acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TouchWorld: A Predictive and Reactive Tactile Foundation Model for Dexterous Manipulation

Abstract

Dexterous manipulation in everyday environments requires both anticipation and reaction: a robot must predict how contact should evolve while rapidly correcting local errors caused by slip, misalignment, unstable grasping, or force mismatch. Vision and language provide semantic and geometric guidance, but they cannot reliably reveal hidden contact states such as force, slip, and contact stability. Although tactile sensing exposes these physical cues, most existing policies treat touch as a low-frequency observation stream within a monolithic action model, coupling slow task reasoning, action generation, and fast contact feedback in a single loop. We introduce TouchWorld, a predictive-and-reactive tactile foundation model for dexterous manipulation. TouchWorld uses a hierarchical policy that separates vision-language subtask planning, tactile world-model prediction, visuo-tactile goal-conditioned action generation, and high-frequency tactile residual refinement. A High-Level Planning Layer produces executable subtasks and predicts tactile subgoals; a Visuo-Tactile Goal-Conditioned Policy generates nominal action chunks; and a Tactile-Conditioned Refinement Policy performs online residual correction using recent tactile and proprioceptive feedback. By using touch as both a predictive contact reference and a fast feedback signal, TouchWorld preserves the semantic generalization of vision-language-action policies while improving local contact adaptation. Across six long-horizon and contact-rich dexterous manipulation tasks, TouchWorld achieves 65.0% success in the clean setting and 53.7% success under human perturbations, outperforming the strongest baseline by 15.7 and 18.5 percentage points, respectively.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Dexterous Manipulation, Tactile Sensing, Tactile Foundation Models, Tactile World Models, Visuo-Tactile Learning, Vision-Language-Action Models, Robot Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_BCLpOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents TouchWorld, a hierarchical system for tactile dexterous manipulation that separates task-level reasoning from fast contact correction. At the highest-level, a subtask planner selects the current subtask and a tactile world model predicts a visual-tactile subgoal for it. A goal-conditioned VLA then generates action chunks from these goals and current observations. Finally, a Tactile Residual Transformer refines those chunks at a higher rate using recent tactile and proprioceptive history. On six real-robot tasks, TouchWorld achieves the highest task success rates.

Critical strengths
  • The motivation is clear and relevant. A hierarchical system that separates high-level task planning and goal prediction from reactive contact correction addresses a real need in dexterous manipulation, where tasks require both reasoning about the intended contact outcome and responding quickly when actual contact deviates from it
  • The evaluation is done on a real robot with a reasonable number of trials and task coverage
  • The paper is overall well-written and easy to follow
Critical weaknesses

1. Baseline comparison

The paper argues that monolithic visuo-tactile policies are limited, but there is no monolithic baseline that shares TouchWorld’s backbone and training data. FTP-1 is the closest comparison, but it differs in several ways at once. The paper does not describe how the baselines were trained, for example whether they used the same 200 trajectories per task. Because of this, it’s hard to tell how much of the gain in Table 1 comes from the architecture and how much from the additional data and labels.

2. Tactile representation and human-to-robot transfer

I couldn’t find a concrete description of how human and robot tactile signals are represented as images; the text says only that they are “rendered or normalized into images.” The figures give some hints, but the tactile in Fig. 2 (hand-shaped maps) and Fig. 6 (patch grids) looks quite different. Since both the world model and the VLA operate on this representation, a clear description seems necessary.

Relatedly, it’s unclear how this image representation carries over between human and robot hands, which have different sensor layouts. Some explanation of how the two are aligned would help. Sec. 2.4 also states that pretraining "transfers human contact priors," but I didn’t find an experiment supporting this, such as a world model trained on robot data only.

3. Ablation design and TRT training

According to Appendix B.5, the planner ablation reuses checkpoints without retraining. The VLA was trained with subtask text and subtask-level goals but receives task-only inputs in this ablation, so part of the drop may come from the input mismatch rather than the loss of planning. The same question applies to the world-model ablation. It would help to clarify which variants were retrained, or to retrain them.

The TRT’s residual targets are computed on states from the teleoperation demos. At deployment, it operates on states the robot reaches itself, which may differ from the demos, particularly under perturbations, which is where it’s meant to help. Was any on-policy or perturbation data used during training? If not, some discussion of where the perturbation gains come from would be useful.

4. Evaluation protocol

The paper doesn’t give per-task success criteria. The human perturbations are listed by type, but their strength, timing, and consistency across methods aren’t described. No confidence intervals are reported. With 100 rollouts per task, some of the smaller differences, such as the 2.5-point world-model gap under perturbations, may be within noise. A written protocol and confidence intervals would make the results easier to trust.

