acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

GuidedVTLA: Where Proactive Tactile Guidance Meets Reactive Tactile Refinement

Abstract

Multi-stage contact-rich tasks are challenging since robots must coordinate global stage-wise execution with local real-time contact reaction, with each global contact stage dictating when and how to react locally. However, existing methods typically use touch as reactive feedback for action generation or refinement in a stage-agnostic manner, limiting their ability to adapt generation and refinement strategies across distinct stages. In this work, we argue that touch is like a coin with two complementary sides: locally, it serves as reactive feedback conveying contact information, while globally, its temporal dynamics act as a proactive indicator offering contact stage awareness. To unlock the latter, we explore the temporal dynamics prior of optical tactile sensing, and discover that jointly leveraging the cumulative tactile motions and their transient differences can provide robust stage guidance for both action generation and refinement. Building on this insight, we propose GuidedVTLA, a slow-fast VTLA model that integrates proactive tactile guidance with reactive tactile refinement. Specifically, we utilize the shared proactive tactile guidance to coordinate both slow and fast action experts. The slow expert uses this guidance to dynamically route a stage-aware Mixture-of-Experts, adapting action generation strategies across contact stages. The fast expert uses temporal tactile cues to refine the action chunk during execution, with the shared guidance modulating refinement strength. Furthermore, we find that action trajectory energy across stages is mainly concentrated in a low-frequency subspace. This observation motivates us to perform tactile-driven action refinement within this subspace using a compact set of spectral residual coefficients, promoting temporally smooth refinement within each action chunk. Extensive experiments involving multi-stage contact-rich tasks on two real-world robot platforms and in simulation demonstrate the superior performance and robustness of GuidedVTLA.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Tactile-driven Manipulation, Contact-rich Manipulation, VTLA

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_kFYQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper argues that tactile signals play two roles. Locally, they serve as reactive feedback, and through their temporal dynamics, they indicate the contact stage, which the authors call proactive guidance. The guidance is built from the mean magnitude of cumulative tactile optical flow and its signed temporal difference. GuidedVTLA combines both roles in a slow-fast VTLA model built on π0.5\pi_{0.5}. The slow expert uses the guidance to route a stage-aware MoE, and the fast expert refines the action chunk in the DCT domain from temporal tactile input with the guidance controlling the refinement strength.

Critical strengths
  • The motivation and method are well addressed. Especially, suggesting the reactive and proactive tactile information and how to combine them is properly constructed and supported by extensive experiments including ablation studies.
  • Extensive experiments with different conditions including different robots, simulation, and ablations.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited novelty. ViTacMotor (Xu et al., 2026) already proposed that the sign of the per-pixel dot product between transient flow Flow(Tt−1,Tt)Flow(T_{t-1},T_{t}) and cumulative flow Flow(T0,Tt)Flow(T_{0}, T_{t}) separates contact stages across sensors. Writing b=Mtcumub=M_{t}^{cumu} and c=Mttranc=M_{t}^{tran} with Mt−1cumu≈b−cM_{t-1}^{cumu}\approx b-c, one has ∥Mtcumu∥−∥Mt−1cumu∥≈(b⋅c)/∥b∥\|M_{t}^{cumu}\| - \|M_{t-1}^{cumu}\|\approx (b\cdot c)/\|b\| to first order in ∥c∥/∥b∥\|c\|/ \|b\|. The paper's transient descriptor is therefore the spatial mean of Corrt/∥Mtcumu∥Corr_{t}/ \|M_{t}^{cumu}\| (Eq. 2 of ViTacMotor), the component of transient flow along the cumulative flow, which carries exactly the sign structure ViTacMotor attributes to TMC and discards its spatial pattern and force-magnitude information.
  • The low-frequency refinement is justified by the wrong quantity and conflicts with its stated purpose. Figure 4. shows the spectrum of the trajectories, which are smooth whether or not contact occurs. By Eq. (13) and the fast loss in A.1, what the fast expert learns is the correction At−AtbaseA_{t}-A_{t}^{base} projected onto the lowest MM modes. Contact reactions such as stopping at impact or recovering from slip are abrupt, containing high-frequency action behavior where current design cannot express them.
  • Unfair baseline comparison. GuidedVTLA starts from the pretrained π0.5\pi_{0.5} model, while ACT, RDP, and ViTacMotor are trained from scratch. The tactile-free π0.5\pi_{0.5} baseline already outperforms ViTacMotor on every task (Table 1), so most of the gap comes from the backbone.
Questions for authors

