- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes DPIKAN, a physics informed KAN approach to estimate blood pressure from physiological signals. The approach consists of decomposing the signal into slow-varying and fast-varying components, integrating biological information such as heart rate in the learning process, and regularizing using a physics informed loss. The approach is evaluated on public datasets and a newly collected Ring PPG dataset which is also released. DPIKAN outperforms different categories of baselines while providing efficiency gains.
Critical strengths
Integration physiological priors in the learning process: Adding physiological information during the training through physics informed KAN is interesting.
Contribution of a new dataset: The new Ring PPG dataset which will be released is a useful resource for the community. Moreover, the efficiency analysis on a Raspberry Pi is a strong evaluation moving us closer toward on-device deployments.
Critical weaknesses
Significance of the contribution to ICLR: The proposed approach is evaluated only for blood pressure estimation. Therefore, the paper's approach is a KAN-based physics informed framework for blood pressure estimation. This is quite narrow and as such it is not a sufficient contribution for ICLR. Moreover, framing the approach as a physiological representation learning implies more tasks, thus it is an overclaim. If the model learns cardiovascular dynamics, then it should be applicable to targets beyond blood pressure estimation
Results: (1) Many results presented Table 1 are only different by a narrow margin. It is unclear if these differences are significant or meaningful. For example, Ring-CPT Corr difference between PITN and DPIKAN is 0.01. Please provide stat. tests or CIs for these results.
Questions for authors
- DPIKAN seems like a general approach for physiological modelling. What is the rationale behind not choosing large datasets such as MIMIC-III? This could open up larger number of people and different tasks.
3 comments
Thank you again for your feedback. As the discussion period draws to a close, please let us know if you have any remaining questions. We would be happy to address them.
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. However, my concerns are unresolved: (1) framing the method as application-oriented representation learning conflates end-to-end single-task regression with transferable representation learning. If the model genuinely captures underlying cardiovascular dynamics, it should demonstrate transferability to at least one additional downstream task beyond BP estimation. (2) the predictive performance gains over PITN on the primary wearable/contactless datasets remain marginal. Accordingly, I will maintain my current score.
W1: Thank you for highlighting this distinction. We clarify our scope as follows:
DPIKAN is intended as an application-oriented representation learning framework for physiological BP sensing, rather than a task-agnostic physiological foundation model. Physiological signals contain domain-specific structures, including slow cardiovascular regulation, fast beat-level dynamics, and measurable cardiovascular descriptors. DPIKAN is designed around these properties through physiology-guided decomposition, component-specific KAN capacity, and explicit physiological regularization. BP estimation serves as the target application for evaluating whether the learned representations capture these domain-relevant structures.
W2:
For on-device physiological estimation, computational cost and inference latency are as important as predictive accuracy. Compared with PITN, DPIKAN requires approximately 1/1262 of the FLOPs and achieves a 58× inference speedup on a Raspberry Pi 4B, while maintaining competitive predictive performance. Thank you for requesting uncertainty estimates. We performed paired subject-level bootstrap analysis, treating each participant as the independent unit. We define Δr=rDPIKAN−rPITN,ΔRMSE=RMSEPITN−RMSEDPIKAN, such that positive values favor DPIKAN.
Q1: Additional evaluation on MIMIC-III
Our work targets lightweight cuffless BP estimation using wearable and contactless sensors in non-ICU settings, whereas MIMIC-III primarily contains bedside physiological recordings collected in ICUs. We therefore prioritized datasets that better match our intended sensing modalities and on-device deployment scenario.
As an additional cross-setting evaluation, we use MIMIC-BP, a curated BP-estimation dataset derived from the MIMIC-III waveform database. MIMIC-BP provides synchronized physiological waveforms and reference BP signals extracted from ICU bedside recordings, enabling direct evaluation of waveform-based BP estimation. We have clarified the relationship between MIMIC-BP and MIMIC-III in the revised manuscript. We evaluate DPIKAN on 85-subject MIMIC-BP subset using LOSO.
All errors are reported in mmHg. These results extend the evaluation to ICU PPG recordings, while our primary target remains lightweight wearable and contactless sensing.