acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Touch as Progress: Residual Policy for Precision Robot Manipulation

Abstract

Tactile feedback provides direct access to subtle physical interactions and is an important sensing modality for precision manipulation. Similar tactile signals may occur at different stages of an interaction and call for different actions, leaving the underlying interaction state ambiguous from individual contact observations alone. This work presents Tactile Progress Residual (TPR), which represents the interaction process as progress estimated from recent tactile and robot-state observations and uses it to organize residual correction of base-policy actions. The progress estimator is trained with weak temporal supervision from recorded interactions without manual stage annotations. The estimated progress conditions a lightweight residual policy, provides process-level feedback for learning through progress differences, and determines when residual correction is applied. Conditioned on progress, the residual policy combines tactile feedback with base-policy predictions to generate bounded action corrections. Experiments on ManiFeel, ManiSkill3, and real-world precision manipulation tasks show that TPR consistently outperforms strong vision-only and tactile baselines. Further ablations validate the effectiveness of tactile-based progress estimation and the role of progress in organizing residual correction. Code is released at an anonymous repository.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Precision Manipulation, Tactile Perception, Progress Estimation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 4%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.25 over 4 reviews, above 96% of the others.
Reviewer_jfvcOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TPR adds a lightweight residual controller on top of a frozen base policy for precise contact-rich manipulation tasks. A progress estimator maps a history of tactile and robot state observations to a scalar interaction process coordinate, trained with weak supervision from relative time within recorded episodes plus endpoint and temporal order auxiliary losses. The coordinate conditions the residual actor, supplies a progress difference term in the PPO reward, and at deployment a hard threshold on it gates whether the bounded residual is applied. Evaluation covers eight ManiFeel tasks, four ManiSkill3 tasks and four real world tasks on an ARX X5 with Xense tactile sensors.

Critical strengths
  • The decomposition of progress into three distinct roles, conditioning, reward, and gating, is a clean idea validated by ablation results.
  • Evaluation is in thorough in general, with 100 real-world trails per method per task.
Critical weaknesses
  • The progress coordinate is defined as relative time within a recorded episode, which presumes a single canonical timeline per task. But when the task has multi-modality, i.e., there are multiple valid strategies to complete the task of differing length, or if demonstrations are collected at different speeds, then the same tactile and state history would map to different targets across episodes, causing ambiguity.
  • Real-world success rates are pretty low, and lacks failure mode analysis.
Questions for authors
  • Would there be an continuous alternative to the hard gate and what would be some trade-offs, if any?
  • Why is g_t=1 during post training but gated at deployment, and why is the evaluation correction gain larger than the training gain?
  • Related work on residual correction for contact-rich manipulation should discuss Compliant Residual DAgger: Improving Real-World Contact-Rich Manipulation with Human Corrections (NeurIPS 2025). It is closely related, it also learns a force-aware residual policy over a frozen pretrained base policy for precision contact-rich tasks, and its evaluation tasks also include gear insertion.
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer jfvc (1/2)

We are grateful to Reviewer jfvc for the thoughtful comments and suggestions. We respond to the comments below and invite the reviewer to consult the revised PDF for the related changes.


W1: "Different execution speeds and valid strategies may assign conflicting temporal labels to similar interaction histories."

A1: Thank you for highlighting this limitation. We use relative-time weak supervision to avoid time-consuming manual progress annotation. We acknowledge that this trade-off can introduce conflicting labels for similar tactile and state histories when demonstrations differ in local execution speed or strategy, potentially reducing estimation accuracy. The estimator therefore depends in part on temporal consistency across demonstrations. We have clarified this limitation in the revised manuscript (Appendix E, Lines 1028–1031).

W2-1: "Real-world success rates remain low..."

A2-1: In real-world tasks, tactile sensing errors, execution delays, and robot motion jitter can reduce task success, with jitter particularly disruptive to fine alignment and contact adjustment. These remain recognized challenges in real-world robotic manipulation [1, 2].

Nevertheless, under the same evaluation protocol, TPR achieves an average success rate of 47.8%, compared with 34.0% for the strongest baseline, an improvement of 13.8% (Table 3).

W2-2: "...failure-mode analysis is missing."

A2-2: Thank you for pointing this out. We have expanded the failure analysis based on the trajectory visualizations in Appendix D.1. These cases show that when the base policy produces large position or orientation errors, the bounded residual correction may be insufficient to resolve them, resulting in persistent misalignment or incomplete insertion or engagement.

Q1: "Would there be a continuous alternative to the hard gate and what would be some trade-offs?"

