- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a retain-and-extend supervision framework to learn informative PPG representations from different signal durations. In RAE-PPG, training proceeds in three stages corresponding signal durations of 10s, 30s, and 240s. Each stage focuses on learning the specific PPG feature target applicable to the duration. Subsequent stages freeze the learned parameter group and learn new targets thus preventing overwriting of useful features. RAE-PPG obtains best performance in 12/18 tasks while demonstrating the retain and extend abilities of pre-training.
Critical strengths
- Practical importance: It is widely accepted that different health abnormalities manifest at different time scales in PPG. However, most modelling approaches do not account for this. RAE-PPG directly address this gap in the learning process, as such it presents an important contribution.
- Evaluation: I commend the authors for providing confidence intervals for the results and performing statistical tests. Furthermore, experiments evaluating the RAE approach are comprehensive.
Critical weaknesses
I am willing to increase my score provided the following is adequately addressed:
-
Lack of comparison to SSL Baselines: RAE-PPG is compared to prior PPG-FMs which varying in architecture, training, size, etc. at the same time. Hence, the contribution of retain-and-extend pre-training to performance is unclear. To address this, RAE must be compared to SSL approaches such as SimCLR or TF-C using the same backbone and data used in RAE-PPG. This would demonstrate whether the performance gains stem specifically from multi-duration physiological feature supervision rather than the model architecture. I also recommend adding the parameter sizes during inference to the table.
-
Intermediate time durations: A central motivation of the paper is organizing learning around signal duration. However, the proposed architecture hardcodes duration into three static horizons (). It seems that this design cannot natively ingest signals of arbitrary or intermediate lengths (e.g., 60 s or 120 s) at inference. How does RAE PPG plan to address this in the future? The limitations or future should expand on this.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
Dear Reviewer,
As the ICLR 2027 discussion phase ends on November 18 at 11:59 PM AoE, please take a moment to review and respond to the authors' comments, even if your response is simply an acknowledgement. Your active participation in the discussion is greatly appreciated.
Thank you for your time and effort!