- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DeAL targets sampling-distribution sensitivity in geometry-to-field surrogates: predictions can change when the same physical case is supplied through a different surface sampling or remesh. A coordinate-only kernel concentration score defines a continuous inverse-density family; paired fixed-budget views with independently drawn strengths are supervised at common queries, and a symmetric stop-gradient Smooth- term penalizes their disagreement; the backbone and single-view inference are unchanged. Across diverse backbones and CFD, heat-exchange, and magnetostatic systems, DeAL lowers error and prediction disagreement relative to matched single-view training under held-out spatial redistributions and remeshes.
Critical strengths
-
Consistent matched gains in accuracy and stability. The single-view Base degrades under held-out shifts in every task–architecture pair, and DeAL lowers both error and direct prediction disagreement in every pair (Sec. 6.1; Table 6; App. E, Table 8), with remesh geometry audited (App. I), paired intervals for SMART (Table 14), and seed replication on a subset (App. H).
-
Drop-in design with matched component ablations. DeAL changes only view construction and the loss (Eqs. (6)–(10); Algorithm 1), needs no density computation at inference, and matches Base in total supervised-view passes rather than optimizer updates (Sec. 5.1; App. C). With SMART, prediction consistency improves on density-varied supervision alone, and continuous density draws outperform fixed-intensity and endpoint pairs (Sec. 6.3; Fig. 4; App. Fig. 7).
Critical weaknesses
-
DeAL's advantage over other view generators rests on a narrow comparison. Downsampling and masking controls are compared across systems but only with SMART (Sec. 6.2; Table 9), as are all other ablations in App. F. Each control is run at one fixed strength (App. A), with masks removing only a small fraction of points in the illustrated example (Fig. 20), whereas DeAL's preselected settings receive a sensitivity analysis (Table 11). Although Sec. 6.2 limits its conclusion to the tested controls, Sec. 7 draws a broader implication about view construction, which Sec. 4 presents as DeAL's defining difference from consistency-based training.
-
Practical value relative to simple resampling preprocessing is not established. Remeshing motivates the work (Sec. 1), and Sec. 2.2 contrasts density-biased inputs with area-uniform sampling; yet Base trains on source-uniform selections, remeshed inputs are drawn uniformly from vertices (App. A; App. D), and no single-view baseline resamples inputs to reduce density bias in both training and inference (e.g., area-uniform resampling of each surface mesh, or, for point clouds, fixed- inverse-density resampling via Eqs. (6)–(7)). Such a baseline is needed to establish DeAL's incremental practical value over simpler preprocessing in the re-meshing workflows targeted in Sec. 7.
Questions for authors
-
(Related to W1; suggested experiment.) How sensitive is Table 9 to control strength (App. A), and how do the downsampling and masking controls compare with DeAL for an already evaluated backbone with different aggregation (e.g., hierarchical PointNet++ SSG or radius-graph PointGNN; Sec. 5.1)?
-
(Related to W2; suggested experiment.) On the existing remesh conditions (Sec. 5.2), how does DeAL compare with a single-view Base trained and evaluated on area-uniform samples of the native and remeshed surfaces (e.g., for SMART)?
If any part of this review reflects a misunderstanding of the paper, I would appreciate the authors pointing it out, and I am happy to revise my assessment accordingly.
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. The SMART baseline using FPS at both training and inference directly addresses my request for a common-preprocessing comparison, and DeAL achieves lower mean errors across the reported sampling-shift conditions. The recomputed C-core fields and broader augmentation controls also strengthen the evidence for the reported robustness gains.
I still regard the methodological contribution as incremental. The practical benefit also remains less directly established: the rebuttal explains why geometry preparation may differ between training and deployment, but does not directly measure DeAL’s benefit in an actual design workflow with those differing input preparations. Thus, the experiments demonstrate improved robustness, while the magnitude of the benefit in actual engineering use remains uncertain.
Nevertheless, the additional results meaningfully address my original concerns. Together with the breadth of the evaluation across architectures and physical systems, they provide a sufficiently strong empirical contribution for weak acceptance. I therefore raise my rating from 2 to 3 (weak acceptance), while retaining the above reservations about methodological novelty and practical validation.