A1: Thank you for this suggestion. A continuous alternative is a piecewise-linear gate, gt=clip((p^t−τ+δ)/(2δ) 0,1)g_t=\mathrm{clip}((\hat p_t-\tau+\delta)/(2\delta)\,0,1), where δ>0\delta>0 controls the half-width of the transition interval around τ\tau.

This makes correction activation smoother, but allows partial corrections below τ\tau and attenuates corrections just above it, potentially applying correction before it is needed or weakening it when full correction is useful. It also introduces an additional hyperparameter, δ\delta, that requires tuning. We will explore this promising direction in future work.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer jfvc (2/2)

Q2-1: "Why is g_t=1 during post training but gated at deployment?"

A2-1: i) Design rationale. We keep gt=1g_t=1 during training to learn residual corrections without a hard progress threshold. Corrections during contact directly affect task completion, whereas those during approach may have little effect on return and thus receive a weaker learning signal. Progress gating at deployment suppresses these less-constrained approach-phase corrections, separating residual learning from intervention timing (Lines 221–228, 458–461).

ii) Training and deployment comparison. We compare three training and deployment settings on the four-task ManiFeel subset. Whenever enabled, progress gating uses the same threshold, τ=0.75\tau=0.75.

TrainingDeploymentPeg ↑USB ↑Plug ↑Gear ↑Average ↑
Always activeAlways active4550655954.8
Progress gateProgress gate5058736962.5
Always activeProgress gate5262767265.5

The two matched settings reduce average success by 10.7% (54.8% vs. 65.5%) and 3.0% (62.5% vs. 65.5%), respectively. These results support learning residual corrections without a hard threshold during training and scheduling their application through progress gating at deployment. We have included this comparison in the revised manuscript (Table 8; Lines 439–444, 458–461).

Q2-2: "why is the evaluation correction gain larger than the training gain?"

A2-2: i) Design rationale. During training, residual actions are sampled from a Gaussian distribution, so a smaller gain limits exploration-induced perturbations to the base actions. At evaluation, a larger gain strengthens deterministic corrections while retaining the same residual budgets and clipping bounds (Eq. 5).

ii) Gain sweep. In our ManiSkill3 experiments, we use a training gain of α=1.0\alpha=1.0 and an evaluation gain of α=1.2\alpha=1.2. To assess sensitivity to the evaluation gain, we evaluate the same trained checkpoint with different gains while keeping the training gain fixed.

Evaluation gainAverage SR (%) ↑
0.845.2
1.045.4
1.245.9
1.445.5
1.645.1

Average success varies by only 0.8% across the tested gains, indicating low sensitivity to the evaluation gain within this range. We have clarified the training and evaluation gains and added the sweep results to the revised manuscript (Sec. 3.3, Appendix B.2, Appendix C.2 and Table 13, Lines 251–254, 803–805, 868–875).

Q3: "Related work on residual correction for contact-rich manipulation should discuss Compliant Residual Dagger[3]."

A3: Thank you for pointing us to this work. Both methods refine a pretrained policy through residual correction, but differ in: i) Learning: CR-DAgger learns from human corrections; TPR uses PPO with geometric and progress-difference rewards. ii) Control: CR-DAgger predicts pose corrections and target wrenches for compliant control; TPR produces bounded action corrections from tactile feedback and estimated progress. iii) Timing: CR-DAgger learns zero corrections from labeled examples; TPR explicitly gates deployment corrections using progress, which also conditions the policy and shapes its reward. We have cited CR-DAgger and discussed its differences from TPR in Related Work (Lines 082–085).

[1] Iretiayo Akinola et al. TacSL: A Library for Visuotactile Sensor Simulation and Learning. IEEE Transactions on Robotics, 2025.

[2] Kevin Black, Manuel Y. Galliker, and Sergey Levine. Real-Time Execution of Action Chunking Flow Policies. In NeurIPS, 2025.

[3] Xiaomeng Xu, Yifan Hou, Zeyi Liu, and Shuran Song. Compliant Residual DAgger: Improving Real-World Contact-Rich Manipulation with Human Corrections. In NeurIPS, 2025.

Reviewer_hjKcOpenReview ↗
Rating
4(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Tactile Progress Residual (TPR). TPR produces a residual policy conditioned on estimated task progress that provides corrections to a base policy. The base policy doesn't need to be altered in any way.

Tactile history and robot state are used as inputs for a learnt progress estimator. The frozen base policy consumes its inputs (vision and potentially other sensors) and produces the base action. The residual policy is conditioned on estimated task progress and tactile information and produces the corrective delta action. The residual policy is only applied if it passes a gating condition, which is that estimated task progress must be greater than or equal to a threshold.