. Please add the ablation in which TproT^{pro} is computed from ViTacMotor's TMC inside the same π0.5\pi_{0.5} based model. Also, if the performance is significantly different. please explain why, since the two descriptors are nearly identical by the argument above. 2. What is the spectrum of the residual At−AtbaseA_{t}-A_{t}^{base} restricted to contact intervals, and the fraction of residual energy retained by M=8M=8? 3. Each update rewrites the remaining chunk through global DCT basis functions. How smooth is the executed command across update boundaries? 4. On the dual-arm platform with multiple sensors, how is TproT^{pro} formed, and is a single router shared across both arms when they are in different contact phases?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking forward to further discussions

Dear Reviewer kFYQ

We sincerely thank you for your insightful comments on our paper, and we genuinely hope that our response could address your concerns. As the discussion period is nearing its end with less than one week remaining, we look forward to receiving your feedback. Please feel free to contact us if you have any further inquiries.

Thank you once again for your valuable contributions to enhancing the quality of our work.

Authors of Submission 6864

Reviewer_AybbOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes GuidedVTLA, a slow-fast visuo-tactile-language-action model for multi-stage contact-rich manipulation. Two scalar tactile dynamics signals (mean cumulative gel flow magnitude and its signed frame-to-frame difference) are fused into a guidance embedding. This embedding routes a tactile-aware MoE in the slow expert and gates a fast expert that refines the low-frequency DCT modes of the action chunk from streaming tactile flow. The model is built on π0.5 and evaluated on six real tasks across two platforms, eight UniVTAC simulation tasks, ablations, and one cross-sensor transfer experiment.

Critical strengths
  • Low-frequency spectral refinement is a sensible design with a clear result. Correcting only the first 8 DCT modes with a contact gate avoids jitter and needs few predicted parameters. Table 5 shows the ordering low-band > full-band > none > time-domain, which supports the design even if the time-domain control is weak.
  • Broad evaluation. Two real embodiments, six tasks with stage-wise success rates, a public simulation benchmark with eight tasks, component ablations, and a cross-sensor transfer test. Few tactile VLA papers cover this much.
  • Reproducibility details. Table S1 lists hyperparameters, Eq. 12 and 13 give the exact routing and residual forms, and B.4 describes online timing. The baselines’ code sources are stated.
Critical weaknesses
  • The central premise is not established. The paper assumes the base VLA lacks stage awareness, but gives no evidence. The π0.5 baseline reaches 100% on the first stage and fails at the first hard insertion, which is a contact-precision failure, not stage confusion. No oracle experiment with ground-truth stage labels, no failure attribution by stage, no case where vision cannot tell which stage the robot is in.
  • “Stage-aware” is contact-phase conditioning. The guidance is two scalars that distinguish no contact, onset, hold, and release. It cannot separate, for example, first gear from second gear. Fig. 6 confirms that expert weights follow contact transitions. The title, abstract, and contributions claim more than the method can do.
  • The same configuration gets different numbers in different tables (slow-only: 70/45 in Table 3, 65/50 in Table 5). The no-guidance variant in Table 4 (50/45) is worse than tactile-free π0.5 on gears (60), which means the tactile MoE and fast expert without guidance hurt. Every attributed effect is 5 to 10 points on 20 trials across two tasks. With inconsistent baselines and one-trial margins, the claims “the MoE helps,” “the fast expert helps,” and “guidance helps both” are not separable from noise. This is the evidence for contributions 3 and 4 of the paper.
Questions for authors
  • Within behavior cloning, the policy already receives vision, language, proprioception, and tactile input, so any stage information inferable from these inputs can be learned implicitly. In what scenario is an end-to-end policy with the same tactile inputs expected to fail while tactile-routed experts succeed? I think the authors need to state the failure mode and show it on at least one task.
  • Can you add a non-MoE slow expert that receives T_pro as an input token, to separate the effect of routing from the effect of the tactile descriptor?
  • How does the router distinguish the first gear from the second gear, or grasping from inserting while in contact, given that the guidance only encodes no contact, onset, hold, and release? If this cannot be distinguished, adding this as a limitation and adjust the strength of the claim in the paper would help the reader understand the scope of this work.
  • What can be the reason behind the no-guidance variant (50 on gears, Table 4) below tactile-free π0.5 (60)?
  • How does the descriptor differ from ViTacMotor’s TMC, which Appendix A.4 describes as extracting the same three contact phases from transient and cumulative flow?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking forward to further discussions

Dear Reviewer Aybb

We sincerely thank you for your insightful comments on our paper, and we genuinely hope that our response could address your concerns. As the discussion period is nearing its end with less than one week remaining, we look forward to receiving your feedback. Please feel free to contact us if you have any further inquiries.

