- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript presents Meredith, a physiology-informed framework for medical time series classification. The framework consists of two key components. One of them is Rhythm Mixer, which learns rhythm-aware representations through frequency decomposition and adaptive aggregation. The other is DACE Net, which incorporates temporal delays to enhance cross-channel representations. The authors evaluate the proposed method against 10 competitive baselines on medical time series benchmarks, demonstrating promising classification performance.
Critical strengths
1、 The paper is well motivated by the characteristics of physiological signals, particularly physiological rhythms and temporally delayed cross-channel relationships. The overall research motivation is clear and relevant to medical time series classification. 2、 The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, covering multiple datasets and a wide range of baseline methods. The authors also adopt both Fixed Subject Split and Monte Carlo Cross-Validation protocols. The main experimental results demonstrate competitive performance across several benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
1、 The core delay-aware aggregation in DACE Net, under its current parameterization, appears mathematically equivalent to a constrained multichannel causal convolution. The paper does not sufficiently clarify the methodological novelty of this formulation or establish its advantages over conventional temporal convolutions through controlled comparisons. 2、 Some ablation results exhibit unexpected behavior that is not adequately discussed. For example, on the PTB dataset, removing both Rhythm Mixer and DACE Net (w/o Both) achieves higher Accuracy and F1 scores than removing either component individually. This non-monotonic behavior raises questions about the interactions between the proposed modules. 3、 Appendix A.1 indicates that some baseline results are taken from previously published studies, including TeCh, rather than obtained by reimplementing all methods under a unified experimental setting. Although using published results is acceptable, the paper should more clearly establish whether the preprocessing procedures, subject splits, label definitions, and evaluation protocols are consistent across the compared methods. 4、 Table 6 reports 72 subjects for the TDBrain dataset, whereas Appendix A.2.1 describes the selection of 25 patients with Parkinson's disease and 25 healthy controls, totaling 50 subjects. This discrepancy raises concerns about the clarity of the dataset description and experimental setup.
Questions for authors
1、 How well does DACE Net generalize to subject-specific or time-varying physiological delays? 2、 Does Rhythm Mixer benefit from physiological frequency priors rather than generic learnable frequency decomposition? Would randomly initialized or uniformly spaced frequency bands achieve comparable performance? 3、 How does the computational and parameter complexity of DACE Net scale with the number of channels and the maximum temporal delay?
2 comments
Response to Reviewer fewe (Part 2)
W4. Clarification of the Number of Subjects in TDBrain Dataset
A4:
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this inconsistency. We apologize for the reporting error in Table 6, where the number of subjects in TDBrain was incorrectly reported as 72 instead of 50. We will correct this in the revised manuscript.
Importantly, this error does not affect the experimental setup or the fairness of our comparisons. Our experiments follow the same TDBrain preprocessing protocol as Medformer, which explicitly states in Appendix B.2: "In this paper, we utilize a subset of this dataset containing 25 subjects with Parkinson’s disease and 25 healthy controls, all under the eye-closed task condition." Therefore, our experiments consistently use the same 50-subject subset as Medformer, and the discrepancy is limited to the reporting error in Table 6.
Q1. Generalization of DACE Net to Subject-Specific and Time-Varying Delays
A5:
(i). Generalization across Subjects.
DACE Net learns channel-pair-specific delay distributions shared across subjects, rather than explicitly estimating individualized delays. Nevertheless, Meredith is evaluated under both Fixed Subject Split and Monte Carlo Cross-Validation protocols, where training and test subjects are disjoint. The results demonstrate that the learned representations generalize to unseen subjects, although they do not directly establish subject-specific delay estimation.
(ii). Adaptation to Time-Varying Delays.
The current DACE Net uses globally learned delay distributions that remain fixed during inference. While its downstream refinement layers can produce input-dependent representations, the delay weights themselves do not adapt dynamically to temporal changes. We acknowledge this limitation and consider input-dependent delay estimation a promising direction for future work.
Q2. Contribution of Physiological Frequency Priors.
A6:
Please refer to A1(i) to Reviewer KDrH, where we provide controlled comparisons among Canonical (ours), Uniform, Random, and Fixed Canonical Rhythm Bank variants. The results consistently demonstrate the benefits of physiologically informed frequency initialization and adaptive frequency learning.
Q3. Computational and Parameter Complexity of DACE Net
A7:
The complexity of DACE Net depends on the number of channels , sequence length , maximum temporal delay , and number of refinement layers .