The residual policy is trained in simulation using PPO. In addition to conditioning, =estimated task progress is also used as an auxiliary reward for the residual policy.

Empirical results show improvement over simple tactile conditioning.

Critical strengths
  • Positive empirical results
  • Real robot results
Critical weaknesses
  • Tactile ambiguity in Figure 1: The authors argue that different stages of the task can have a similar tactile profile, and task progress can disambiguate. However, vision can also disambiguate, as in the example in Fig. 1. Simply conditioning on vision + tactile should perform just as well as the proposed method. I suspect the weaker performance of tactile-based benchmarks could be due to architectural bottleneck, not enough tuning, etc instead of tactile progress being fundamentally superior.
Questions for authors
  • Why is gating necessary? The residual policy should be able to learn near-zero values when it's not needed.
  • Line 240: gating is always 1 during training, which is a train-test mismatch. Why is this desirable, and what happens if we get rid of this mismatch?
  • Why is vision dropped from the progress estimator as well as the residual policy?
  • In Fig. 5, how does vision + tactile based curve look? Does it improve over tactile only?
  • Line 342: In the real world setup, after base policy is fine tuned on 100 teleop demos, is the residual policy re-trained on top? If so, in sim or in real?
  • Line 268: What is the correction gain? Is it the PD gain of the low level controller?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer hjKc (1/2)

We appreciate Reviewer hjKc's careful review and helpful suggestions. Our point-by-point responses follow below, with corresponding revisions in the updated PDF.


W1-1: "Simply conditioning on vision + tactile should perform just as well as the proposed method."

A1-1: i) Vision captures coarse stages but may miss subtle interaction changes during precision manipulation that tactile progress can distinguish.

ii) Beyond policy conditioning, progress supplies a process-difference training signal and gates deployment correction (Lines 051–059, 101–103).

iii) We compare TPR with two vision + tactile history-conditioned residual PPO variants on ManiSkill3 (Sec. 4.4), replacing the progress input while a) retaining the progress-based reward and gate or b) removing both.

Residual variantPeg ↑Pick ↑Plug ↑StackCube ↑Average ↑
a)14.282.13.877.644.4
b)13.579.23.573.842.5
TPR15.284.04.480.045.9

Replacing only the progress input reduces average success by 1.5% (44.4% vs. 45.9%); removing the progress-based reward and gate as well reduces it by 3.4% (42.5% vs. 45.9%). These results support the benefit of explicit progress beyond vision + tactile conditioning, both as a policy input and as a shared signal for reward and gating. We have added the vision–tactile history comparison to the revised manuscript (Sec. 4.4, Table 7, Lines 432–438, 451–456).

W1-2: "...the weaker performance of tactile-based benchmarks could be due to architectural bottleneck, not enough tuning, etc instead of tactile progress..."

A1-2: We agree that architectural and tuning differences across methods may affect the performance gaps between TPR and existing tactile baselines. We have revised the corresponding claims to attribute these gains to the TPR framework as a whole (Lines 292–300, 302–309, 350–356).

Q1: "Why is gating needed if the residual policy can learn to output zero when correction is unnecessary?"

A1: i) Reward design. The task reward contains distance, geometric-shaping, and progress-difference terms, without an explicit penalty on residual magnitude (Eq. 7). It does not explicitly encourage zero residuals when correction is unnecessary; gating directly controls when correction is applied.

ii) Gating benefit. With the same trained checkpoints, always-active correction achieves 60.8% average success, compared with 73.5% under progress gating (Table 6; Lines 430–431). This 12.7% improvement supports explicitly scheduling residual intervention.

Q2: "Why train with gt=1g_t=1 but apply progress gating at deployment, and what happens if this mismatch is removed?"

A2: i) Design rationale. We keep gt=1g_t=1 during training to learn residual corrections without a hard progress threshold. Corrections during contact directly affect task completion, whereas those during approach may have little effect on return and thus receive a weaker learning signal. Progress gating at deployment suppresses these less-constrained approach-phase corrections, separating residual learning from intervention timing (Lines 221–228, 458–461).

ii) Removing the mismatch. We evaluate two matched settings on the four-task ManiFeel subset: always-active correction in both training and deployment, and progress gating in both with the same threshold, gt=1[p^t≥0.75]g_t=\mathbf{1}[\hat p_t\geq0.75].