Questions for authors
  • Which model is the nominal policy’s vision-language backbone, and what was it pretrained on? The paper describes it only as "a vision-language backbone and a diffusion Transformer action expert." Knowing this would help reproducibility and the interpretation of results.
  • How were the baselines trained? Did they use the same 200 trajectories per task and a comparable fine-tuning budget, and did any of them have access to subtask annotations, or access to the EgoTrack dataset?
  • How exactly are the human and robot tactile signals rendered into images, and how are they aligned given the different hand and sensor layouts? Which representation do Fig. 2 and Fig. 6 show?
7 comments

Part 1/5: Overview; backbone and baseline training (W1 / Q1 / Q2)

Dear Reviewer BCLp,

Thank you for recognizing that the motivation is clear and relevant, that the evaluation is done on a real robot with a reasonable number of trials and task coverage, and that the paper is well written. Thank you also for the careful and specific comments. We first summarize our answer to each point and then respond in detail.

Overview

  • W1 / Q1 / Q2, baselines and backbone: the nominal policy is initialized from π0.5 weights, and all baselines use the same data and training budget. At deployment, every method receives the same full task instruction; subtasks are decomposed online by TouchWorld's Planner. Following your comment, we add a monolithic visuo-tactile baseline with the same backbone (π0.5 plus the tactile image); it reaches 42.5%/29.3%, and TouchWorld is 22.5/24.3 percentage points above it and 15.7/18.5 points above FTP-1. (Parts 1 and 2)
  • W2 / Q3, tactile representation and human pretraining: Figure 6 shows the representation actually used, and Figure 2 is an illustration. Human and robot touch are both rendered as 21 × 21 hand-shaped grids and enter through the same image interface. Following your suggestion, we add a robot-only world-model control: with human pretraining, terminal contact IoU rises from 46.8% to 52.7%, and success rises from 62.8%/52.3% to 65.0%/53.7%. (Part 3)
  • W3, ablations and TRT training: the ablations reuse one set of weights, and the no-TRT ablation leaves the inputs of the nominal policy unchanged. The module contributions given by an added level-by-level retrained comparison are close to the ablations in Figure 5. TRT is trained only on teleoperated demonstrations, and its benefit is larger under perturbations (13.3 vs. 9.7 percentage points). In an added control, removing only the tactile history of TRT lowers perturbed success from 53.7% to 45.3%. (Part 4)
  • W4, evaluation protocol: we give per-task success criteria, the perturbation protocol, and 95% confidence intervals for all methods and ablations. The gaps between TouchWorld and the three baselines, and those of the Planner and TRT ablations, are beyond statistical error. (Part 5)

W1 / Q1 / Q2 — Which backbone does the nominal policy use? How were the baselines trained? Does the gain come from the architecture, or from additional data and labels?

Backbone (Q1). The nominal policy uses the π0.5 architecture, i.e., PaliGemma with a Gemma-2B language backbone plus a Gemma-300M flow-matching action expert, and is initialized from the officially released π0.5 base checkpoint. According to the π0.5 paper, these weights are co-trained on manipulation data from multiple robot embodiments and on web image–text data. From this initialization, the nominal policy is fine-tuned for 30,000 steps with global batch size 32 and predicts 32-step, 120-dimensional action chunks. The Planner starts from Qwen3-VL-4B-Instruct; the world model starts from Wan2.2-TI2V-5B, is first pretrained on EgoTouch human visual–tactile data, and is then adapted on robot data.

Baseline training (Q2).

  • Same data. All methods use 200 teleoperated demonstrations per task, and all receive images from the head camera and two wrist cameras.
  • Same training budget. Each baseline and our nominal policy start from their officially released base checkpoints and are fine-tuned for 30,000 steps with global batch size 32.
  • Same external inputs. At deployment, the external instruction given to every method is the same full task instruction, and the camera images are the same. The subtask is not an external input: it is decomposed online by TouchWorld's Planner, and the terminal goals are generated by TouchWorld's world model.
  • No additional labels or data for the baselines. Subtask annotations and EgoTouch are used only to train TouchWorld's own Planner and world model; the training of the three baselines involves neither (details in Part 2).
MethodExternal language inputTactile inputConditions generated inside the system
π0.5Full task instructionNoneNone
FTP-1Full task instructionNative tactile interfaceNone
GR00T N1.7Full task instructionNoneNone
TouchWorldFull task instructionCurrent tactile image and TRT tactile historyCurrent subtask (Planner); visual and tactile goals (world model)

Part 2/5: A same-backbone monolithic visuo-tactile baseline; additional supervision (W1, continued)

W1 (continued) — Does the gain come from the architecture, or from additional data and labels?