(i). Parameter Complexity.
DACE Net employs channel weights and delay weights, together with a projection layer and channel refinement layers. The total number of learnable parameters is (including the learnable parameters of BatchNorm layers), yielding a parameter complexity of when is fixed.
(ii). Computational Complexity.
Delay-aware aggregation requires operations, while channel aggregation and subsequent projection and refinement require operations. Therefore, the overall computational complexity is , which simplifies to for a fixed .
Thus, both parameter and computational complexity scale quadratically with the number of channels and linearly with the maximum temporal delay. This is consistent with the asymptotic complexity of conventional multichannel causal convolution, while DACE Net introduces structured channel connectivity and delay distributions.
References:
[1] Medformer: A Multi-Granularity Patching Transformer for Medical Time-Series Classification (NeurIPS 2024)
[2] Towards multi-resolution spatiotemporal graph learning for medical time series classification (WWW 2025)
[3] Decentralized Attention Fails Centralized Signals: Rethinking Transformers for Medical Time Series (ICLR 2026)
Response to Reviewer fewe (Part 1)
Dear Reviewer fewe:
Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully addressed your comments, and our detailed responses are provided below.
W1. Mathematical Interpretation and Advantages of DACE Net over Conventional Convolutions
A1:
We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment. We acknowledge that the delay-aware aggregation in DACE Net can be mathematically interpreted as a constrained multichannel causal convolution. However, the key distinction lies in its structured parameterization, which explicitly separates cross-channel connectivity from temporal delay distributions.
(i). Methodological Distinction.
Unlike conventional convolutions that directly learn unconstrained spatiotemporal kernels, DACE Net parameterizes the effective convolution weights as Wi,j,d=Ai,jPi,j,d, where Ai,j represents the learned connectivity between channels i and j, and Pi,j,d characterizes their temporal delay distribution at delay d∈{0,…,τ}, with τ denoting the maximum temporal delay. Both are normalized through Softmax, yielding non-negative, normalized aggregation weights. This design introduces an explicit structural inductive bias for modeling delayed cross-channel interactions, rather than proposing a fundamentally new convolution operation.
(ii). Controlled Comparisons with Conventional Convolutions.
To evaluate the effectiveness of this design, we conducted additional experiments replacing the core delay-aware aggregation with either Causal Conv1D or Standard Conv1D, while keeping the remaining architecture and training settings unchanged. As shown in the following table, DACE Net consistently outperforms both alternatives, demonstrating the effectiveness of its structured delay-aware parameterization.
W2. Non-monotonic Ablation Results and Module Interactions
A2:
We acknowledge the non-monotonic behavior on PTB and provide the following clarification.
(i). Explanation of Non-monotonic Behavior.
Rhythm Mixer and DACE Net capture complementary information through physiological rhythm modeling and delay-aware channel enhancement, respectively. Their outputs are integrated before the Transformer encoder, meaning that their contributions are not necessarily additive. Moreover, each ablation variant is independently trained from scratch, and removing different modules changes both the feature representations and the optimization process. Therefore, removing both modules may occasionally yield better performance than removing either one individually.
(ii). Effectiveness of Joint Modeling.
As shown in Table 2, although the "w/o Both" variant outperforms the two individual ablations on PTB in terms of Accuracy and F1 score, the complete Meredith model substantially outperforms all three variants across all six evaluation metrics. Furthermore, "w/o Both" variant performs worse than both individual ablations on the other four datasets.
These findings indicate that the contributions of Rhythm Mixer and DACE Net are not strictly additive, while the consistent superiority of the complete model across all five datasets supports the effectiveness of their joint integration.
W3. Fairness and Consistency of Baseline Comparisons
A3:
(i). Fixed Subject Split.
Our experiments follow the evaluation protocol established by Medformer[1], which is also adopted by MedGNN[2] and TeCh[3]. Specifically, the preprocessing procedures, subject splits, and label definitions are consistent across these studies, ensuring fair comparisons under the same experimental setting. Therefore, directly adopting previously reported baseline results is appropriate and avoids unnecessary reimplementation. Notably, TeCh follows the same practice, explicitly stating on page 6 that "The results of all baselines on the five MedTS datasets are directly taken from Medformer."
(ii). Monte Carlo Cross-Validation.
Please refer to A3(i) to Reviewer KDrH for clarification of the evaluation protocol and baseline comparisons under this setting.
We will further clarify these details and the sources of the baseline results in Appendix A.1 to improve transparency and reproducibility.