TrainingDeploymentPeg ↑USB ↑Plug ↑Gear ↑Average ↑
Always activeAlways active4550655954.8
Progress gateProgress gate5058736962.5
Always activeProgress gate5262767265.5

The two matched settings reduce average success by 10.7% (54.8% vs. 65.5%) and 3.0% (62.5% vs. 65.5%), respectively. These results support learning residual corrections without a hard threshold during training and scheduling their application through progress gating at deployment.

We have included this comparison in the revised manuscript (Table 8; Lines 439–444, 458–461).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer hjKc (2/2)

Q3: "Why is vision dropped from the progress estimator as well as the residual policy?"

A3: Vision provides limited cues for fine contact adjustment, where visually similar configurations may require different corrections. In Figure 5, the vision-only estimate saturates before the interaction is complete, while the tactile estimate continues to follow the reference progress. The vision-only estimator also has a higher prediction error (Table 4).

We separately evaluate the effect of adding visual inputs to progress estimation and residual correction.

i) Progress estimator. We additionally augment the tactile estimator with visual inputs, keeping the other settings unchanged.

Progress estimatorMSE ↓
Vision-based0.225
TPR0.0052
Vision + Tactile0.0085

Adding vision increases MSE from 0.0052 to 0.0085, supporting our tactile-based progress estimator. Visual variation unrelated to interaction progress may make it harder to extract the relevant tactile cues.

ii) Residual policy. We also add visual inputs to the residual policy while keeping the other settings unchanged.

MethodPeg ↑USB ↑Plug ↑Gear ↑Average ↑
TPR5262767265.5
TPR + Vision5260767164.8

Adding vision slightly reduces average success by 0.7% (64.8% vs. 65.5%), providing no improvement for residual correction. Visual variation unrelated to contact may interfere with learning fine tactile corrections.

We have added these comparisons with additional visual inputs to the revised manuscript (Sec. 4.4, Figure 5, Tables 4 and 5; Lines 378–385, 393–405, 422–424).

Q4: "how does vision + tactile based curve look? Does it improve over tactile only?"

A4: Please see A3(i) and Figure 5.

Q5: "after base policy is fine tuned on 100 teleop demos, is the residual policy re-trained on top? If so, in sim or in real?"

A5: Yes. We freeze the fine-tuned base policy and retrain the residual policy directly on the real robot using PPO. Each iteration collects 10 episodes and performs 10 PPO epochs, averaging 20 iterations (200 training episodes) per task.

We have clarified the real-world residual training procedure and budget in the revised manuscript (Sec. 4.3; Lines 322–323, 348–349).

Q6: "What is the correction gain? Is it the PD gain of the low level controller?"

A6: No. The correction gain α\alpha scales the mapped residual Δˉj\bar{\Delta}_j before clipping (Eq. 5; Lines 213–220). It controls the magnitude of the correction applied to the base policy’s nominal action when the gate is active.

Reviewer_hjKcOpenReview ↗

Thank you for answering the questions and the additional results

Thank you for thoroughly going through my concerns.

The new results align with my expectations:

  • "vision + tactile history-conditioned residual PPO replacing the progress input while a) retaining the progress-based reward and gate" - this variant is very close to TPR, roughly within 1-2%.
  • The small gain is likely due to the small scale of data. In large data scales, these gains will likely diminish and the network can implicitly extract task progress instead of requiring an external progress signal. This should be explicitly acknowledged in the paper.

My other main remaining concern in the motivating example in figure 1. It argues that tactile is similar in the 4 images. However, vision can clearly distinguish them. I agree with the authors on "Vision captures coarse stages but may miss subtle interaction changes during precision manipulation that tactile progress can distinguish", but the motivating example doesn't show it and is misleading.

Nonetheless, I believe the authors do provide a recipe for a residual policy that can improve the base policy in low data regime. I am willing to update my score to a clear acceptance if the 2 remaining concerns are addressed:

  1. Fix the motivating example
  2. Explicitly acknowledge that one variant is close to TPR and that the gain could be due to low data regime
Reviewer_ajDGOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

To address the ambiguity of similar tactile signals across different stages of contact-rich manipulation, this paper proposes Tactile Progress Residual (TPR), a framework that uses estimated interaction progress to guide local action correction. Specifically, a progress estimator first processes recent tactile observations and robot states to predict a continuous interaction-progress coordinate, learned through weak temporal supervision from recorded trajectories. A residual policy then uses this estimate, local tactile features, robot states, and nominal actions from a frozen base policy to generate bounded action corrections. During residual training, changes in estimated progress provide an auxiliary reward alongside geometric task rewards. During execution, a progress-based gate determines whether the corrections are added to nominal actions, enabling selective refinement during precision manipulation.