A monolithic visuo-tactile baseline with the same backbone (W1). Following your comment, we add a monolithic visuo-tactile policy that shares TouchWorld's backbone and data:

  • Setup. It is initialized from π0.5 weights and takes the same current tactile image as TouchWorld as an additional input, without the Planner, predicted goals, or TRT.
  • Training and evaluation. It is fine-tuned on the same 200 demonstrations per task for 30,000 steps with global batch size 32; the evaluation protocol is that of Table 1, with 100 rollouts per task per condition.
PolicyInitializationTactile inputClean success (%)Perturbed success (%)
π0.5 (Table 1)π0.5None40.727.7
π0.5 + tactile image (new)π0.5Current tactile image42.529.3
FTP-1 (Table 1)FTP-1Native tactile interface49.335.2
TouchWorldπ0.5Current tactile image and TRT tactile history65.053.7
  • TouchWorld is 22.5/24.3 percentage points above the monolithic visuo-tactile policy with the same backbone. With the same backbone, the same robot data, and the same tactile sensor, this gap comes from the hierarchy.
  • Adding the tactile image to a monolithic policy brings only a limited gain. Adding the tactile image to π0.5 raises clean/perturbed success by only 1.8/1.7 percentage points. This is consistent with the submission's argument that monolithic visuo-tactile policies are limited.
  • FTP-1 is a stronger monolithic reference. According to its official release, FTP-1 is pretrained on approximately 3,000 hours of tactile manipulation data. TouchWorld is 15.7/18.5 points above it.

Adding the modules one level at a time. To separate the contributions, we train one more level on top of the monolithic baseline above: it adds subtask planning, i.e., the text input of the nominal policy includes the current subtask, which the Planner provides at deployment; it uses neither predicted goals nor TRT, with the same data and training budget. Together with existing results it gives the table below, in which every level is trained in its own configuration and involves no input mismatch:

ConfigurationClean success (%)Perturbed success (%)Gain over the previous level
π0.5 + tactile image (monolithic, new)42.529.3—
+ subtask planning (new)51.037.88.5/8.5
+ world-model goals ("No TRT" in Figure 5)55.340.34.3/2.5
+ TRT (full system)65.053.79.7/13.3
  • Subtask planning and TRT contribute the most, followed by the world-model goals. Subtask planning brings 8.5/8.5 percentage points, the world-model goals 4.3/2.5 points, and TRT 9.7/13.3 points.
  • The effect of the subtask annotations is measured on its own. It appears at the second level and accounts for 38%/35% of the total gain of 22.5/24.3 percentage points; the rest comes from the predicted goals and the tactile residual correction.

What the subtask annotations and EgoTouch are used for. Both are used only to train TouchWorld's own Planner and world model. They are part of the method, and both are additional to the action-policy fine-tuning budget above. The three baselines are monolithic policies trained in their original form on the full task instruction, and do not involve either of them:

  • Subtask annotations. The Planner is fine-tuned separately on 128,866 records from annotated teleoperation traces (LoRA rank 16, learning rate 10^-4); the text input of the nominal policy includes the current subtask.
  • EgoTouch human data. Used only for pretraining the world model. The world model is then adapted on 10 hours of robot demonstrations (rank-64 LoRA, learning rate 10^-4) and is trained before the nominal policy; the terminal visual–tactile goals it generates condition the nominal policy during training and deployment.

The gain does not come only from these two sources of supervision. With either one removed, the system remains above FTP-1, the strongest baseline:

  • Without EgoTouch. With a world model trained on robot data only (see Part 3), the success rate is 62.8%/52.3%, which is 13.5/17.2 percentage points above FTP-1.
  • Without subtask planning. With the Planner removed, the nominal policy receives only the full task instruction. Even though this differs from the inputs it was trained with, the success rate is still 55.5%/46.2%, which is 6.2/11.0 points above FTP-1.

Part 3/5: Tactile representation and human pretraining (W2 / Q3)

W2 / Q3 — How are tactile signals represented as images? How are human and robot hands aligned? Does human pretraining help?

Figures 2 and 6. Figure 6 shows the representation the system actually uses; the hand-shaped drawing in Figure 2 is only an illustration of tactile sensing. We will state this distinction in the captions of both figures.

Rendering. Touch uses the representation format of TouchAnything (EgoTouch):

  • From readings to a grid. The glove on each hand outputs 256 raw readings. After the baseline of the first frame is subtracted, the readings are placed, according to the position of each sensing unit on the hand, into a 21 × 21 hand-shaped grid; 217 cells correspond to sensing units on the thumb, the four fingers, and the palm, and the remaining positions have no sensor.
  • Normalization. The grid is divided by the pressure upper bound computed for the task and clipped to [0, 1].
  • Coloring. Each cell is colored by its value with a blue–cyan–yellow–red color map, without interpolation, which gives the colored patches in Figure 6; positions without sensors take the background color. The grids of the left and right hands are placed side by side in one tactile panel.
  • How it enters the models. The input and output of the world model is a 384 × 224 image arranged as a 2 × 2 grid, whose four tiles are the head view, the two wrist views, and the tactile panel above. The nominal policy takes the current tactile image as a separate image, together with the three camera images (all resized to 224 × 224), rendered in the same way.

