- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper argues that tactile signals play two roles. Locally, they serve as reactive feedback, and through their temporal dynamics, they indicate the contact stage, which the authors call proactive guidance. The guidance is built from the mean magnitude of cumulative tactile optical flow and its signed temporal difference. GuidedVTLA combines both roles in a slow-fast VTLA model built on . The slow expert uses the guidance to route a stage-aware MoE, and the fast expert refines the action chunk in the DCT domain from temporal tactile input with the guidance controlling the refinement strength.
Critical strengths
- The motivation and method are well addressed. Especially, suggesting the reactive and proactive tactile information and how to combine them is properly constructed and supported by extensive experiments including ablation studies.
- Extensive experiments with different conditions including different robots, simulation, and ablations.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited novelty. ViTacMotor (Xu et al., 2026) already proposed that the sign of the per-pixel dot product between transient flow and cumulative flow separates contact stages across sensors. Writing and with , one has to first order in . The paper's transient descriptor is therefore the spatial mean of (Eq. 2 of ViTacMotor), the component of transient flow along the cumulative flow, which carries exactly the sign structure ViTacMotor attributes to TMC and discards its spatial pattern and force-magnitude information.
- The low-frequency refinement is justified by the wrong quantity and conflicts with its stated purpose. Figure 4. shows the spectrum of the trajectories, which are smooth whether or not contact occurs. By Eq. (13) and the fast loss in A.1, what the fast expert learns is the correction projected onto the lowest modes. Contact reactions such as stopping at impact or recovering from slip are abrupt, containing high-frequency action behavior where current design cannot express them.
- Unfair baseline comparison. GuidedVTLA starts from the pretrained model, while ACT, RDP, and ViTacMotor are trained from scratch. The tactile-free baseline already outperforms ViTacMotor on every task (Table 1), so most of the gap comes from the backbone.
Questions for authors
. Please add the ablation in which is computed from ViTacMotor's TMC inside the same based model. Also, if the performance is significantly different. please explain why, since the two descriptors are nearly identical by the argument above. 2. What is the spectrum of the residual restricted to contact intervals, and the fraction of residual energy retained by ? 3. Each update rewrites the remaining chunk through global DCT basis functions. How smooth is the executed command across update boundaries? 4. On the dual-arm platform with multiple sensors, how is formed, and is a single router shared across both arms when they are in different contact phases?
Looking forward to further discussions
Dear Reviewer kFYQ
We sincerely thank you for your insightful comments on our paper, and we genuinely hope that our response could address your concerns. As the discussion period is nearing its end with less than one week remaining, we look forward to receiving your feedback. Please feel free to contact us if you have any further inquiries.
Thank you once again for your valuable contributions to enhancing the quality of our work.
Authors of Submission 6864