- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors present Physio-HNet, a model that can deal with multiple time-scales for PPG. They evaluate their model on several datasets and observe strong performances when compared to baselines.
Critical strengths
- Adapts a H-Net to PPG data.
- comprehensive experiments
- lots of details in the appendix.
Critical weaknesses
- I think framing the model as "Physiology-Aware" or more for "physiological waveforms" is a bit misleading. I believe the author only tested their method on univariate PPG data, which is very specific type of data. Specifying that this model is only good for PPG data would strengthen the paper.
- There are many instances in the paper which I think are explained in an unnecessarily complicated manner. For example in section 5.2, "Each trial starts cold, so the results do not measure uninterrupted state carry across processing windows or separate retained history from recurrent-state settling." I do not know what recurrent-state settling means, and no where in the paper mentions this term. I have to constantly make assumptions about what the author is trying to say due to inconsistencies in or overcomplicated terminology across the paper.
- I also think this paper is not well-scoped and just has too many random experiments that are not really explained well. This is especially so in the appendix. Although i appreciate a lot of details, I think that it should be at least coherent and relevant to the paper's main topics.
- No code. I think this is a big weakness as reproducibility is very important in architectural advancements like these. I would have loved to looked at the code to see how the Physio-Hnet is implemented and how different it is from the original Hnet.
Overall, I think this is a fancy neural network architecture with some nice benefits, however, due to the way it was communicated in the paper, it was not clear at all and I feel readers will have to spend lots of time to understand the main points of the work. Additionally, the motivation for all of the different components is not well conveyed as well.
Questions for authors
- For clarification, is the PPG input is purely a 1d time series (not multi-variate)? I believe this is not mentioned in the paper.
- What does lookahead mean in Figures 5 and 7?
- line 1423 seems to have an indenting problem
- There are many terms in the figures which are not properly explained in the paper. For example, what is a Temporary clinical head, Readout-level encoder, etc.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer rpMv (2/3)
W3 Scope and coherence of the experiments and appendix
Scope unclear; too many experiments, and an appendix that is not coherent.
The paper now makes one claim, and each experiment and each appendix is tied to it.
- Scope. The paper extends the context of PPG representation learning from seconds to hours. Cardiac-cycle hierarchies make hour-long input tractable, and vital-sign supervision teaches long-range regularities. The abstract, the introduction and the conclusion state this, and the title changes at camera-ready, as described in W1. Each main-text experiment tests one part of this claim.
- The context-length experiment in §5.2, Figure 3 and Table 9 tests whether the representation benefits from hours of context.
- The boundary comparison in §5.3 and Tables 3, 12 and 15 tests what cardiac-cycle supervision adds over unsupervised and fixed-stride segmentation.
- The external comparison in §5.1 and Table 1 evaluates the frozen representation before and after continued pretraining.
- The objective ablation in §5.4 and Table 4 explains the design choices.
- Appendix. The appendix is reorganized in three parts that follow the paper, namely background, method and training, and the experiments of §5.1 to §5.4. An overview links each appendix to the three contributions and the main-text sections it supports. App C argues for the design rather than testing it and is now titled as a discussion. We removed passages that were not tied to a reported result. These were the former extended discussion, the description of a decoder path that the reported experiments do not use, a repeated description of an experiment not reported here, and configuration keys copied from code.
- Terminology. As described under W2, the terms are now consistent across the paper, and App A lists them.
Every experiment and appendix now serves the one claim of the paper, and the overview table shows which part it supports.
W4 No code
No code; how does Physio-HNet differ from H-Net?
The training code is in an anonymized repository at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Physio-HNet-Opensource-328F/. It contains the encoder, self-supervised pretraining, continued pretraining with vital-sign supervision, and the configurations of the four chunking variants A1, A2, B and C. A script builds each variant and runs a forward pass without data or checkpoints, and it reports the 1.2M parameters of the deployed encoder. The full code, including evaluation, will be released with the paper. For readers who want the differences from H-Net without reading the code, Physio-HNet changes five things, each for a stated purpose.
- Supervised boundaries. H-Net learns its boundaries end to end, with only a ratio loss on the compression rate. Physio-HNet adds landmark losses that place sub-beat boundaries at the pulse foot, the systolic peak and the dicrotic notch. A cycle loss places one beat boundary per cardiac cycle (§3.2). Each unit then describes one phase of one cardiac cycle, or one cycle, instead of mixing parts of neighbouring beats as fixed patches do. §5.3 tests this by comparing A2 with B, which uses the same router without boundary-location supervision.
- Each chunk is represented by its last state. H-Net represents a chunk by the vector at its start. Physio-HNet uses the causal state at the chunk's end (§3.1). This state has processed the whole unit and can retain earlier context. It is available as soon as the unit closes, so the encoder stays causal.
- A decoder used only in training, without an encoder skip connection. In H-Net the decoder receives a residual path from the encoder and stays part of the model for autoregressive prediction. In Physio-HNet the decoder only reconstructs the waveform during training (§3.3). Without a skip connection, each unit's representation must retain the content of its unit. The decoder runs backwards in time, so each position is rebuilt from representations that encoded it. It is discarded at inference, which leaves a 1.2M-parameter causal encoder.
- Recurrent state carried through the recording. In training, the Mamba-2 blocks carry their recurrent state across consecutive windows. At inference there are no windows, and the state runs forward through the whole recording. The beat sequence is about fifteen times shorter than the token sequence, so this state can span hours. This is what lets the encoder use hour-scale context.
