- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces AneumoBench, a dataset that links 401 real aneurysm geometries to 9,693 locally edited variants, with steady velocity–pressure simulations and transient wall shear stress sequences for each. Using splits that hold out whole source families, the authors compare training on sources, on variants, and on variants followed by source fine-tuning across nine architectures, and study how many variants to use and how to spread them across sources.
Critical strengths
-
Large new transient dataset covering full cardiac cycles, backed by substantial simulation effort.
-
Careful protocol: whole source families are held out, and every test geometry counts equally.
-
Honest reporting of negative results and data issues.
Critical weaknesses
-
The reference models barely outperform a trivial baseline on the steady task. The paper notes that predicting zero velocity gives a RelL2 of about 1, yet source-only velocity errors range from 0.83 to 1.02, and some recipes exceed 1 (e.g., F-FNO R2 velocity, FNO R1 pressure). In addition, all reported steady results include about 6% zero-valued placeholder points inside the fluid domain, and only six GraphSAGE checkpoints were re-evaluated without them. This makes the R1–R3 comparisons difficult to interpret.
-
Several of the main conclusions are confounded or do not hold up. R3 receives extra fine-tuning beyond R2, and the paper notes that sample and update counts differ across recipes, so only the GraphSAGE controls compare at matched compute. The allocation preference reverses for Transolver on airfoils. In WSS rollout, both Transolver and U-Net perform worse than simple persistence, and a geometry-free PointwiseMLP outperforms all geometry-aware models.
-
The descendants differ structurally from the source aneurysms. Each one is made by removing the original aneurysm and displacing a surface patch outward by only 0.5–1.0 mm, so the resulting geometries look more like vessels with small bulges than like edited aneurysms. This weakens the paper's framing of aneurysm CFD transfer and raises the question of whether the observed gains come from learning general vessel flow rather than aneurysm hemodynamics. The editing is also operator-guided in Geomagic, which makes the construction hard to reproduce or extend, and 60 descendant records are exact duplicates.
I suggest the authors to report results with the corrected point domain and physical coordinates for all models, compare recipes at matched compute, and strengthen the baselines so that they clearly outperform trivial predictors before drawing conclusions about the value of the variants.
Questions for authors
Please see the Weaknesses section.