Thank you once again for your valuable contributions to enhancing the quality of our work.

Authors of Submission 6864

Thank you for your response for each point and answering questions with additional experiments. The narrowed scope to contact-stage awareness addresses my main concern about overclaiming, and the repeated ablations and the input-token comparison help clarify the contribution of each component.

I still have one remaining concern regarding the evaluation protocol.

we have repeated the component and shared-guidance ablations over three evaluation rounds on Gears Assembly and Fruits Collection, with 20 trials per task in each

By this wording I understand that the authors used the same model checkpoint and increased the number of evaluations. However, a large part of the variance in BC policy performance comes from training side, such as training seeds and checkpoints selection. I would not ask the authors to retrain the whole model sets and evaluate again, but it would be nice to have a reproducible simulation results across multiple seeds to add statistical rigor to the conclusion.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Aybb

Dear Reviewer Aybb,

Thank you for your constructive feedback and for reconsidering your score. Your suggestions have helped improve the clarity and rigor of our work. We sincerely appreciate your time and support.

We fully agree that training-side variance is an important factor in behavior cloning policies. Following your valuable suggestion, we will include multi-seed simulation ablation results on the UniVTAC [1] benchmark in the revision.

[1] Baijun Chen, et al. UniVTAC: A Unified Simulation Platform for Visuo-Tactile Manipulation Data Generation, Learning, and Benchmarking. In 2026 CoRL.

Best regards, Authors of Submission 6864

Reviewer_PMM5OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors mainly propose Guided VTLA, which integrates proactive tactile guidance with reactive tactile refinement. By streamlining two different approaches, the proposed system was able to adapt to different stages of the task. The authors have carried out multiple evaluations and comparisons with priors to validate the performance of the proposed Guided VTLA.

Critical strengths

The main strength would be extensive evaluation of the proposed system across various aspects, from comparisons with SOTA to an ablation study of GUIDEDVLTA-related parameters. Also, the added supplementary video will validate the validity and feasibility of employing the proposed method. Moreover, it is impressive to see large set of qualitative results which well support the scalability of the proposed ethod.

Critical weaknesses

In my opinion, there are two weaknesses. The first one is the clarification of the paper’s novelty. When I look at Figure 1(a), I cannot really see much innovation between Slow-Fast VTLA vs. GuidedVTLA. It would be great if authors could pinpoint how the proposed design differs from prior art and how this difference enhances the overall model performance.
Writing is a major weakness in my opinion. First, the paper is long and hard to understand. Also, it is not reader-friendly. For example, I cannot really read the text in the figure, and this is not good practice. The authors should put enough effort into making the paper legible to readers without any difficulties. These crowded texts and figures make it harder for readers to understand the paper, in my opinion.

Questions for authors
  1. For Figure 1(a), what is the main innovation from slow-fast VLTA to GuidedVLTA? Are they fundamentally different? If not, what was the main factor that determined the difference in final performance?
  2. I cannot really get the idea of Figure 1(b). What is the main purpose of showing this illustrative graph?
  3. In the contribution, you mentioned “We reveal that touch has a complementary dual role, serving as both reactive feedback signals providing local contact information and proactive stage indicators offering global stage awareness.”. In this paper, did we actually confirm that the system understands contact-stage awareness through the temporal dynamics of touch? I am not fully sure whether Figure 3(b) supports this claim.
  4. If you need to condense the paper, what parts could be put into a supplementary? The reason is that I think the current main text and figures are too crowded, and it would be better to leave some space for a clearer context.
  5. What could be the downside of utilizing the temporal aspect of touch, since utilizing temporal data requires more data to collect/analyze/handle?
  6. References
  • Link to the first 3 references should be fixed/updated.
  • Too many ArXiv references. Could we avoid this as much as possible?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Looking forward to further discussions

Dear Reviewer PMM5

We sincerely thank you for your insightful comments on our paper, and we genuinely hope that our response could address your concerns. As the discussion period is nearing its end with less than one week remaining, we look forward to receiving your feedback. Please feel free to contact us if you have any further inquiries.

Thank you once again for your valuable contributions to enhancing the quality of our work.

Authors of Submission 6864

Reviewer_PMM5OpenReview ↗

Follow-up on the response

I have one quick question regarding the first response.

You mentioned "whether action generation and refinement are explicitly conditioned on contact stages, as well as in the space where refinement is performed". Could you clarify little bit more why this is important? (Not about the difference, but more about the importance and impact of the claim)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer PMM5

[Q]: Importance and impact of contact-stage conditioning and the action refinement space.

