- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Gaussian splatting method for CT reconstruction which works with fixed number of Gaussians, instead of using threshold-based density control. Main idea is to make each Gaussian as a slice of higher-dimensional Gaussian mixture, therefore splitting and merging can happen in continuous way during optimization. Authors also add a reallocation step under same budget and some adaptive rules for initialization and loss weights. Experiments show the method is better than R2-Gaussian at same kernel count, and the gap becomes larger when the budget increases.
Critical strengths
-
Exact control of the kernel count is useful in practice and it makes a controlled comparison across budgets possible. The budget sweep in Fig. 3 is one of the convincing part for me, since Lifted-GS is better than R2-Gaussian by about 0.7 to 1.9 dB at the largest budget on all four volumes while R2-Gaussian saturates.
-
The gain at the default matched count is small but consistent overall, including the real FIPS scans at 25 views. At ADC threshold 2e-4, R2-Gaussian almost does not densify (about 50.2k Gaussians), and Lifted-GS is still better by 0.37 to 0.68 dB while using about half of the initial points.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main claim is not really isolated by the experiments. Since x_ik and A_ik are free per component, the sliced field is the same function class as B plain 3D Gaussians, and c is redundant with the auxiliary means (shifting c and all b_ik together gives exactly the same field). So the benefit can only come from optimization dynamics, but this is not analyzed. Also the final method still relies on PAGR, which is a discrete hard selection with its own thresholds, and the comparison with R2-Gaussian changes initialization, loss, optimizer settings and fixed count at once. The only isolating evidence is one row of Table 3, on single volume and single seed with unspecified view count, so I am not convinced the lifting itself is the source of the improvement.
-
Several numbers in the tables do not match the appendix figures, and this matters because many margins in Table 1 are only 0.01 to 0.1 dB with one seed. Colon 75 and 180 views SSIM are swapped between two methods compared with Fig. 7 and Fig. 5/14, head-and-neck 25 views PSNR is 34.23/34.22 in Table 1 but 34.22/34.24 in Fig. 10, seashell 25 views SSIM of Lifted-GS is 0.9411 vs 0.9391 in Fig. 12, and seashell 75 views PSNR of R2-Gaussian is 43.99 vs 44.40. All of these differences go in favor of the proposed method. Table 2 also seems to pick the best points with different rules for two methods (R2-Gaussian SSIM 0.9507 and 0.9654, but 0.9517 and 0.9668 in Fig. 5/6). In current form, it is hard to trust the reported numbers.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify which values are correct for the mismatches between Table 1/2 and Fig. 5, 6, 7, 10, 12, 14, 15, and which view count and kernel count are used in Table 3.
-
Could you report a plain fixed-count 3D Gaussian baseline with the same initialization, loss and optimizer, and also a variant with c and d frozen?
-
If I understand correctly, PAGR runs only once at iteration 10k. How many mixtures are reallocated, and how often does the check in Eq. 9 actually fail? Since all amplitudes are nonnegative and the projection is linear, the relative L1 change seems close to the mass fraction (at most zeta = 0.01), which is already below tau_D = 0.05.
-
Which scans pass the stability gate in Sec. 4.4, and what alpha is used for each scan? For the simulated data with exact geometry, I guess alpha is always 0.5.
-
Results with multiple seeds, runtime and memory, a budget sweep under sparse views (25 or 50 views), and comparison with fixed-budget strategies such as 3DGS-MCMC or Taming 3DGS adapted to CT would make the paper much stronger.
Responses to the questions
Thank you very much for pointing out our oversight. Regarding the method section, as noted in "Overview of Revisions and Additions 1," we have revised the descriptions to eliminate redundancy, re-conducted experiments, and verified the experimental data. Furthermore, as mentioned in "Overview of Revisions and Additions 4," we have expanded the scope of our ablation studies and included additional analysis of the optimization process.
A1: We re-conducted the experiment and verified the experimental data.
A2: We have added ablation experiments on shared/independent amplitude A and shared/independent centers to analyze their effects. (Table 4) We also conducted comparative experiments on R2 without ADC in optimization dynamics. Compared with the lifted kernel under the same initialization conditions, without PAGR, amplitude initialization, and adaptive loss function, the Lifted kernel still outperforms R2 without ADC in convergence. (Figure 6)
A3:Yes, PAGR is performed once per training run, at iteration 10,000. The contribution cap ζ=0.01 limits the candidates’ cumulative integrated contribution to 1% of the total, rather than selecting 1% of the mixtures. Consequently, a relatively large number of low-contribution mixtures can be reallocated. Across the 40 runs covering all ten volumes at 50 and 180 views under the default and highest tested budgets, the reallocated mixtures accounted for an average of approximately 13.1% and 8.7% of all mixtures, respectively. All 40 runs passed the check in Eq. 9 on the first attempt with τD=0.05. When we replayed the same checkpoints with the tighter threshold τD=0.01, 18 of the 40 cases failed the initial check, triggering one halving of ζ.
A4: For the four cases from TCIA, the values are generally around 0.5. In the AAPM dataset, the loss function weights for L192 reach 0.6685 and 0.6179. In the FIPS dataset, the value for "pine" is 0.5/0.5 at the 25 view, while it is higher than this at other angles; at the 75 and 180 views, the values for all three FIPS cases increase to 0.8.
A5: As analyzed in "Overview of Revisions and Additions 2, 4", we have expanded the data analysis to include training duration and peak GPU memory usage, and added comparative curves for different Gaussian kernel budgets under 50 views. Due to time constraints, we were unable to conduct multiple sub-experiments for all trials and adapted experiments with 3DGS-MCMC or Taming 3DGS.