too coarse to resolve beat-to-beat PAT anyway.
Experiment and Results
- I am a bit concerned about Table 1. It still reports the historical cohort (0.7695), and PhysioDyT drops by about 0.05 on the clean cohort, while MOMENT and NormWear barely change.
- Pulse-PPG collapses to 0.5146 in the clean evaluation, what happened?
- CHD detection from PPG might be strongly confounded by age, so an age/sex-only baseline would be expected.
Minor Issues and Suggestions
- Figure could be enhanced by increasing the font size.
Questions for authors
Apart from above weakness, I would expect some clarification on:
- How does PhysioDyT compare with a PPG-only self-supervised model trained on the same corpus, and with variants without transport or without the dustbin?
- Could the authors describe the pretraining corpus and CWPC?