Critical strengths

The paper focuses on the problem that similar tactile observations may require different actions at different stages of an interaction, highlighting the limitations of reactive control based solely on instantaneous tactile feedback. Using historical information to provide context for the interaction is well motivated.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The progress estimator is supervised using normalized trajectory time, which may not reliably reflect interaction conditions during pauses, jamming, or retries. Since timeout episodes also end with a target progress of 1, further evidence is needed to show that the estimate remains useful for control in these cases.

  2. Although the reward ablation shows an average performance benefit, increases in estimated progress do not necessarily indicate movement toward task completion. It remains unclear whether inaccurate estimates can reward unproductive behavior during stalled or failed executions.

Questions for authors
  1. Does the estimator track changes in interaction conditions, or does it mainly predict temporal position from familiar robot motion patterns? Could the authors evaluate it under changes in execution speed, pauses, and repeated attempts, and show how its predictions behave during failure recovery?

  2. Appendix B reports gating thresholds of 0.75 for ManiFeel and 0.70 for ManiSkill3. How were these values selected, and how sensitive are the results to them? Does progress-based gating still outperform contact-based gating when both are tuned under the same validation protocol?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer ajDG (1/2)

We thank Reviewer ajDG for the constructive feedback. We have revised the manuscript in light of these comments; please see the revised PDF for details.


W1-1: "The progress estimator... which may not reliably reflect interaction conditions during pauses, jamming, or retries."

A1-1: We collected trajectories involving pauses, jamming, and retries to evaluate the progress estimator. The estimate stagnates during jamming and follows task advancement during retries, indicating that it reflects changes in interaction conditions (Anonymous Video Supplement). We have added the video supplement and corresponding analysis to Appendix D.1 (Lines 1015–1017).

W1-2: "Since timeout episodes also end with a target progress of 1..."

A1-2: The progress estimator is trained on demonstration trajectories (teleoperated demonstrations in the real-world setting, Lines 322–323), which contain no failed or timed-out trajectories. Thus, timeout episodes are not assigned a target progress of 1 during training. We apologize for the potentially misleading wording and have revised the relevant descriptions (Lines 151–155).

W2-1: “increases in estimated progress do not necessarily indicate movement toward task completion.”

A2-1: i) On episodes unseen during training, tactile progress estimates closely follow the reference progress throughout execution, supporting consistent estimation of task advancement on unseen trajectories (Figure 5; Table 4).

ii) During jamming and retries, the estimate stagnates or follows task advancement accordingly, supporting its correspondence with physical advancement toward completion (W1-1).

W2-2: "It remains unclear whether inaccurate estimates can reward unproductive behavior during stalled or failed executions."

A2-2: As shown in W1-1, the estimated progress remains accurate during stalled and failed-retry executions, indicating that it is robust in these cases.

Q1: "Could the authors evaluate estimator under changes in execution speed, pauses, and repeated attempts, and show how its predictions behave during failure recovery?"

A1: i) Pauses and repeated attempts. We simulate pauses by repeating the frame at progress pp for the remainder of the trajectory. We simulate repeated attempts by inserting the reversed segment [b,a][b,a], yielding [start,a]→[a,b]→[b,a]→[a,end][\mathrm{start},a]\rightarrow[a,b]\rightarrow[b,a]\rightarrow[a,\mathrm{end}]. Each setting is evaluated on 150 demonstration trajectories using progress-estimation MSE.

ConditionSettingMSE ↓ConditionSettingMSE ↓
Pausep=0.45p=0.450.0057Repeated attempt[a,b]=[0.45,0.55][a,b]=[0.45,0.55]0.0054
Pausep=0.55p=0.550.0053Repeated attempt[a,b]=[0.55,0.65][a,b]=[0.55,0.65]0.0052
Pausep=0.65p=0.650.0056Repeated attempt[a,b]=[0.65,0.75][a,b]=[0.65,0.75]0.0055
Pausep=0.75p=0.750.0055Repeated attempt[a,b]=[0.75,0.85][a,b]=[0.75,0.85]0.0058
Pausep=0.85p=0.850.0050Repeated attempt[a,b]=[0.85,0.95][a,b]=[0.85,0.95]0.0052

Across all tested settings, MSE remains within 0.0050–0.0058, supporting stable progress estimation under simulated pauses and repeated attempts.

ii) Execution speed. Since offline demonstrations do not allow actual accelerated execution, we vary the estimator’s history sampling rate rr at inference as a proxy and evaluate downstream success on ManiSkill3.