Alignment between human and robot hands. Human data (EgoTouch) and robot data use the same grid format and the same rendering pipeline, so they can enter the same model without an additional mapping. The shapes of the human and robot hands and the physical positions of the sensing units differ (the different sensor layouts noted in Sec. 2.4); this difference is not handled by a unit-to-unit correspondence but by two-stage training: the world model is first pretrained on human data and then adapted on robot data.

Effect of human pretraining. Following your suggestion, we add a world model trained on robot data only and compare it with the original model in both prediction quality and closed-loop success:

  • Setup. It starts from the same Wan initialization and uses the same robot data and adaptation budget, omitting only EgoTouch pretraining.
  • Prediction quality. Evaluated on held-out subgoal segments in the same way as Table 2 of the submission.
  • Closed-loop evaluation. The nominal policy, the Planner, and TRT are kept unchanged, with 100 rollouts per task per condition.

Tactile prediction quality on held-out subgoal segments (%). The first two rows and the last row are from Table 2 of the submission.

MethodTemporal contact accuracyTerminal contact IoUVolumetric IoU
Current tactile copy70.431.824.6
Nearest-neighbor retrieval77.539.231.0
World model: robot adaptation only82.446.837.9
World model: EgoTouch pretraining + robot adaptation86.352.743.8

Closed-loop success (%). The first row is from Figure 5 of the submission.

ConfigurationClean success (%)Perturbed success (%)
No world-model goals60.251.2
World model: robot adaptation only62.852.3
World model: EgoTouch pretraining + robot adaptation65.053.7
  • Human pretraining improves the prediction of robot subgoals. Terminal contact IoU rises from 46.8% to 52.7%, volumetric IoU from 37.9% to 43.8%, and temporal contact accuracy from 82.4% to 86.3%. This corresponds directly to the statement in Sec. 2.4 that human contact priors transfer to robot subgoal prediction.
  • The change in closed-loop success is consistent with this. The world-model goals bring a total gain of 4.8/2.5 percentage points, of which 2.2/1.3 points come from human pretraining, about half (computed before rounding).

We will add both sets of results to the revision.

Reviewer_Fi9ROpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

To address failures caused by slippage, misalignment, and inappropriate contact forces during contact-rich manipulation, this paper proposes TouchWorld, a hierarchical framework that combines predictive visual-tactile goals with reactive action refinement. Specifically, a high-level planner first selects the current subtask, and a tactile world model predicts the visual and tactile observations expected at its completion. A goal-conditioned policy then uses these predicted goals, current observations, and task instructions to generate nominal action sequences. During execution, a Tactile Residual Transformer uses recent tactile and proprioceptive histories, nominal actions, and policy context to predict residual corrections. These corrections are added to nominal actions, allowing the robot to adapt to changes in contact conditions.

Critical strengths
  1. The idea of leveraging touch for both prediction and feedback is novel and well suited to addressing the challenges of contact-rich manipulation. These complementary roles guide the robot toward desired contact states while enabling adaptation to unexpected changes during execution.

  2. Decoupling slower task-level planning from higher-frequency tactile feedback is well motivated, as it avoids assigning all responsibilities to a single model and allows each component to operate at an appropriate frequency, making the framework well suited to precise grasping and sustained-contact tasks.

Critical weaknesses

The real-time feedback claim lacks measured end-to-end latency. The reported model invocation rates do not establish how quickly tactile feedback affects execution, while Appendix B.5 assumes predictions are ready at update boundaries. The paper should report actual sensing-to-actuation latency and clarify how residual corrections are aligned with ongoing execution, including how corrections for already-executed actions are handled.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors report the measured latency from tactile sensing to execution of the corrected action, along with the inference times and hardware used for TRT, the action policy, and the world model? How are residual corrections aligned with ongoing execution if the corresponding actions have already been executed, and how does the actual implementation differ from the reference schedule in Appendix B.5?
  2. The perturbation experiments provide evidence of robustness. Could the authors clarify whether the training demonstrations include perturbations and recovery behaviors, and how the test-time perturbations differ from those encountered during training?
5 comments

Part 1/3: Overview; latency and module timing (W / Q1)

Dear Reviewer Fi9R,

Thank you for recognizing the novelty of using touch for both prediction and feedback, and the motivation for decoupling slower task-level planning from faster tactile feedback. Thank you also for the specific questions about how the system runs on the robot. We first summarize our answer to each point and then respond in detail.