[A]: Thank you for this insightful follow-up question! We clarify the practical importance and empirical impact of both design choices below.

(1) Importance of shared contact-stage guidance. Conditioning both experts on contact stages is essential because the role of tactile signals changes fundamentally before and after physical contact. During non-contact phases such as approach and alignment, tactile sensors still produce uninformative fluctuations and background noise. Without contact-stage conditioning, injecting these cues directly into action generation or refinement interferes with visual localization and destabilizes pre-contact motion. As discussed in our response to Reviewer Aybb [W3-2&Q4], recent studies report similar findings, where AT-VLA [1], TacVLA [2], and T-Rex [3] show that directly incorporating tactile inputs without stage regulation introduces pre-contact localization errors and substantially degrades grasping performance.

To further verify this failure mode caused by the lack of stage guidance, we have included a controlled comparison on real-world bulb insertion in our response to Reviewer Aybb [Q1] (newly added in Appendix C.7, Table S3, and Fig. S14):

MethodGrasp Bulb →Align Bulb →Insert Bulb
π0.5\pi_{0.5}100.055.045.0
π0.5\pi_{0.5} + direct tactile concatenation50.020.05.0
GuidedVTLA100.060.060.0

Direct tactile concatenation frequently fails during pre-contact grasping and alignment. Attention maps in Figure S14 show that unconditioned tactile inputs disperse the attention of the action expert away from the bulb during grasping and away from the target socket during alignment. In contrast, GuidedVTLA uses shared contact-stage guidance to suppress irrelevant tactile interference before contact and engage tactile feedback during contact, restoring grasping and alignment performance while improving overall insertion success. This stage decoupling is critical for reliable multi-stage manipulation without degrading base visual-motor capabilities.

(2) Importance of low-frequency spectral refinement. Performing refinement in a low-frequency spectral space is crucial for smooth and accurate adjustments during contact-rich manipulation. In tasks such as gear assembly, the robot relies on tactile feedback for subtle pose corrections, where overly abrupt adjustments easily cause alignment deviations. When the fast expert directly predicts point-wise residuals in the raw action space, high-frequency tactile feedback easily induces rapid action changes, resulting in abrupt step-to-step jumps that disrupt the smoothness of the executed action chunk and ultimately lead to assembly and insertion failures.

In contrast, normal robot trajectories are predominantly concentrated in low-frequency modes, as shown in Fig. 4. Building on this property, restricting the fast expert to a compact low-frequency DCT subspace enables the model to predict only a small set of low-frequency spectral residual coefficients to reconstruct a smooth correction across the action chunk. This design aligns refinement with the spectral characteristics of natural trajectories while structurally preventing abrupt step-to-step jumps, ensuring gradual and compliant adjustments during contact. As shown in the ablation study in Table 5, low-frequency spectral refinement outperforms raw action-space refinement on precise contact-rich tasks.

[1] Xiaoqi Li, et al. AT-VLA: Adaptive Tactile Injection for Enhanced Feedback Reaction in Vision-Language-Action Models. In CVPR 2026.

[2] Heng Zhang, et al. TacVLA: Contact-Aware Tactile Fusion for Robust Vision-Language-Action Manipulation. In IROS 2026.

[3] Dantong Niu, et al. T-Rex: Tactile-Reactive Dexterous Manipulation. In CoRL 2026.

Comments on the paper

7 comments
Area_Chair_UtvHOpenReview ↗

Discussion Reminder

Dear Reviewers,

I hope this message finds you well. As we are now in the discussion period, I would like to kindly remind you to leave comments for the authors through OpenReview if you have not already done so.

Thank you very much for your time and effort. Please let me know if you have any questions.

Best

Thank you for the detailed response.

W1. The response lists differences in motivation, framework, and formulation. My concern was slightly different. It was about the second contribution, the claim that the paper discovers a contact-stage indicator. Let me state the relation more precisely than in my review.