Sampling ratePeg ↑Pick ↑Plug ↑StackCube ↑Average ↑
r=0.5×r=0.5\times14.883.44.279.145.4
r=0.667×r=0.667\times14.983.84.379.845.7
r=1.5×r=1.5\times15.283.74.479.545.7
r=2×r=2\times15.083.64.279.645.6
Nominal (r=1×r=1\times)15.284.04.480.045.9

Average success decreases by at most 0.5%, indicating limited sensitivity to the tested changes in temporal sampling.

iii) visualizations. Please see W1-1.

We have added these experiments (Appendix C.1) and visualizations (Appendix D.1) to the revised manuscript.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer ajDG (2/2)

Q2-1: "gating thresholds... How were these values selected, and how sensitive are the results to them"

A2-1: We select the progress threshold through a hyperparameter sweep, choosing the value with the highest average success rate. To assess sensitivity to this choice, we report performance across the tested thresholds below.

ManiFeelManiSkill3
τ\tauAverage SR (%) ↑τ\tauAverage SR (%) ↑
0.6572.20.6044.7
0.7072.80.6544.8
0.7573.50.7045.9
0.8072.50.7545.2
0.8572.40.8044.9

Average success varies by at most 1.3% on ManiFeel and 1.2% on ManiSkill3 across the tested thresholds, indicating low sensitivity to the exact threshold.

We have added this sensitivity analysis to the revised manuscript (Appendix C.2, Table 12, Lines 856–860).

Q2-2: "Does progress-based gating still outperform contact-based gating when both are tuned under the same validation protocol?"

A2-2: To tune contact-based gating under the same protocol, we computed the average tactile intensity at different progress levels in demonstration trajectories (0.65–0.85 for ManiFeel, 0.60–0.80 for ManiSkill3) and used each intensity as the contact-gate threshold. The results are as follows.

GateManiFeel Average SR (%) ↑ManiSkill3 Average SR (%) ↑
Contact gate (p=0.60p=0.60)—42.1
Contact gate (p=0.65p=0.65)65.943.3
Contact gate (p=0.70p=0.70)67.442.9
Contact gate (p=0.75p=0.75)64.942.5
Contact gate (p=0.80p=0.80)61.842.2
Contact gate (p=0.85p=0.85)62.1—
Progress gate73.545.9

Under the same tuning protocol, the best contact gate trails progress gating by 6.1% on ManiFeel (67.4% vs. 73.5%) and 2.6% on ManiSkill3 (43.3% vs. 45.9%), showing that interaction progress provides a more effective signal for scheduling correction.

We have added this comparison under the same tuning protocol to the revised manuscript (Appendix C.2, Table 10, Lines 861–867).

Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The clarification that the estimator is trained only on successful demonstrations resolves my concern about timeout trajectories receiving a final progress target of 1. The additional evaluations on pauses, jamming, and retries help alleviate my concerns about the usefulness of estimated progress under these conditions. The threshold sensitivity analysis and the comparison with tuned contact-based gating also address my gating-related questions. These additions have improved my assessment of the paper, and I will raise my rating to weak accept.

Thank you for your positive feedback and thoughtful consideration of our responses and additional experiments. We are glad that these clarifications and evaluations have addressed your concerns. We appreciate your constructive suggestions, which have helped us improve the paper.

Reviewer_q7NdOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Tactile Progress Residual (TPR), a progress-aware residual policy for precision robot manipulation. TPR estimates interaction progress from tactile observations and robot states using weak temporal supervision. The estimated progress is used to condition residual action corrections, provide auxiliary rewards, and determine when corrections are activated. Experiments on ManiFeel, ManiSkill3, and real-world manipulation tasks show improvements over existing baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. The proposed method achieves consistent improvements over existing baselines on ManiFeel, ManiSkill3, and real-world manipulation tasks, demonstrating its practical effectiveness.
  2. The paper is well-written and easy to follow. The ablation studies provide useful evidence for the effectiveness of different components.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty of the proposed method is somewhat limited. TPR mainly combines existing techniques, including progress estimation, residual reinforcement learning, and reward shaping. The paper does not sufficiently demonstrate why the explicit progress representation is necessary compared with simpler temporal tactile representations.
  2. The paper lacks important baselines to isolate the contribution of progress estimation. For example, a residual PPO policy directly conditioned on tactile history, without explicit progress estimation, would be a meaningful comparison. The reported improvements may partly come from additional temporal information and residual post-training rather than the proposed progress representation.
  3. The progress estimator is trained using normalized episode time rather than actual physical task progress. Since failed trajectories and timeouts are also assigned high progress values near termination, it is unclear whether the learned progress reflects meaningful physical advancement. Furthermore, the progress-based gating mechanism is not compared with simpler time-based gating strategies.
Questions for authors

See the above weaknesses. In particular, could the authors provide comparisons with history-conditioned residual PPO and time-based gating baselines, and clarify how the estimated progress behaves on failed or recovery trajectories?