Overview

  • W / Q1, latency and timing: the measured latency from tactile acquisition to completion of the corrected action block is 56.53 ms. Of this, about 6.5 ms elapse from tactile acquisition to the dispatch of the corrected actions. On an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090, one TRT refresh takes 3.46 ms, nominal-policy inference 78.14 ms, and one world-model goal generation 657.49 ms. (This part)
  • Q1, difference from Appendix B.5: the action schedule is the same, and the update rates differ. The 10/30 Hz in B.5 are reference rates; in deployment, the average update rates of the nominal policy and TRT are approximately 4.20 Hz and 12.59 Hz. (Part 2)
  • Q1, alignment of corrections with execution: corrections are completed before actions are dispatched, and already-executed actions are never corrected retrospectively. (Part 2)
  • Q2, perturbations and recovery: the training demonstrations contain neither perturbations nor recovery behavior, and the physical perturbations at test time do not appear in training. The full system reaches 53.7% success under perturbations; removing only the tactile history of TRT lowers it to 45.3%. (Part 3)

W / Q1 — What is the measured sensing-to-execution latency? What are the inference times and the hardware of each module?

Sensing-to-execution latency. From the logs of real-robot runs, the latency from tactile acquisition to completion of the corresponding four-action corrected block is 56.53 ms. This interval includes sensor acquisition, preprocessing, TRT inference, communication, scheduling, and action execution. Of this, executing the four actions takes 50 ms (at 80 Hz), and about 6.5 ms elapse from tactile acquisition to the dispatch of the corrected actions. The value corresponds to TRT refreshes that reuse the cached nominal chunk, i.e., the second and third of the three refreshes in each nominal cycle.

Module timing. The table below gives wall-clock times on the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 used for real-robot deployment, at batch size one, after warm-up and with CUDA synchronization:

Measured callTimed callsMedian (ms)P95 (ms)
Nominal policy: action chunk and context10078.1478.86
TRT refresh (reusing the cached nominal chunk)3003.463.51
Joint nominal + TRT refresh10081.3481.96
World model: 17-frame goal clip30657.49672.61
  • A tactile correction does not require rerunning the nominal policy or the world model. TRT reuses the cached nominal chunk and policy context; one refresh takes 3.46 ms, about 1/23 of the nominal-policy inference time.
  • The 657.49 ms of the world model is outside the feedback loop. The world model refreshes its goal only when the subtask or the task state changes; stable phases reuse the cached goal.
  • Measurement configuration. Policy calls use the model configuration reported in the paper and replay four recorded observations that include proprioception and touch. The nominal policy keeps all 10 denoising steps and takes three camera images, the current tactile image, and the predicted goal grid; the five images are resized to 224 × 224 before timing. The world model is benchmarked separately on the same GPU type, with a 384 × 224 observation grid, 8 denoising steps, and two warm-up runs.
  • Timing boundary. Policy timings include input packaging, host/device transfer, inference, and return of the actions to the host; sensor acquisition, image resizing, robot communication, and actuator response are counted in the sensing-to-execution latency above.

Part 2/3: Differences from Appendix B.5; alignment of corrections with execution (Q1, continued)

Q1 (continued) — How does the implementation differ from the reference schedule in Appendix B.5?

The schedule is the same. Deployment uses H = 32 predicted actions, W = 16-step correction windows, and C = 4 committed actions per update. TRT refreshes at offsets 0, 4, and 8; after 12 actions have been executed in a nominal cycle, the nominal policy refreshes and replaces the remaining actions and the context.

The update rates differ. The 10/30 Hz in B.5 assume that predictions are ready at update boundaries and are reference rates. In deployment, the action step rate is 80 Hz and inference is blocking; the 30 FPS in the submission is the camera frame rate, while actions are recorded and executed at 80 Hz. Computed from the measured module timings, during phases that reuse the world-model goal, one nominal cycle takes about 238 ms:

  • The nominal policy refreshes every 238 ms on average, i.e., at 4.20 Hz.
  • TRT refreshes every 79 ms on average, i.e., at 12.59 Hz.

The ratio of TRT updates to nominal updates remains 3 : 1. Within each nominal chunk, tactile feedback has three opportunities to correct execution, without waiting for the next nominal-policy refresh. A change in touch is taken into account at the next TRT refresh, which occurs every 79 ms on average; without TRT, it would have to wait for the next nominal-policy refresh, every 238 ms on average.

In the revision, we will report both the reference rates and these deployment rates in Sec. 3.1 and Appendix B.5.

Q1 (continued) — How are residual corrections aligned with ongoing execution, and how are already-executed actions handled?

Already-executed actions are never corrected retrospectively. Execution is blocking: TRT first corrects the upcoming action window, and its first four corrected actions are then dispatched to the robot; the system waits for this block to finish before moving to the next correction. Corrections are therefore always completed before dispatch, and subsequent correction windows exclude actions that have already been executed.

Alignment follows global action indices. Let a nominal chunk begin at action step t, let the current correction step be τ, and let the local offset be j = τ − t. For residual-window position r = 0, …, 15, nominal entry j + r and its correction refer to global action τ + r. For example, at j = 4, nominal entries 4–19 correspond to actions t + 4 through t + 19; actions t through t + 3 have already been executed and are outside this window.

