- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents CANTO, a neural operator that takes CAD geometry directly in NURBS form instead of a mesh or point cloud. Trimmed CAD surfaces are first converted into untrimmed patches. Each patch is encoded into a token from its control points, weights and knot vectors. These tokens condition an AB-UPT-style transformer that predicts surface and volume fields at arbitrary query points. The paper also introduces a framework that views the surrogate as a map from boundary patch parametrizations to solution fields. On four automotive and aircraft aerodynamics datasets, CANTO improves over AB-UPT on most fields, with notable gains on HiLiftAeroML. An inverse design study on AhmedML finds lower-drag designs, which are then verified with CFD.
Critical strengths
-
Feeding the native CAD representation into a neural operator is a fresh and well-motivated idea. The paper also shows that it scales to industrial geometries with tens of thousands of patches.
-
The results are strong on difficult datasets, for example about 20% lower surface-pressure error than AB-UPT on HiLiftAeroML. I also liked that the inverse-design results are checked by re-running the original CFD setup, where the surrogate is within about 2% of the simulations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The claim of avoiding meshing is overstated. Volume anchors are still sampled from the CFD volume mesh, and since the surface branch attends to the volume branch, even surface predictions depend on mesh points. The paper does not explain where these anchors come from for a new design, for instance during inverse design. Untrimming is not free either, taking around 45 minutes per DrivAerML car.
-
It is unclear where the gains come from. AhmedML, WindsorML and HiLiftAeroML have only six to eight design parameters, so a baseline conditioned on the design parameters is needed. This is all the more relevant because, on AhmedML, a plain MLP on fixed-size NURBS features already matches the Perceiver encoder on the surface fields (Table 2). CANTO also replaces AB-UPT's sampled surface anchors with NURBS-derived surface tokens. Part of the gain may therefore come from a different surface context rather than from the geometry encoder, and the number of these tokens is not reported.
Questions for authors
- Where do the volume anchors come from for a new geometry without a CFD mesh, for example in the inverse-design loop?
- How many surface tokens does CANTO use compared with AB-UPT's anchors, and how does AB-UPT perform with a matched context size?
- How does a baseline conditioned on the design parameters perform?
- Was AB-UPT retrained with NURBS-based sampling in Fig. 2? If not, its large error there may reflect a train/test mismatch.
5 comments
R: Q4
AB-UPT was not retrained with the alternative sampling strategy used in Figure 2. The experiment measures the sensitivity of its trained predictions to changing the surface-anchor distribution at inference, so its degradation can include train/test sampling mismatch.
The result identifies a practical distinction: CANTO constructs its surface tokens directly from NURBS, so changing the distribution of sampled surface points does not change its surface-context construction. We will clarify the scope of this experiment in the caption.
The complementary experiment reported by the AB-UPT authors in [1], Table 5, Section 4.6, trains with CAD-sampled surface inputs and randomly sampled volume anchors. The model trained with this alternative sampling strategy remained less accurate than the CFD-mesh-sampled model. Thus, in that study, the accuracy difference persisted with consistent training and inference sampling. The authors explain that CFD-mesh sampling concentrates anchors in highly resolved regions, which typically contain more complex flow features.
Because both surface and volume sampling change, that experiment does not isolate surface sampling alone. It nevertheless demonstrates the feasibility of inference without CFD-mesh-derived anchors, complementing our experiment on inference-time surface-sampling sensitivity.
[1] Alkin, Benedikt, et al. "AB-UPT: Scaling neural CFD surrogates for high-fidelity automotive aerodynamics simulations via anchored-branched universal physics transformers." arXiv preprint arXiv:2502.09692 (2025).
The anchor construction is now clear. The inverse-design loop avoids remeshing each candidate by deforming anchors from a reference CFD mesh. I would scope the meshing claim accordingly and describe Figure 2 as a test of inference-time sampling sensitivity.
The trimmed DrivAerML result with fewer training tokens is encouraging. A matched-context AB-UPT comparison would help isolate the contribution of CAD encoding, and a design-parameter baseline would test its added value within the prescribed shape families. Since these comparisons remain open, I am keeping my rating at 2.
R: W1, Q1
We thank the reviewer for this helpful question, which highlighted an omission in Annex E. We will revise the annex to clarify how volume anchors are obtained for new geometries without a CFD mesh within the inverse-design loop.
For the AhmedML inverse-design experiments, no new CFD mesh was generated for each candidate. We deformed 16,384 anchor points selected uniformly from run 420’s CFD volume mesh, the dataset design closest to the centre of the parameter box. We computed displacements at 3,328 corresponding NURBS surface points, then transferred that motion into the volume: P(x)=Pref+b⊙[W(S(x)−S(xref))].
Here, Pref contains the reference volume points, and S(x)−S(xref) gives the displacement of each surface point.
W is a fixed 16,384 × 3,328 interpolation matrix: each row corresponds to one volume point, and each column corresponds to one surface point. Each row contains nonzero weights only for the 64 surface points closest to that volume point in the reference geometry. These weights are proportional to the inverse squared distance and normalized to sum to one, so closer surface points contribute more strongly. Multiplying the surface displacements by W therefore assigns each volume point a weighted average of nearby surface motion.
The factor b smoothly fades this motion from full displacement within 0.15 m of the reference body to zero at 1 m, keeping the tunnel and far field fixed. The symbol ⊙ denotes elementwise multiplication.
Thus, the inverse-design loop avoids per-candidate meshing by using a fixed reference point cloud. The new trimmed variant further eliminates the need for untrimming and its associated preprocessing cost. In response to the reviewer’s feedback, we are currently investigating two alternative anchor sampling strategies: one based on the SDF, and another that follows the sampling procedure used during meshing but generates anchor points independently of the mesh itself. These strategies will allow us to evaluate performance without mesh-derived volume anchors.
R: W2, Q2
The surface context contains one token per NURBS anchor patch. The table below reports training and evaluation counts for both CANTO variants and the AB-UPT models used in the comparisons. We will include these counts in the manuscript.
The trimmed DrivAerML model retains approximately 8.5k surface tokens during training, compared with AB-UPT’s 16,384 surface anchors, while reducing pressure, velocity, and wall-shear errors from 3.82/5.93/7.29 to 3.78/5.28/7.06. It also uses fewer surface tokens than untrimmed CANTO, which retains approximately 35k during training. These results show that the trimmed model’s gains over AB-UPT do not require a larger training surface context.
The original untrimmed DrivAerML model uses a larger training surface context. The comparisons above are not a matched-context training ablation and do not separately quantify the effects of anchor count and CAD encoding. We will make the counts and scope of these comparisons explicit.
R: Q3
Our objective is to learn a mapping from CAD geometry to solution fields, with the longer-term aim of generalizing to novel shapes as the diversity of training data increases. Conditioning on design parameters addresses prediction within a prescribed shape family, whose scope is determined by the chosen parameterization. By operating directly on NURBS representations, CANTO provides a common geometric input format across different design families.