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer q7Nd (1/2)

We thank Reviewer q7Nd for the constructive feedback! We respond to each weakness and the question below. We have revised the manuscript accordingly (please see the revised PDF).


W1-1: "The novelty of the proposed method is somewhat limited. TPR mainly combines existing techniques..."

A1-1: We apologize for not making our contribution sufficiently clear. The scope of our research is precision contact-rich manipulation, where similar tactile observations at different interaction stages can require different corrections. Our contribution is to learn one explicit tactile progress coordinate and share it across policy conditioning, auxiliary reward, and deployment gating (Lines 051–059, 101–103; Reviewers jfvc and hjKc).

It is non-trivial to i) learn meaningful interaction progress from tactile observations under weak temporal supervision and ii) use the same coordinate for correction selection, policy learning, and intervention timing, unlike prior progress-aware methods that primarily derive progress from visual or language representations for a specific downstream purpose (Lines 096–103, 151–159). We have revised the relevant descriptions to clarify TPR’s contribution and distinction from prior work (Lines 051–059, 096–103, 466–468).

W1-2: "...not sufficiently demonstrate why the explicit progress representation is necessary compared with simpler temporal tactile representations"

A1-2: i) Our explicit progress scalar supports policy conditioning, progress-difference rewards, and threshold-based gating (Lines 051–059), but tactile history alone does not. ii) We compare TPR with two tactile-history-conditioned residual PPO variants on ManiSkill3 (Sec. 4.4), replacing the progress input while a) retaining the progress-based reward and gate or b) removing both.

Residual variantPeg ↑Pick ↑Plug ↑StackCube ↑Average ↑
a)12.980.83.776.643.5
b)12.778.53.273.041.9
TPR15.284.04.480.045.9

Replacing only the progress input with tactile history reduces average success by 2.4% (43.5% vs. 45.9%), and removing the progress-based reward and gate as well reduces it by 4.0% (41.9% vs. 45.9%). These results support the benefit of explicit progress over a simpler temporal representation.

The comparison between a) and b) further shows that progress-based reward and gating remain beneficial even when the residual policy does not receive the progress scalar as input.

We have added the corresponding comparisons and analysis to clarify the benefit of explicit progress over temporal tactile representations (Table 7; Lines 432–438, 451–456).

W2: "The paper lacks important baselines to isolate the contribution of progress estimation."

A2: Variant b) in W1-2 replaces the progress input with tactile history and removes the progress-based reward and gate, providing a history-conditioned residual PPO baseline to isolate the contribution of explicit progress estimation. Its average success rate is 4.0% lower than TPR (41.9% vs. 45.9%), demonstrating the benefit of explicit progress beyond tactile history and residual post-training.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Reviewer q7Nd (2/2)

W3-1: "...failed trajectories and timeouts are also assigned high progress values near termination"

A3-1: The progress estimator is trained on demonstration trajectories (teleoperated demonstrations in the real-world setting, Lines 322–323), which contain no failed or timed-out trajectories. We apologize for the potentially misleading wording and have revised the relevant descriptions (Lines 151–155).

W3-2: "it is unclear whether the learned progress reflects meaningful physical advancement"

A3-2: i) On episodes unseen during training, tactile progress estimates closely follow the reference progress throughout execution (Figure 5; Table 4), supporting consistent estimation of task advancement on unseen trajectories. ii) To further distinguish interaction progress from elapsed time, we collected stalled and retry trajectories. The estimate stagnates during jamming and follows task advancement during retries, indicating that it reflects meaningful physical advancement rather than elapsed time alone (Anonymous Video Supplement). We have added the video supplement and corresponding analysis to Appendix D.1 (Lines 1015–1017).

W3-3: "the progress-based gating mechanism is not compared with simpler time-based gating strategies."

A3-3: i) Progress gating outperforms contact-triggered activation and always-active correction by 8.6% and 12.7%, respectively, supporting its effectiveness for selective residual intervention (Table 6; Lines 430–431).

ii) We additionally evaluate a time gate that activates at 0.75 times the mean demonstration length in decision steps, corresponding to the progress threshold τ=0.75\tau=0.75. The results are as follows.