- Continued pretraining with vital-sign supervision. After self-supervised pretraining, a readout level whose chunks end at vital-sign measurement times is added, and routine vital signs supervise the representation (§3.4). The readout level and supervision heads are then discarded, and the encoder is evaluated frozen.
In sum, the five changes serve one goal, a small causal encoder whose units follow the cardiac cycle and whose state carries them over hours.
Response to Reviewer rpMv (3/3)
W5 Overall clarity and motivation of the components
Hard to follow, and the motivation of each component is not conveyed.
The revised introduction now states the problem behind each component. The reasoning is as follows.
- Physiological states such as blood pressure change over minutes to hours, while released PPG foundation models encode windows of 10 to 240 s in isolation. The encoder therefore carries its recurrent state forward through the recording.
- Two hours of PPG span 144,000 tokens even at 50 ms per token, so the stream must be compressed. Fixed-length patches cut across cardiac cycles, so landmark and cycle losses place the boundaries of the compressed units.
- A unit's representation should summarize the whole unit without looking ahead, so each unit is represented by the causal state at its end. §3.1 states this reason.
- The compressed units must keep the content of the waveform they replace. During pretraining, a decoder with no skip connection therefore reconstructs the waveform from them alone.
- Objectives on the waveform alone reward modelling the waveform rather than the physiological state behind it. Continued pretraining therefore adds supervision from routine vital signs.
The three contributions follow the same reasoning, namely cardiac-cycle chunking, long-context modelling with recurrent state, and continued pretraining with vital-sign supervision. Each is tied to the experiment that tests it, as listed in W3. W4 compares the components with H-Net, and W2 describes the terminology revision.
Each component now appears in the paper as the answer to a stated problem.
Q1 Is the PPG input univariate?
Is the PPG input univariate?
Yes. The encoder takes a single PPG channel sampled at 40 Hz, a univariate time series, in both training stages and in every evaluation. §3.1 now states this explicitly.
Other physiological measurements enter training only as labels. In continued pretraining, each training window holds up to two hours of one patient's PPG (§3.4). Heart rate, respiratory rate, oxygen saturation and blood pressure supervise the representation each time they are measured within the window. This longitudinal vital-sign supervision follows the patient's physiological state as it changes over the two hours. The measurements are never inputs to the encoder. The purpose is to learn more from PPG itself. PPG reflects cardiovascular, autonomic and respiratory state only indirectly, and these labels teach the encoder which of that information to read from the waveform. If the measurements were inputs, the model could use them directly and would not need to learn this from PPG.
Q2 "lookahead" in Figures 5 and 7
What does "lookahead" mean in Figures 5 and 7?
It labels A1, a control in the boundary comparison (§5.3). App G.1 defines A1 in the paragraph "Convolutional router (A1)" and in Eq. (25). A1 places boundaries with a convolutional router whose kernel spans 15 tokens centred on the current position. Each boundary decision therefore also sees the next 7 tokens, or 350 ms, of signal. "Lookahead" referred to this. "BCE" referred to A1's per-token binary cross-entropy loss against detected landmarks, which the same paragraph states. The revised figures label it "A1", the code that App A and App G.1 define, and Figure 9 changes in the same way.
Q3 Indentation at line 1423
Indentation problem at line 1423.
The paragraph break before "Cohort and preprocessing" in App D.4 is restored in the revision.
Q4 Terms in the figures
Terms in the figures not explained, e.g. "Temporary clinical head", "Readout-level encoder".
We checked every label in Figures 1 to 12 against the text. The revised figures use the terms that the text defines and App A lists. For the two examples:
- The "readout-level encoder" is now the "readout encoder" (§3.4). It is added in continued pretraining. It processes the beat embeddings and divides them into chunks that end at the times the vital signs are measured. Each chunk is represented by the last beat-level state at or before its measurement time, so no later waveform is used.
- The "temporary clinical head" is now the "supervision heads". They estimate the vital signs at each measurement time during continued pretraining. They and the readout encoder are discarded afterwards, so only the encoder is evaluated.
Response to Reviewer rpMv (1/3)
Summary
We thank the reviewer for the careful review and the concrete examples. Following these comments, the revision improves the presentation. The method, data and existing results are unchanged. New results are marked as new, and new or revised text is shown in green.
In sum, the revision keeps the content and makes the paper easier to read, with one claim, one term per concept and code to check the implementation.
W1 Framing as "physiology-aware" / "physiological waveforms"
We take the reviewer's suggestion and state that the model is for PPG. Every experiment uses univariate PPG. The revised abstract and introduction state the PPG scope in their first sentences. At camera-ready the title becomes "Physio-HNet: Physiologically Guided Hierarchical Representation Learning for Long-Context Photoplethysmography".
The new title says "physiologically guided" because physiological knowledge supervises the model at two scales. Waveform landmarks and the cardiac cycle guide its segmentation, and routine vital signs supervise its representation along each recording. The revised Related Work states this in §2.
W2 Overcomplicated explanations and inconsistent terminology
"Settling" referred to the recurrent state moving away from its zero start as the input is read. The revision removes the term and rewrites the sentence.
The sentence describes the context-length experiment. Each input starts with the recurrent state set to zero, so that it contains exactly its stated context length. This is a control of the experiment. At inference there are no windows, and the state runs forward from the start of the encounter (§3.1). §5.2 now says this directly.
Beyond this sentence, we revised the terminology of the whole paper, including the appendices. App A is now a table of the terms used in the paper, and §3 points to it. The figure labels follow the same terms, as described in Q4.