- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
TacFRS adds high-frequency tactile correction to frozen flow-based VLA policies. It uses flow reversal to convert VLA action chunks into structured noise, then decodes them with a tactile-conditioned revision network. Tactile-gated supervision is used to preserve base-policy behavior when correction is unnecessary. Experiments on four real-robot tasks with π0.5 and SmolVLA show consistent improvements, supported by several ablations.
Critical strengths
- The slow-fast design is practical: it adds high-frequency tactile feedback without modifying the pretrained VLA.
- The real-robot results are consistent across two backbones, and the ablations support the main design choices.
Critical weaknesses
- The structured-noise comparison is not fully convincing. The direct correction baseline is quite weak, and stronger baselines with visual or VLA features would better isolate the benefit of flow reversal.
- Evaluation is limited to four tasks, one robot setup, and 20 trials per setting.
Questions for authors
- Have you compared against a stronger direct revision baseline using visual or intermediate VLA features?
- Are the tactile revision modules trained separately for each task, or can one model handle multiple tasks?
Response to Reviewer NM2D
Thank you for your constructive feedback and for recognizing the practicality of TacFRS’s slow–fast design and the consistency of our real-robot results across two VLA backbones.
1. Comparison with a direct action refinement baseline that uses visual features
Following your suggestion, we adapted VLA-Touch to use the same fine-tuned π₀.₅ backbone as TacFRS and trained its refinement module with the same number of demonstrations per task (300). The VLA-Touch refinement module conditions on independently extracted DINOv2 RGB features, robot proprioception, and tactile features. Implementation and training details are provided in Appendix D.2, in the VLA-Touch paragraph and Table 12 (p. 27).
We evaluated both methods on all four tasks, with 20 real-robot trials per method per task. The full results are reported in Section 5.2.1 and Figure 5 (p. 7), and the stage-wise success rates are reported in Appendix B.1, Tables 4–7 (pp. 18–19).
TacFRS achieved a higher observed success rate on all four tasks, with a mean advantage of 11.25 percentage points.
This comparison measures the overall performance of the two methods. To further examine the role of structured noise obtained through flow reversal, we also evaluated a baseline with the same flow-matching revision network architecture in the structured noise ablation in Section 5.2.4 (pp. 9–10). This baseline initializes the flow from random noise and conditions it on VLA-predicted actions. It achieved success rates of 25% on Insert Tube and 5% on Pick Two Tubes, compared with 90% and 65% for TacFRS, respectively. These results support the use of structured noise obtained through flow reversal in our revision architecture.
2. Can a single tactile revision module serve multiple tasks?
The original experiments used a separately trained tactile revision module for each task. To test whether one module could serve multiple tasks, we jointly trained a shared module on 1,200 demonstrations from all four tasks, with 300 per task, matching the per-task count in the original experiments. Each task retained its own frozen π₀.₅ policy and used the same tactile revision module weights. The shared module uses a common 20-dimensional bimanual action representation and masks the action dimensions and tactile inputs of the inactive arm on single-arm tasks.
We evaluated the same jointly trained checkpoint on all four tasks, with 20 real-robot trials per task. The training setup and results are described in Section 5.2.2 (pp. 7–8), with the full comparison in Table 2 (p. 8).
The same tactile revision module could be used across all four evaluated tasks. Its mean success rate was 55.00%, 1.25 percentage points above the frozen π₀.₅ policies and below the 67.50% achieved by task-specific training. We discuss this result in Section 5.2.2 of the revised manuscript.
3. Number of real-robot trials and evaluation across robot embodiments
We agree that the evaluation scope is limited. Our real-robot experiments cover four tasks on a single robot platform, with 20 trials per method per task (Section 5.1, pp. 6–7). Given the time available during the rebuttal period, we focused our additional experiments on the VLA-Touch comparison and the evaluation of the shared tactile revision module. We were unable to increase the number of trials per setting or run experiments on additional robot embodiments within that period. Our conclusions are based on the platform and tasks evaluated here. Transfer across robot embodiments remains to be tested, as discussed in the Limitations paragraph in Section 6 (p. 10).