Intervention rulePeg ↑USB ↑Plug ↑Gear ↑Nut ↑Bulb ↑Search ↑Ball ↑Average ↑
Always active455065597470606360.8
Contact gate485369647775637064.9
Time gate475267617674616863.3
Progress gate526276728688747873.5

Progress gating outperforms time gating by 10.2% in average success rate (63.3% vs. 73.5%), showing that interaction progress provides a more effective signal for intervention timing than elapsed time.

We have added the time-based gating comparison and corresponding analysis to the revised manuscript to clarify the benefit of progress-based intervention timing (Table 6; Lines 426–431).

Q1-1: "...comparisons with history-conditioned residual PPO and time-based gating baselines."

A1-1: Please see W2 and W3-3.

Q1-2: "how the estimated progress behaves on failed or recovery trajectories?"

A1-2: Please see W3-2.

Reviewer_q7NdOpenReview ↗

Follow-up Response from Reviewer q7Nd

Thank you for your detailed response and additional experiments. I appreciate the new history-conditioned residual PPO baselines and time-based gating comparison, which address several of my previous concerns. The clarification regarding the training trajectories and the additional stalled/retry examples are also helpful.

However, I still have some concerns about the novelty and significance of the proposed method. Although the new experiments demonstrate the benefit of explicit progress estimation, the improvement over the history-conditioned residual PPO baseline is relatively modest (45.9% vs. 41.9%) and is only evaluated in simulation. I would like to see whether this advantage also holds in real-world experiments. Furthermore, the analysis of stalled and recovery trajectories remains largely qualitative, and I believe stronger quantitative evidence is needed to demonstrate that the estimated progress reflects physical task advancement rather than temporal information.

Overall, the rebuttal has addressed some of my concerns, but I remain uncertain whether the methodological contribution is sufficiently significant. Therefore, I would prefer to maintain my original rating.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Reviews and Responses

We thank all reviewers for their time and constructive feedback. We appreciate their feedback on the role of tactile progress (Reviewers q7Nd and jfvc), the reliability of progress estimation (Reviewer ajDG), and the real-world evaluation (Reviewers hjKc and jfvc).

We have made every effort to address the reviewers' concerns and revise the manuscript accordingly. The main revisions are summarized below.

Clarifications on Tactile Progress and Residual Control

  1. Clarified the three roles of tactile progress in TPR (Sec. 5).
  2. Clarified the construction of progress and endpoint targets (Sec. 3.1).
  3. Explained the training gate setting and the choice of correction gains (Secs. 3.2–3.3, Appendix B.2).
  4. Added details on residual policy training on the real robot (Sec. 4.3).

Additional Experiments and Analyses

  1. Evaluated visual inputs for progress estimation and residual control (Sec. 4.4, Tables 4–5).
  2. Compared explicit progress with tactile and visual–tactile histories in a unified ablation (Sec. 4.4, Table 7).
  3. Added a time-based gating baseline and a training and deployment gating ablation (Sec. 4.4, Tables 6 and 8).
  4. Measured progress error under simulated pauses and retries and task success across history sampling rates (Appendix C.1, Tables 9 and 11).
  5. Compared progress and contact gating under the same tuning protocol (Appendix C.2, Table 10).
  6. Added sensitivity analyses for the progress threshold and correction gain (Appendix C.2, Tables 12–13).

Additional Visualizations

  1. Added the visual–tactile estimate to the progress visualization (Sec. 4.4).
  2. Updated the paired success and failure trajectories (Appendix D.1).
  3. Linked an anonymous video supplement showing stalls and retries with synchronized progress estimates (Appendix D.1).

Expanded Discussion

  1. Added a comparison with Compliant Residual DAgger (Sec. 2).
  2. Expanded the analysis of representative failure modes (Appendix D.1).
  3. Discussed limitations of relative-time supervision and continuous gating as future work (Appendix E).

The main changes are highlighted in red in the revised manuscript. Point-by-point replies are provided in the reviewer-specific responses. We welcome further discussion.

Dear Reviewers,

Thank you again for your reviews of this submission. The authors have now posted their responses, and the author–reviewer discussion period ends on November 18, 2026 (AoE).

Please read the authors' rebuttal and let them know whether it addresses your concerns. A short reply is enough, for example:

  • which of your concerns are now resolved;
  • which remain open, and what evidence or clarification would resolve them;
  • whether you plan to update your rating.

If the rebuttal changes your assessment, please update your review and rating before the discussion period ends. If you have already engaged, thank you, and no further action is needed unless the authors reply again.

Your participation is important for a fair and well-informed decision.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.