At a nominal refresh. The system replaces the remaining part of the old chunk and the cached context, discards the old residuals, resets the local offset, and recomputes the correction from the latest feedback. Observation histories keep their global indices.

Part 3/3: Perturbations and recovery (Q2)

Q2 — Do the training demonstrations contain perturbations or recovery behavior? How do the test-time perturbations differ from training?

Training demonstrations. The training demonstrations contain neither deliberately introduced physical perturbations nor recovery behavior. TRT is trained with the nominal policy frozen, and its residual target is the difference between the demonstrated action and the aligned nominal action. The Planner's training data includes memory variants such as stale histories and phase transitions; these change the text context given to the Planner and involve no physical perturbation of the robot or the objects.

Test-time perturbations. Perturbations are applied manually by an operator during task execution and cover the three types named in the submission: target displacement, unstable contact, and grasp interference.

  • Type and timing. Figure 4 shows four of them: interfering with the cup held by the robot, the bottle during clearing, the spray bottle during watering, and the cloth during wiping. In plug insertion, the operator moves the power strip while the robot approaches and aligns with the socket; in tissue pulling, the operator moves the tissue box as the robot is about to extract a tissue.
  • Difference from training. These perturbations change object positions or contact conditions during execution and do not appear in the training demonstrations.
  • Consistency across methods. For all methods, the operator follows the same task-specific criteria and applies the same kind of operation at the corresponding task stage.

Evaluation. Each method is evaluated with 100 rollouts per task per condition. Clean and perturbed trials use the same completion criteria: the task must be completed within the allotted time, during which autonomous retries and recovery are allowed; partial completion, timeout, or completion that requires additional human assistance is scored as failure.

Where robustness comes from without recovery demonstrations.

  • Task-level recovery is handled in closed loop by the Planner and the nominal policy. After a perturbation, the Planner reassesses the task state from the current observations and selects an executable subtask, and the nominal policy regenerates the action chunk from the new observations. Removing the Planner lowers perturbed success from 53.7% to 46.2%, a drop of 7.5 percentage points.
  • Contact-level correction comes from TRT. Removing TRT lowers perturbed success to 40.3%, a drop of 13.3 percentage points, larger than the 9.7 points under clean conditions.
  • This gain comes from tactile feedback. We add a control that removes only the tactile history of TRT, keeping the predicted goals and the other TRT inputs, reusing the trained weights, with 100 rollouts per task per condition. Perturbed success drops to 45.3%, a drop of 8.3 percentage points.
ConfigurationClean success (%)Perturbed success (%)
Full TouchWorld65.053.7
No Planner55.546.2
Remove only TRT tactile history (new)58.345.3
No TRT55.340.3

Differences are computed from unrounded success rates.

Reviewer_3VMgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TouchWorld combines subtask planning, predicted visual-tactile goals, and tactile residual feedback for dexterous manipulation. A goal-conditioned policy generates nominal actions, while a faster tactile controller refines their execution. On six real-robot tasks, it reports average success rates of 65.0% in clean conditions and 53.7% under human perturbations, improving over FTP-1 by 15.7 and 18.5 percentage points, respectively.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important control problem with a coherent hierarchical design. Separating task planning, contact-goal prediction, and tactile correction provides a reasonable way to coordinate task-level reasoning with local physical feedback.
  2. The real-robot experiments demonstrate useful system-level improvements. TouchWorld consistently outperforms the evaluated baselines in both clean and perturbed settings, with additional ablations and prediction analyses.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence does not sufficiently support the foundation-model positioning. The downstream evaluation is limited to one robot platform and six tasks, without demonstrating generalization to unseen tasks, unseen object combinations, other robots, or different tactile sensors. The current evidence better supports a hierarchical predictive/reactive manipulation framework than a general tactile foundation model.
  2. Baseline selection is not fair and experiment design is not sufficient. Although FTP-1 is included as a tactile baseline, no comparison with recent predictive/reactive visual-tactile works, such as OmniVTA, T-Rex, Dream-Tac. More targeted comparisons would make the novelty and benefits of the design more convincing.
Questions for authors
  1. Overall Contribution Clarification: The paper feels somewhat over-engineered. It consists of five modules, but their integration appears somewhat ad hoc. The current evidence demonstrates strong overall performance, but does not clearly establish the merits of each module’s design or justify the individual design choices. Suggest to add a clear design motivation and whether this design could be commonly used in wide tasks or combined with other backbones.
  2. Baseline Selection and Experiment Design: The choice of baselines is not sufficiently convincing. Apart from FTP-1, the paper lacks comparisons with other relevant tactile-based methods, such as OmniVTA, T-Rex, and Dream-Tac. Suggest to add more comparison experiments.
  3. Generalization: The experiments provide limited evidence of generalization, as the evaluation covers only six tasks using a single robot–hand configuration. Additional experiments across a broader range of tasks and hardware configurations would strengthen the paper. Suggest to add more comparison experiments.
6 comments

Part 1/4: Overview and the second real-robot platform (W1 / Q3)

Dear Reviewer 3VMg,

Thank you for recognizing that the paper addresses an important control problem with a coherent hierarchical design, and that the real-robot experiments show consistent system-level improvements in both clean and perturbed settings. We first summarize our answer to each point and then respond in detail.

