- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces RePrior, a sparse-view CBCT framework that incorporates learned priors into Gaussian reconstruction through three stages: (1) Selective Correction Proposal (SCP) selects and scales local prior-derived corrections; (2) Measurement-Constrained Reconciliation (MCR) jointly reconciles these corrections with observed X-ray measurements; and (3) Hybrid Residual Enhancement (HRE) combines voxel- and Gaussian-domain residual refinement while preserving measurement consistency.
Critical strengths
-
This paper addresses a meaningful problem in prior-assisted CBCT reconstruction: how to benefit from learned anatomical information without unconditionally transferring every prior-induced change into the final volume. Its distinction between local correction utility and patient-specific measurement compatibility provides a useful perspective on combining learned priors with Gaussian reconstruction.
-
This paper provides a valuable discussion of the limitations of prior-guided sparse-view reconstruction. The problem analysis distinguishes spatially varying prior reliability from conflicts between volumetric improvement and projection fitting. The reported observation that 43.3% of the analyzed volumetrically beneficial candidates worsen observed-view projection error provides concrete motivation for treating these as separate problems and helps explain why direct prior supervision may be insufficient.
-
The proposed framework connects learned correction proposals with patient-specific measurements. MCR accounts for interactions between correction responses in projection space rather than treating each local correction independently. HRE further evaluates candidate volumes using the production voxelizer and forward model before acceptance. These choices are technically well motivated and provide a controlled way to explore additional corrections under the specified measurement constraints.
-
Although further quantitative and qualitative validation is needed to clarify the nature and reliability of the improvements, the reported results show promising gains in reconstruction quality over the evaluated baselines.
Critical weaknesses
-
The current experiments compare RePrior mainly with projection-driven reconstruction methods such as SAX-NeRF, X-Gaussian, R²-GS, and Exact-GS. These are useful reference points, but RePrior additionally benefits from a pretrained volumetric model and a ground-truth-supervised correction predictor. It therefore remains unclear whether the reported improvements demonstrate an advantage of the proposed correction strategy over other ways of incorporating learned priors. The DeepSparse-25 baseline is helpful, but its direct prediction does not replace comparisons with prior-assisted optimization methods. Could the authors include relevant approaches such as DiffNR, DiffusionMBIR [1], and DDIP/D3IP[2] (DDIP3D) under matched acquisition conditions, while clearly reporting differences in training-data access, test-time adaptation, and computational cost? In particular, DiffNR is already discussed in Section 2.3 but is absent from the experiments.
-
The Gaussian reconstruction is already optimized using spatial supervision from the DeepSparse prediction , so the two inputs are not independent estimates and may share the same errors. Defining ground-truth-derived targets for correction selection and magnitude during training does not, by itself, establish that useful corrections can be distinguished from prior bias using the observable input features at test time. In particular, Eq. (35), , produces zero SCP correction at locations where both inputs have the same erroneous value. Although MCR and HRE introduce additional correction freedom, the current evaluation does not sufficiently demonstrate whether these stages actually correct such shared errors. Could the authors distinguish cases where the prior contains incorrect structures from cases where both inputs miss the same structure, and provide stage-wise evidence showing how these errors are handled?
-
It is difficult to assess the reliability of SCP’s selection mechanism from input discrepancy maps and final reconstruction images alone. At minimum, the authors should provide correction-selection maps showing which patches are accepted or rejected, together with the applied coefficient maps. These decisions should be compared post hoc with the ground-truth-derived patch-level actionability labels and the actual change in reconstruction error. Signed correction maps should separately indicate attenuation increases and decreases, since these signs do not represent acceptance and rejection. Moreover, agreement with a patch-level actionability label does not establish that every voxel benefits from the applied correction. Such an analysis would clarify whether SCP genuinely retains useful corrections and suppresses harmful ones, rather than relying on aggregate improvements to support this claim.
-
The most apparent visual improvements in Figure 5 seem to concern artifact reduction and a cleaner local appearance. Although some boundaries appear better defined, the examples do not clearly establish whether the correction stages recover specific structures missing from the prior-assisted reconstruction, rather than primarily transferring cleaner information already present in DeepSparse. The omission of the matched Prior-R²-GS baseline from the qualitative panels further limits this assessment. Could the authors provide enlarged comparisons of the DeepSparse prior, Prior-R²-GS, intermediate stages, final reconstruction, and ground truth under identical display settings? These comparisons should examine vessels or fine bone structures that are missing or incorrectly represented in the inputs, distinguishing recovery of true anatomy from propagation or introduction of structures absent from the ground truth. The current images do not demonstrate that hallucinations occur, but they are insufficient to assess this important failure mode.
[1]. Chung, H., Ryu, D., McCann, M. T., Klasky, M. L., & Ye, J. C. (2023, June). Solving 3d inverse problems using pre-trained 2d diffusion models. In 2023 IEEE/CVF conference on computer vision and pattern recognition (CVPR) (pp. 22542-22551). IEEE.
[2]. Chung, Hyungjin, and Jong Chul Ye. "Deep diffusion image prior for efficient ood adaptation in 3d inverse problems." European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024.
Questions for authors
Could the authors address the concerns raised in the Critical Weaknesses section with clarifications and supporting evidence?