- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a new method for sparse-view CT reconstruction through integrating rays per detector-square area, and additionally two other regularizers, a material-coupled response and a low-bandwidth correction. The paper demonstrates these on two anthropomorphic phantoms and compares with 6 other baselines, showing good performance.
Critical strengths
The paper develops a forward operator suitable for this CT projection problem and uses it for image reconstruction.
The paper compares it with existing baselines and shows good performance.
Critical weaknesses
- While the paper sells the "area-integration" over the rays as the primary contribution (the CAA), the ablation study in Fig 6 shows little benefit of this particular addition. The CAA seems to add the least benefit, and more benefit seems to be derived from the MCR and DPS. However, this could be made more clear with 1) error maps compared to ground truth for each ablation point and 2) metrics. Authors should add these analyses.
Questions for authors
None.
4 comments
Follow-up to Reviewer 2wtn: Additional Experimental Results and Revision Summary
Dear Reviewer 2wtn,
We would be grateful if you could review our response and the expanded ablation analysis in the revised manuscript. Your suggestion led us to add two center-ray controls, yielding six configurations with quantitative metrics and FDK-referenced signed difference maps (Table 3, Fig. 6).
The revised analysis compares CAA enabled and disabled at three fixed MCR/DPS settings. CAA reduces LPIPS in all three paired comparisons, including an improvement from 0.569 to 0.544 when both MCR and DPS are active. The paired reconstructions also show a more distinct scan-table boundary with CAA. These comparisons make CAA’s contribution more explicit alongside the vessel delineation and soft-tissue uniformity effects associated with MCR and DPS.
We would appreciate your feedback on whether these additions address your concerns. If any questions or concerns remain, please let us know; we would be pleased to respond promptly and provide further clarification.
Thank you once again for devoting your time and expertise to reviewing our paper. We sincerely appreciate your constructive feedback, which has helped us strengthen both the presentation and experimental evaluation of our work.
Sincerely,
The authors of Submission 38290
Thank you! Your quantitative analysis in the rebuttal looks good to me and addressed my concerns. I will increase my score to a 4 (clear acceptance)
Thanks to Reviewer 2wtn
Dear Reviewer 2wtn,
Thank you very much for taking the time to carefully review our responses and revised manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful consideration and are pleased that the expanded quantitative analysis has addressed your concerns.
Your suggestion to provide metrics and difference maps for each ablation configuration led to a more informative evaluation and helped us explain the contributions of CAA, MCR, and DPS more clearly. These additions have meaningfully strengthened our paper.
We hope that this work contributes to the development of practical self-supervised CT reconstruction methods for real measurement data and provides a useful starting point for further research.
Thank you once again for the time and care you have devoted to reviewing our work. We are sincerely grateful for your constructive feedback, which has helped us improve experimental evaluation of our paper.
Sincerely,
The authors of Submission 38290
Response to Reviewer 2wtn
Thank you for recognizing the forward model and the comparison with existing reconstruction methods. We appreciate your suggestion to provide error maps and quantitative metrics for each ablation configuration. We agree that the original cumulative ablation did not sufficiently distinguish CAA’s contribution from those of MCR and DPS.
[W1] Clarifying CAA’s contribution through expanded ablations
Following your suggestion, we added two center-ray controls, expanding the analysis to six configurations. The revised Fig. 6 and Table 3 now compare CAA enabled and disabled at three fixed MCR/DPS settings, with quantitative metrics and signed difference maps relative to the 720-view FDK reference after global affine intensity alignment.
CAA reduces LPIPS in all three paired comparisons on the 50-view Lungman scan, while its effects on MANIQA and vessel Dice depend on the configuration. Each entry below reports CAA off → CAA on, with the MCR/DPS settings held fixed.
CAA’s clearest local effect is improved scan-table boundary visibility. In the rightmost column of Fig. 6, where both MCR and DPS are active, the boundary is faint with CAA disabled and more distinct with CAA enabled. This boundary lies outside both the lung ROI used for vessel Dice and the common field of view used for the difference maps. Its improvement is therefore shown directly in the reconstruction insets, separately from the reported quantitative comparisons.
The expanded analysis also clarifies the complementary effects of MCR and DPS. Reading across the lower half of Fig. 6, adding MCR to CAA makes pulmonary vessels more distinct and increases vessel Dice from 0.736 to 0.752. Adding DPS then improves the uniformity of posterior soft tissue near the spine, although the signed map shows a broad difference from FDK in this region. The radial profiles in Appendix Sec B.1, Fig. 8b explain this behavior: FDK itself exhibits cupping, so a flatter soft-tissue profile can increase local disagreement with that reference. The full configuration also achieves the highest reference-free MANIQA score in Table 3.
We have revised Sec. 5.3 to explain these distinct contributions and their metric-dependent effects more clearly. We thank the reviewer for the suggestion, which helped us make the ablation analysis more informative.
We hope that the revised manuscript and additional analyses satisfactorily address your concerns. We would be pleased to clarify any remaining points or provide further details as needed. We sincerely thank you for your careful assessment and constructive feedback, which have helped strengthen the presentation and evaluation of our work.