Overview

  • W1 / Q3, generalization and positioning: we add a second real-robot platform and the Bench2Dex simulation benchmark. The second platform changes the arms, the dexterous hands, and the tactile sensors. On iced latte preparation, which requires five subtasks to be completed in sequence, TouchWorld completes the full task in 8/20 trials, while FTP-1 and T-Rex both achieve 0/20. On three Bench2Dex tasks, TouchWorld reaches a mean success rate of 45.3%, compared with 26.7% for the highest baseline mean. (Parts 1 and 2)
  • W2 / Q2, tactile baselines: we add real-robot comparisons with T-Rex on both platforms. On the six tasks of the original platform, T-Rex reaches a mean clean/perturbed success rate of 44.3%/31.2%, compared with 65.0%/53.7% for TouchWorld. Across the five subtasks on the second platform, the mean success rate is 82.4% for TouchWorld, 54.8% for FTP-1, and 48.0% for T-Rex. (Part 3)
  • Q1, design rationale: functionally, the system has four learned modules at three control levels. Removing the Planner, the world-model goals, or TRT reduces clean/perturbed success by 9.5/7.5, 4.8/2.5, and 9.7/13.3 percentage points, respectively. (Part 4)

W1 / Q3 — With one platform and six tasks, does the evaluation support generalization and the foundation-model positioning?

The evaluation in the submission covers one robot platform, one hand morphology, and one tactile sensor. To address the other robots, different tactile sensors, and additional tasks that you list, we add two sets of experiments.

(1) Second real-robot platform.

  • Hardware. Tianji Marvin dual arms and Sharpa Wave dexterous hands. Touch comes from visuotactile sensors integrated in the fingertips, a different sensing modality from the JQ-Industries pressure-sensing gloves on the original Wuji platform.
  • Task. Iced latte preparation, which is not among the six tasks in the submission. It consists of five subtasks: pouring milk, moving the cup under the coffee machine, picking up and inserting a capsule, closing the coffee machine, and pressing the switch.
  • Adaptation. We train the system on teleoperated demonstrations collected on the new platform. The hierarchy and the image-based goal interface are unchanged, and TRT uses a tactile encoder that matches the new sensors.
  • Compared methods. FTP-1 and T-Rex. FTP-1 is the strongest baseline in the submission. T-Rex directly addresses tactile-reactive dexterous manipulation, and both its real-robot experiments and FTP-1's dexterous-hand experiments use Sharpa Wave hands, the same hands as on this platform, so the three methods can be compared on the same hardware. All three methods use the same demonstrations and initial configurations.
  • Evaluation. Two protocols. First, each subtask is evaluated on its own, starting from its own initial state, with 50 trials per method per subtask. Second, the full task is executed from the beginning, with 20 trials per method; a trial succeeds only if all five subtasks are completed.

Table R1. Independent-subtask success rates (%), 50 trials per method per subtask.

MethodPour milkMove cup under machinePick up and insert capsuleClose coffee machinePress switchMean
FTP-1665436586054.8
T-Rex626244363648.0
TouchWorld828476888282.4

Table R2. Full-task sequential execution, 20 trials per method. Each column gives the number of trials that complete the task up to and including that subtask; the last column is the number of full-task successes.

MethodPour milkMove cup under machinePick up and insert capsuleClose coffee machinePress switch (full-task success)
FTP-1137310
T-Rex128310
TouchWorld16141098
  • TouchWorld has the highest success rate on all five subtasks (Table R1). Its mean is 82.4%, which is 27.6 and 34.4 percentage points above FTP-1 and T-Rex, respectively.
  • In 20 trials, only TouchWorld completes the full task (Table R2). TouchWorld succeeds in 8/20 trials (40%), while FTP-1 and T-Rex both achieve 0/20. The two-sided Wilson 95% confidence intervals are approximately 22% to 61% and 0% to 16%, respectively.
  • The gap widens as the task proceeds. TouchWorld completes the first three subtasks in sequence in 10 trials, and each of the two baselines in 3 trials.

Part 2/4: Bench2Dex and positioning (W1 / Q3, continued)

W1 / Q3 (continued) — With one platform and six tasks, does the evaluation support generalization and the foundation-model positioning?

(2) Bench2Dex simulation benchmark.