Use the notation of ViTacMotor. Let b=Mtcumub = M_{t}^{cumu}, a=Mt−1cumua = M_{t-1}^{cumu}, and c=Mttranc = M_{t}^{tran}, with c≈b−ac \approx b - a. Then at each pixel

∥b∥−∥a∥=c⋅(a+b)∥a∥+∥b∥=2Corrt−∥c∥2∥a∥+∥b∥\|b\| - \|a\| = \frac{c \cdot (a+b)}{\|a\|+\|b\|} = \frac{2\mathrm{Corr}_t - \|c\|^2}{\|a\|+\|b\|}

where Corrt=c⋅b\mathrm{Corr}_t = c \cdot b is the TMC of ViTacMotor (their Eq. 2). The spatial mean of the left side is Mˉttran\bar{M}^{tran}_t in Eq. 3 of this paper. So the transient descriptor can be computed from the per-pixel quantities of ViTacMotor (MttranM^{tran}_t, MtcumuM^{cumu}_t, and their dot product Corrt\mathrm{Corr}_t) by dividing by ∥a∥+∥b∥\|a\|+\|b\| and averaging over the image. Both papers obtain these quantities from the same three frames with the same optical flow method. For ∥c∥≪∥b∥\|c\| \ll \|b\| the expression reduces to the mean of Corrt/∥b∥\mathrm{Corr}_t / \|b\|, as in my review.

I do not claim that the two representations are identical. TMC is a dense map and keeps spatial structure and magnitude. The descriptor here is a scalar, and the paper adds the mean cumulative magnitude to separate stable contact from no contact. My point is that the property presented as a discovery in Sec. 3.1, that the sign of the transient change separates contact establishment from release, follows directly from the same property of TMC. The third point of the authors' response to W1, which contrasts the dense TMC map with the compact descriptor, is consistent with this. Averaging a dense map is what produces a compact scalar.

In the main text, ViTacMotor appears as a Mixture-of-Transformers fusion architecture in Sec. 2 and as a baseline in Sec. 4. Its TMC representation is not mentioned there. It appears only in Sec. A.4, which describes it as distinguishing contact establishment, stable contact, and contact release. Sec. 3.1 introduces the descriptor without reference to it. I ask that this relation be stated in Sec. 3.1, and that the second contribution be reworded accordingly.

I accept that the system differs from ViTacMotor. Using one guidance signal for routing in the slow expert and for gating in the fast expert is a contribution at the system level. One more ablation would help to clarify where the gain comes from. Tables 3 and 4 switch the guidance on and off as a whole and do not separate its two channels. Could you report the result when the guidance is built from the cumulative magnitude alone?

W2. My concern is about the justification, and it remains. Low-frequency dominance of trajectories is expected, since a trajectory is dominated by large and slow motion. It does not show that the corrections can be low-frequency. Each window covers a whole recovery of 3 to 8 seconds. Most of it is slow retraction and realignment, so the reported energy describes the slow part.

I agree that many useful corrections are low-frequency, for example a lateral offset during insertion or a change in grip width. The open question is how much of the required correction falls outside the first MM modes, since the fast expert cannot correct that part.

The direct evidence for the band restriction is Table 5. Low band and full band differ by 15 and 5 points. If the ablations use 20 trials per task as in Table 1, this is 3 trials and 1 trial, which is too few to conclude that the restriction matters.

W3. The regrouped tables address my concern.

Q1. Thank you for running this. I read the result as support for the point in W1, since replacing the descriptor with TMC keeps most of the gain. To interpret the remaining difference I need to know how the replacement was done. The descriptor has two channels, the mean cumulative magnitude and the transient difference. The relation in W1 concerns only the second one. Was the cumulative channel kept? Was TMC fed as a dense map through an encoder, or pooled to a scalar?

This matters because TMC is near zero both in stable contact and without contact. If it replaced both channels, the router could no longer tell these two states apart, and the drop would come from losing the cumulative channel, not from granularity. The comparison that tests my argument keeps the cumulative channel and replaces only the transient difference with the spatial mean of TMC.

Q2. Thank you for analyzing the residual. This is the analysis that can settle W2. Sec. C.6 states that one window per task was selected within the 98%–99% retention range. Three windows chosen by their retention value do not show how ρ8\rho_8 is distributed. If 98%–99% is typical, please report the distribution over all contact windows, computed on held-out trajectories (not from training data), to show it. If the distribution stays high, my concern in W2 is resolved.

Overall, the response resolves W3, Q3, and Q4. My main concerns are W1 and W2. Stating the relation to TMC and reporting the residual distribution would make the paper clearer, and I encourage the authors to add them. However, I still think the contribution and novelty of the paper are still limited. The contact-stage descriptor is a pooled form of TMC. Restricting corrections to a low-frequency band is a common technique. For it to count as a contribution, its benefit would need to be clear in the ablations, and Table 5 does not establish this. What remains is the use of one guidance signal for both routing and gating, which I see as a reasonable design, and the current ablations do not yet show how much it contributes.

I therefore keep my rating for now. I would reconsider it if ablations with enough trials show a clear benefit from the band restriction, and from the shared guidance over simpler alternatives such as the cumulative magnitude alone.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.