- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TimeSWARM, a mixture-of-experts framework for multivariate time series classification. Each channel is split into local patches, and a temporal-spectral router assigns each channel-patch to multi-scale experts; the same dense routing distribution is reused as a soft latent-group assignment for cross-channel interaction. This couples local representation specialization with relational modeling without a separate graph or clustering module, and yields the best average accuracy and rank on the UEA archive.
Critical strengths
-
Reusing MoE routing as the relational structure is clean: it couples local specialization with cross-channel interaction without a separate graph or clustering module, and yields a provably low-rank, symmetric, row-stochastic channel relation (Section 3.3).
-
Evaluation is broad and strong: full UEA-30 plus UEA-10/UEA-25 subsets and UCI-HAR, with the best average accuracy, average rank, and most top-1 results, backed by pairwise Wilcoxon tests.
-
The ablation cleanly isolates the three components; removing any one degrades accuracy on both UEA-30 and UEA-10.
-
The appendix analysis goes beyond headline accuracy with routing visualization, expert-utilization diversity, and dense-routing versus induced-relational structure.
Critical weaknesses
-
No comparison against the MoE-based MTSC methods it cites (AnchorMoE, TVSRNet); the Table 1 baseline set is largely inherited from SGN.
-
The efficiency motivation is undercut: all experts are evaluated for every channel-patch, sparsification affects only aggregation, and no parameter counts, runtime, or memory are reported.
-
Per-dataset grid search (patch period, kernels, MoE layers, overlap, differencing) with best test performance from a single seed makes the modest margins hard to assess; no variance across seeds is reported on UEA.
-
The relational step is low-rank soft group averaging, conceptually close to existing channel-grouping and factorized message passing, so the core novelty is incremental.
Questions for authors
-
Please add AnchorMoE and TVSRNet (the cited MoE-based MTSC methods) as baselines, or justify their omission.
-
Please report parameter counts, training/inference time, and peak memory on representative datasets.
-
Please report mean and standard deviation over multiple seeds on UEA and clarify whether the test split is used for hyperparameter or model selection.
-
Please add an ablation replacing the routing-induced relation with a learned or fixed channel graph to show the routing coupling specifically helps.
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and clarifications. Most of my concerns have been adequately addressed. I will maintain my original rating.
Thank you very much for your response and consideration! We sincerely appreciate your constructive feedback and are glad that your concerns have been addressed.
Review Reminder
Dear Reviewer gofd,
We sincerely thank you again for your constructive feedback and for recognizing the potential strengths of our proposed shared expert-induced relational modeling mechanism.
Following your valuable suggestions, we have conducted several additional experiments, including comparisons with recent MoE-based methods, computational efficiency analyses, multi-seed evaluations, and controlled architectural ablations to further validate our core methodological contribution.
As the discussion period ends in less than 24 hours, we hope you will have an opportunity to review our additional results and the corresponding revisions. We greatly appreciate your encouraging assessment of our work and hope that the new experimental evidence further strengthens your confidence in our proposed method.
Thank you once again for your time, consideration, and valuable support.
Best regards,
The Authors