- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SimpleTouch, a tactile extension of for contact-rich manipulation without additional tactile policy pretraining or a separate visuotactile alignment stage. The method preserves all current tactile tokens from a frozen T3 encoder and uses a tactile expert to provide context for action generation. Multi-horizon future tactile prediction supplies auxiliary supervision during training, while inference uses only current observations. Experiments on six UniVTAC tasks and four real-robot tasks show improvements over the evaluated baselines with 50 demonstrations per task.
Critical strengths
- Learning to use touch from task demonstrations while reusing pretrained VLA and tactile representations is a useful practical direction. SimpleTouch provides a relatively simple recipe and outperforms FTP-1 in average success on both the simulation and real-robot evaluations.
- The separation between predictive supervision and action conditioning is clearly described. The simulation ablations examine spatial tactile detail, encoder freezing, and future prediction, while the Joint/IDM/Fast comparison supports using prediction during training without requiring future tactile generation at deployment.
Critical weaknesses
- The data-efficiency evaluation does not establish how the proposed recipe compares with tactile policy pretraining when task demonstrations are scarce. Section 4.4 compares only with FTP-, which has not undergone tactile policy pretraining. Although the main experiments include FTP-1 at 50 demonstrations, its performance at 10 or 20 demonstrations is not reported. Since reducing the need for additional tactile policy pretraining is central to the paper, this comparison is important for understanding the conditions under which the proposed alternative remains effective.
- The component ablations in Section 4.3 are limited to simulation, leaving the benefit of future tactile prediction on real hardware unverified. Representative real-robot ablations would help isolate the contribution of the proposed tactile learning recipe.
- Appendix B.2 cites related predictive tactile methods, including OmniVTA, Dream-Tac, and UniTacVLA, but provides no experimental comparison with them. The internal Joint/IDM/Fast variants do not reproduce these complete methods and therefore do not establish the relative benefits of SimpleTouch over existing predictive tactile approaches. Direct comparisons with these related methods would strengthen the evidence.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors provide FTP-1 results at the lower demonstration budgets in Figure 6, particularly 10 and 20 demonstrations? This would clarify whether the advantage over a tactile-policy-pretrained model persists when task data are more limited.
- Does removing future tactile prediction reduce real-robot performance when the current-touch pathway and training data are held fixed? A comparison on representative tasks such as Wipe Board or Pick Up Chips would help establish whether the predictive objective contributes beyond the tactile input itself.
- Please supplement the evaluation with direct comparisons against related predictive tactile methods such as OmniVTA, Dream-Tac, and UniTacVLA.
- The authors are encouraged to cite VTAM [1] and TacWAM [2] and briefly clarify their relationship to SimpleTouch. VTAM incorporates touch into a pretrained video model without independent tactile pretraining, while TacWAM uses future tactile supervision without allowing the action branch to directly read future prediction tokens.
[1] Haoran Yuan et al. VTAM: Video-Tactile-Action Models for Complex Physical Interaction Beyond VLAs. arXiv:2603.23481, 2026.
[2] Lei Jin et al. TacWAM: Anchor-Guided World Action Model with Mechanics-Aware Tactile Prediction. arXiv:2607.28391, 2026.
7 comments
2. Prediction Supervision and Hardware Evidence (W2 & Q2)
Unfortunately, organizational and resource changes beyond our control have made the original robot platform unavailable, preventing further hardware ablations. We deeply regret this situation. However, we had already conducted the requested comparison on Pick Up Chips while the platform was available: removing only the future tactile prediction loss, with the current-touch pathway, training data, and all other training and execution settings unchanged, reduced success from 70% (14/20) to 50% (10/20), a 20-pp drop. This agrees with the simulation ablations (Table B, from manuscript Table 3).
Table B. Prediction ablation with current touch fixed (manuscript Table 3; simulation, %).
| Method / metric | Pull-out Key | Put Bottle | Insert Hole | Insert Tube | Mean |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No prediction | 60 | 37 | 83 | 95 | 68.8 |
| Full | 62 | 50 | 85 | 100 | 74.3 |
| Gain (pp) | +2 | +13 | +2 | +5 | +5.5 |
We chose Pick Up Chips because it requires a careful balance between maintaining a stable grasp and avoiding damage to fragile chips. Crushing was the main failure mode after removing prediction supervision. This controlled comparison directly supports a benefit of the predictive objective beyond current tactile input. The failure pattern is also consistent with our motivation: training-time future-touch supervision encourages the shared expert to learn how actions affect subsequent contact, supporting more appropriate grasping actions. In simulation, removing only the prediction loss likewise lowers success on all four tasks, from 74.3% to 68.8% on average.
3. Direct Comparison with Predictive Tactile Methods (W3 & Q3)
We strongly value direct comparisons with these predictive tactile methods and pursued their reproduction before preparing the manuscript. However, OmniVTA has not released its model implementation, and the UniTacVLA repository still states “coming soon.” We also found no public UniVTAC implementations or evaluation results for either method. These missing resources prevented reliable reproduction and fair direct comparisons. For Dream-Tac, a closely related method with a public implementation, we reproduced it using Dream-Tac’s official implementation and training hyperparameters. On UniVTAC, both methods use the same 50 demonstrations per task and are evaluated over 100 trials per task (Table C).
Table C. Dream-Tac vs. SimpleTouch on UniVTAC (success rate, %).
| Method | Pull-out Key | Put Bottle | Insert Hole | Insert Tube | Mean |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dream-Tac | 26 | 44 | 41 | 91 | 50.5 |
| SimpleTouch | 62 | 50 | 85 | 100 | 74.3 |
SimpleTouch outperforms Dream-Tac on all four tactile-sensitive tasks, increasing mean success from 50.5% to 74.3%, a 23.8-pp gain (Table C), further validating the effectiveness of our simple post-training approach. We attribute this advantage to the combination of a strong backbone and effective tactile adaptation: π0.5 provides a strong foundation for vision-language understanding and action generation, while SimpleTouch equips it to act on tactile feedback through encoder freezing, full tactile tokens, and multi-horizon predictive supervision. The comparison with FTP-π0.5 using the same backbone and the controlled ablations further support the roles of these designs (Table 1, Figure 4, and Table 3).
1. Low-Data Evaluation and the Central Question (W1 & Q1)
Thank you for recognizing the practical value of our work. SimpleTouch’s defining feature is simplicity and effectiveness in both architecture and training: it reuses a strong pretrained VLA and an off-the-shelf tactile encoder, adding touch through a single stage of task post-training. Tables 1–2 establish that 50 demonstrations per task suffice to exceed FTP-1 without additional tactile policy pretraining, while substantially outperforming strong baselines that also omit that stage. We provide the main results and controlled ablations below.
New FTP-1 results at 10/20 demonstrations complete the comparison with the original 50-demonstration results. At each budget, methods use identical demonstration subsets and update counts: 4k/8k/20k steps for 10/20/50 demonstrations, respectively, always reporting the final checkpoint and 100 evaluation trials per setting. Both FTP-1 and SimpleTouch improve monotonically from 10 to 50 demonstrations.
Table A shows that SimpleTouch exceeds FTP-1 in all six task–budget settings. At 20 demonstrations, for example, Put Bottle/Insert Hole achieve 38%/57% versus FTP-1's 30%/48%. The performance advantage without additional tactile policy pretraining therefore extends to the 10- and 20-demonstration settings, while the original advantage over FTP-π0.5 is retained.
Table A. Low-data comparison with added FTP-1 results (Figure 6 + new experiments; %; 100 trials per setting).