- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CardioPRF separates conditional cardiovascular-signal generation into a deterministic prediction and a stochastic residual. Global and local conditioning pathways produce a target-specific anchor; conditional flow matching models the remaining latent variation. Their sum is decoded into the target waveform. The experiments compare this formulation with deterministic-only and direct-flow alternatives and examine reconstruction, distributional fidelity, and external downstream utility.
Critical strengths
Separating observation-predictable structure from remaining conditional variation is a clear and useful formulation of an underdetermined generation problem. The anchor–residual construction is straightforward to understand, and the complementary global/local conditions fit the structure of cardiovascular waveforms. The experiments make the trade-off between paired reconstruction and distributional fidelity visible instead of suggesting that a single metric captures all aspects of generation. The anchor-only and direct-flow comparisons are particularly informative, and the external downstream evaluations add useful context to the main results.
The formulation and empirical findings make a positive overall case for weak acceptance.
Critical weaknesses
The evidence would be easier to interpret with a sharper distinction between two pairs of claims:
- Better distributional fidelity versus conditional or patient-specific correctness.
- Architectural support for nine tasks versus the settings highlighted in the main tables.
These are primarily clarification and presentation issues in my assessment, rather than reasons to reject the paper.
Questions for authors
On the evaluation metrics, please specify the number of generated samples per input, how MAE is aggregated, and whether the same sampling budget is used for Min-MAE across methods. It would also help to give the precise feature space and implementation used for the reported Fréchet distance.
On task coverage, the framework supports nine directed tasks, whereas the main comparisons emphasize a subset. Could you make clear which tasks were evaluated in each table and where results for the remaining settings can be found?
Finally, on interpreting the findings, please distinguish the evidence that residual generation improves distributional fidelity from evidence about conditional physiological correctness. In particular, explain which current analyses support the hypothesis that additional observed modalities reduce unresolved variation, and frame the external downstream results within their demonstrated scope.
2 comments
Response to Reviewer xaHe (Part 2/2)
3. Conditional physiological consistency and complementary observations
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion to distinguish waveform-distribution fidelity from conditional physiological consistency.
To complement the raw FD comparisons, we introduced a cardiac-rhythm consistency analysis for PPG→ECG generation (Section 4.4, Table 5; Appendix F). Using the same PPG observations and paired ECG references, we compare anchor-only prediction, direct flow, and anchor–residual generation in terms of cardiac-period agreement and R-peak matching.
Anchor–residual flow achieves the lowest cardiac-period errors relative to both the observed PPG (54.93 ms) and recorded ECG (60.37 ms), together with the highest R-peak micro-F1 (0.566). These results provide additional evidence that the generated ECG preserves timing information associated with its conditioning observations, complementing the distributional improvements.
Regarding additional observed modalities, the revised Table 2 shows that adding ABP to PPG reduces ECG MAE from 0.31 to 0.29, while adding ECG to PPG reduces ABP MAE from 0.60 to 0.58. These improvements indicate that complementary observations contribute useful predictive information within the shared generation framework.
We have further expanded the downstream evidence through a frozen BP-regressor experiment (Section 4.5, Table 6; Appendix H). Following the prior-work downstream evaluation protocol, five generated ECG realizations are averaged for each PPG input and supplied to the fixed predictor in place of recorded ECG. CardioPRF achieves BP estimation errors close to those obtained with recorded ECG on external Cuffless BP, providing additional evidence of downstream utility. The original external WESAD evaluation is retained in Appendix G.
The revised manuscript now more clearly connects the complete nine-task formulation, distributional fidelity, and rhythm-level physiological evidence to the corresponding empirical claims. We thank the reviewer again for the constructive suggestions and positive assessment.
Response to Reviewer xaHe (Part 1/2)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the encouraging assessment and for recognizing the motivation behind predictable–residual factorization and the complementary global/local conditioning pathways. We appreciate the suggestions concerning evaluation transparency, complete task coverage, and the interpretation of conditional generation. We have addressed these points through revised metric definitions, expanded nine-task results, and additional experiments examining cardiac-rhythm consistency and inference stability.
1. Clarification of evaluation metrics and sampling procedures
We have revised Section 4.1 and expanded Appendix D to specify the evaluation metrics and sampling protocol.
For the main waveform-generation experiments, each conditioning window produces one generated realization. Standard MAE measures the direct paired waveform error, whereas Min-MAE uses bounded temporal alignment within ±1 second, following the shift-tolerant evaluation in UniCardio. The error is computed over the valid overlapping region, and the minimum across integer temporal shifts is selected for each window. Consequently, Min-MAE measures tolerance to temporal displacement rather than selecting the best of multiple stochastic samples. The same procedure applies to deterministic and stochastic models.
KS is computed from per-window empirical amplitude distributions and averaged across windows. Raw FD is calculated directly from the means and covariance matrices of the generated and recorded 512-dimensional waveform vectors, without using a pretrained feature extractor. These definitions and aggregation procedures are provided explicitly in Appendix D (Eqs. 11–15).
To further examine sampling stability, we have added five-seed inference evaluations with fixed model checkpoints (Appendix E, Tables 10–11). Each seed produces a separate full-test-set evaluation, and we report the mean and sample standard deviation of the resulting metrics. This analysis characterizes the consistency of the reported results across inference-noise realizations.
2. Complete results for all nine directed generation tasks
We agree that the original submission did not sufficiently distinguish the framework's nine-task capability from the representative tasks emphasized in the main comparisons.
The revised manuscript now explicitly reports results for all six single-observation and three dual-observation generation tasks. Appendix E provides the unified CardioPRF model's complete results (Table 7), global/local conditioning ablations (Table 8), and comparisons among anchor-only prediction, direct flow, and anchor–residual generation (Table 9).
Furthermore, Tables 10–11 extend the anchor–residual versus direct-flow comparison to all nine tasks under five inference seeds. Anchor–residual flow achieves lower mean raw FD in every task, while maintaining competitive paired reconstruction accuracy. This extends the evidence for the proposed formulation beyond the representative ECG and ABP settings in the main text.
We have also clarified the distinction between the unified nine-task CardioPRF model, the task-specific CardioPRF-F variant, and CardioPRF-M, which uses two observed modalities with the same unified model. The main comparisons remain focused on settings with established external baselines, while the appendix documents the complete task coverage and corresponding ablations.