- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
TimeCED proposes a multivariate time-series classifier that separates sequence-level representation learning from local candidate selection. It defines a candidate's contribution as the change in classification loss when that candidate's learned embedding is removed, approximates this effect with a first-order Taylor expansion, aggregates scores over samples and discovery epochs, and reuses high-scoring channel-temporal candidates for subsequent training. On 30 UEA datasets, the reported mean accuracy is 0.744 versus 0.718 for MiniROCKET in the paper's comparison table. Removing the whole candidate pathway lowers the mean by 3.60 percentage points. A Top-100 versus random/bottom selection comparison on eleven eligible datasets yields means of 0.659, 0.633, and 0.625. The Taylor scores agree closely with exact removal of the same learned embeddings, with mean Spearman correlation 0.9954 across those eleven datasets.
Critical strengths
S1. The paper addresses the potential loss of local discriminative information during global temporal aggregation by explicitly identifying channel-temporal regions that contribute to the classification objective. The two-pathway design is conceptually coherent, and the contribution-based selection mechanism provides a more direct connection to the classification loss than purely attention-based importance weighting. The distinction between global sequence modeling and local evidence discovery is a meaningful design choice.
S2. The authors evaluate all 30 UEA datasets and provide relevant structural ablations. The evidence-selection experiments show that top-ranked candidates outperform random and bottom-ranked candidates by 2.6 and 3.4 percentage points, respectively, on the evaluated subset. The Taylor approximation is also validated against exact candidate removal, achieving an average Spearman correlation of 0.9954 and a Top-100 overlap of 97.7%. These results provide credible evidence that the approximation faithfully reproduces the proposed removal-based ranking and that the resulting ranking is useful for classification.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The paper shows that the Taylor approximation is accurate, but it does not adequately compare the proposed score with other importance measures, such as gradient-based scores or absolute contribution values. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the proposed scoring method is responsible for the performance improvements.
W2. TimeCED selects the same important channel-temporal locations for all samples. However, different classes or samples may contain discriminative patterns at different time positions. The paper does not investigate whether this shared selection strategy remains effective in such cases. Additional analysis of computational overhead would also strengthen the evaluation.
Questions for authors
Q1. Have the authors evaluated gradient-based scores, absolute contribution values, or removal-based importance scores under the same Top-M selection budget? Such results would help establish the advantage of the proposed scoring method.
Q2. How does it compare with simpler importance scores under the same architecture and selection budget? Additionally, does the Top-100 selection strategy consistently outperform random selection on the remaining 19 UEA datasets? These results would help determine whether the proposed scoring mechanism is responsible for the reported improvements.