  • Tasks. Three of the 26 tasks in the benchmark: Canned Food Tray Arrangement, Baking Tray Prep, and Jigsaw Puzzle Assembly, all with the IIWA7 + Sharpa embodiment.
  • Training. TouchWorld is trained separately for each task on the official demonstrations, with subtask annotations derived from the task stage definitions.
  • Evaluation. 50 trials per task, using the None channel of the benchmark (scenes match the reference setting) and the official termination and stability-hold criteria.

Table R3. Stable success rates (%) on three Bench2Dex tasks, 50 trials per task. Baseline results are taken from the same channel of the official leaderboard. The methods use different input modalities, so the table compares complete systems.

MethodInputsCanned Food Tray ArrangementBaking Tray PrepJigsaw Puzzle AssemblyMean
ACTRGB + proprioception34.018.00.017.3
Diffusion PolicyRGB + proprioception0.06.00.02.0
π0.5RGB + proprioception + language30.050.00.026.7
GR00T N1.5RGB + proprioception + language20.038.020.026.0
GR00T N1.5 + tactileRGB + proprioception + language + touch28.036.08.024.0
TouchWorldRGB + proprioception + language + touch50.054.032.045.3
  • TouchWorld is above the listed baselines on all three tasks. Its mean success rate is 45.3%, which is 18.7 percentage points above the highest baseline mean (π0.5, 26.7%).

Summary. The same hierarchical design remains effective after the arms, the dexterous hands, the tactile sensors, and the task are changed. In the revision, we will add both sets of experiments, describe TouchWorld as a hierarchical predictive–reactive tactile manipulation framework, and limit the generalization claims to the evaluated platforms and tasks.

Part 3/4: Tactile baselines (W2 / Q2)

W2 / Q2 — Is the baseline selection fair? Apart from FTP-1, comparisons with tactile methods such as OmniVTA, T-Rex, and Dream-Tac are missing

There are two points here: whether the comparison in Table 1 of the submission is fair, and whether other tactile baselines are missing.

(1) The comparison in Table 1 of the submission. The three baselines in Table 1 and our nominal policy use the same robot data and the same training budget: 200 teleoperated demonstrations per task, image inputs from the head camera and two wrist cameras, and fine-tuning for 30,000 steps with global batch size 32, each starting from its officially released base checkpoint. Among them, the π0.5 baseline and our nominal policy are initialized from the same π0.5 pretrained weights. TouchWorld is 24.3/26.0 percentage points above it under clean/perturbed conditions, and 15.7/18.5 points above FTP-1, the strongest baseline.

(2) The added comparisons with T-Rex. We add T-Rex on both platforms. T-Rex has released its code and pretrained weights; OmniVTA and Dream-Tac have not yet released model weights and are therefore not included.

  • The second platform. The setup and the full results are given in Tables R1 and R2 in Part 1. TouchWorld is 20 to 52 percentage points above T-Rex on the five subtasks. On the full task, T-Rex achieves 0/20 and TouchWorld 8/20.
  • The six tasks on the original platform. T-Rex is trained on the same 200 demonstrations per task as the other baselines and evaluated under the same protocol as Table 1, with 100 rollouts per task per condition. The results are in Table R4: T-Rex reaches a mean clean/perturbed success rate of 44.3%/31.2%, and TouchWorld is 20.7/22.5 percentage points above it and higher on all six tasks under both conditions.

Table R4. Success rates (%) on the six tasks of the original platform; each cell is clean / perturbed, with 100 rollouts per task per condition. The T-Rex row is new; the other rows are from Table 1 of the submission.

MethodWater FlowerTabletop ClearingCup InsertionPower Plug InsertionPot WipingTissue PullingMean
π0.552 / 3466 / 4436 / 2412 / 639 / 2839 / 3040.7 / 27.7
FTP-156 / 3960 / 4248 / 3432 / 2057 / 4243 / 3449.3 / 35.2
GR00T N1.750 / 3258 / 3633 / 2118 / 936 / 2641 / 3239.3 / 26.0
T-Rex (new)46 / 3152 / 3544 / 3130 / 1952 / 3942 / 3244.3 / 31.2
TouchWorld72 / 6076 / 6266 / 5245 / 3570 / 5761 / 5665.0 / 53.7

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers,

Thank you again for your reviews of this submission. The authors have now posted their responses, and the author–reviewer discussion period ends on November 18, 2026 (AoE).

Please read the authors' rebuttal and let them know whether it addresses your concerns. A short reply is enough, for example:

  • which of your concerns are now resolved;
  • which remain open, and what evidence or clarification would resolve them;
  • whether you plan to update your rating.

If the rebuttal changes your assessment, please update your review and rating before the discussion period ends. If you have already engaged, thank you, and no further action is needed unless the authors reply again.

Your participation is important for a fair and well-informed decision.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.