- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper establishes a connection between Instant-NGP and B-spline functions and proposes a variable-order B-spline encoding method for sparse-view CT reconstruction. The authors provide theoretical analysis of approximation error and evaluate the proposed method on 2D CT reconstruction tasks.
Critical strengths
-
Theoretical analysis of B-spline encoding. The paper provides a useful mathematical analysis of the relationship between Instant-NGP and linear B-splines. It further shows that, under suitable smoothness conditions, increasing the B-spline order can lead to a tighter upper bound on the optimal approximation error. This provides a theoretical motivation for using higher-order B-splines.
-
Consistent improvements across different numbers of views. The experiments show that higher-order B-spline encoders consistently improve reconstruction quality across different view settings. For example, the quartic B-spline achieves higher PSNR than the linear B-spline in the reported lung CT experiments. The CUDA implementation also helps maintain computational efficiency.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited comparison with recent methods. The experiments mainly compare the proposed method with traditional reconstruction methods and earlier neural representation methods, such as SIREN, RDFN, and Instant-NGP. Although most recent works on improving neural representations for CT reconstruction focus on 3D CT, NAB (ICLR 2026) studies an alternative coordinate encoding method for sparse-view 2D CT reconstruction. However, the paper does not compare with NAB or clearly discuss the differences between the two methods.
-
The performance improvements appear relatively modest. Although higher-order B-spline encoders consistently improve reconstruction quality, the gains over the linear B-spline encoder are relatively modest. On the lung dataset, the quartic B-spline improves PSNR by approximately 0.38–0.52 dB across different view settings.
Questions for authors
-
Can the proposed B-spline encoder be integrated into other neural CT reconstruction methods? It would be interesting to explore whether the proposed B-spline encoder can serve as a plug-in replacement for the original coordinate encoder in other frameworks. Consistent improvements across different methods, even if the resulting methods do not achieve the best overall performance, would help demonstrate the compatibility and general applicability of the proposed encoder.
-
Could the authors clarify the relationship between the proposed method and other encoding methods? In particular, how does the variable-order B-spline encoding differ from Freq-NAF and NAB? A clearer discussion would help readers better understand the novelty and advantages of the proposed method. If feasible, a comparison with NAB under the same experimental setting would also help better evaluate its practical value.
I appreciate the authors' efforts and the additional experiments on 95 independent patients. Comparing the proposed method with recent SOTA methods (e.g., NAB) would be a direct way to show its value. If such a comparison is not available, the authors should at least show its value by demonstrating that it works well across different neural CT reconstruction frameworks. However, the new experiments only show that the method generalizes to different patients, not to different reconstruction frameworks. Therefore, I believe the value of the proposed method has not been fully demonstrated, and I maintain my original rating.