- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a PPG pretraining technique. They use contrastive and physics-informed representation learning. The authors aim to put a prior to improve PPG representation learning. The authors used twelve baselines on eight tasks to provide evidence for their technique.
Critical strengths
The overall motivation of the paper, integrating physics to the PPG representation, is strong.
The chosen datasets are good fit to the purpose of showing and validating the claims.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments seem completely wrong. WildPPG numbers, especially R^2, are worse than mean prediction (R^2 negative?). The techniques basically do not work. The numbers are also inconsistent with the published WildPPG paper. The baselines are not new. There are couple of new baselines [1] for PPG representation learning, which perform much better.
[1] Learning Without Augmenting: Unsupervised Time Series Representation Learning via Frame Projections. NeurIPS 2025.
The presentation is not clear. The paper is very hard to follow. The figures occupy too much space. Some important details in Appendix can also be brought to main manuscript.
I think the paper has significant problems in presentation and results. The reported negative R^2 values also make the reader question about the rigor of the work.
Questions for authors
How can the R^2 reach -0.7? A simple linear probe that estimates training data mean should be 0 no? The results are also completely different from the originally published work. How do the authors explain this difference?
Hi authors, I'm looking forward to discussing the paper. If my concerns are addressed, I will reconsider my score.