- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper decouples the measurement operator / acquisition model from the representation design of INRs. Under fixed representation, fixed measurement, and fixed optimization steps, it compares point acquisition and Gaussian-pixel spatial acquisition. Using PSNR, spatial error maps and spectral error, the authors demonstrate that the acquisition model systematically alters continuous-field recovery. And they claim that acquisition modeling should be treated as a design axis on par with representation.
Critical strengths
- The problem studied in this paper is practically meaningful, and the chosen angle is worthwhile.
- The experiments yield reasonably consistent results.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is limited. The core findings lack clear distinctions from existing theories and methods. Finite-support acquisition, pixel integration, anti-aliasing, and measurement-aware reconstruction are not new concepts. Related ideas have already been developed in Thera, mip-NeRF, and sampling theory.
- The experiments suffer from acquisition-model mismatch, which weakens the interpretability of the main results. The main experiments use the Gaussian–pixel operator to generate observations. However, the Point baseline interprets these observations as point samples, whereas the Spatial method adopts the correct forward operator. Consequently, the performance gains may partly stem from properly modeling the physical observation process, rather than from a novel insight for INR reconstruction.
- The coverage of experimental tasks and acquisition models is limited, and stronger mechanistic evidence is lacking. Although four architectures are tested, all main experiments are restricted to natural image reconstruction and rely primarily on one synthetic Gaussian–pixel kernel.
- The computational overhead is substantial, and a sufficient efficiency–performance analysis is missing. Training time for spatial acquisition is roughly 9–24 times that of point acquisition, with peak GPU memory consumption increased by approximately 26–35 times.
- The writing and presentation are poor. Figure 1 appears too early in the manuscript, making it difficult to grasp its intended message. Additionally, the * symbol in Eq (4) is left undefined, with no specification of the operation it represents.
Questions for authors
Please refer to weaknesses.
4 comments
C4. Computational overhead. The computational cost reported in the submission is based on quadrature. We further evaluate quadrature, which retains 88–97% of the reconstruction gain across all four INR families, while reducing training time to 2.5–4.9$\times$ that of point supervision, with no increase in peak GPU memory (Tables R6–R7). (Appendix A, L. 715–717, Table 2; Appendix D, L. 813–816, Table 6; Sec. 7, L. 514–515)
We also examine whether additional training or model capacity can close the performance gap. Even after training the point model for 54,142 steps (18$\times$ the original number) or increasing its parameters by 2$\times$ and 4$\times$, spatial supervision maintains a mean PSNR advantage of 1.53–1.83 dB, improving all 24 images (Table R15). The inference cost remains unchanged, as the acquisition operator is used only during training.
Table R15: Capacity and optimization controls (Appendix F of the paper): Spatial minus each enlarged Point model; FINER, Kodak-24, .
| Point model | Spatial ahead by (dB) | Images where Point wins |
|---|---|---|
| 54,142 steps (18$\times$ original) | 0/24 | |
| 2$\times$ parameters | 0/24 | |
| 4$\times$ parameters | 0/24 |
C5. Presentation. We have defined as two-dimensional convolution in Eqs. (4)–(5), with and , and use consistent notation for the observation and reconstruction operators throughout the paper. ( defined at L. 203)
Thanks for your response and new experiments. Most of my concerns are addressed. But I don't know why you only include image fitting in the main text. I think that adaptation to other kinds of INR tasks is important. Overall, I decide to raise my score from 1 to 2.
Thank you for reconsidering our submission and for the helpful suggestion. We agree that results on other INR tasks are important. In the paper, these results are discussed in Sec. 5.1 (L. 349–361), and the corresponding tables are provided in the appendix (Tables 14–19). Given the space budget, we kept the main text focused on the central question of the paper so that its argument remains clear. We appreciate your time and feedback throughout the discussion.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical relevance of the problem and the consistency of the results. We address each concern below.
C1. Novelty relative to Thera, mip-NeRF and sampling theory. Thera and mip-NeRF incorporate the pixel footprint into their architectures, through the activation function in Thera and the input encoding in mip-NeRF. Our study examines a different question: how does acquisition supervision affect reconstruction when the representation and optimization remain fixed? (Sec. 2, L. 134–140) While sampling theory establishes the importance of prefiltering, it does not explain how different INR architectures respond to acquisition supervision across sampling densities. We investigate these differences through controlled experiments (Table 1; Tables R10 and R14). We further demonstrate the practical relevance of this analysis by improving existing INR pipelines without changing their representations, obtaining +0.81 dB for SuperF and +0.44 dB for FINER's NeRF pipeline (Table R8). These results establish the value of studying acquisition supervision independently of representation design, with four main findings summarized in our response to Reviewer dAYP (C3).
C2. Acquisition-model mismatch. The acquisition-consistency control reveals an important interaction between acquisition choice, sampling density, and INR architecture. Under sparse sampling (×4), spatial acquisition consistently outperforms genuine point acquisition across all four INR families (+0.90 to +1.29 dB; Appendix E), demonstrating that the advantage observed in our main experiments is not solely attributable to the mismatched point baseline. However, at denser sampling, the results become architecture-dependent, and point acquisition can outperform spatial acquisition. These findings show that the effectiveness of spatial acquisition depends on the sampling regime and representation, rather than being universally superior. This provides further evidence that acquisition modeling should be considered an independent design axis in INR reconstruction. (Sec. 4, L. 246–249; Sec. 5.1, L. 321–323, 349–350; Appendix E, L. 869–873, Table 8)
We further examine whether these improvements require precise knowledge of the acquisition operator. Across five acquisition kernels, spatial supervision using the corresponding operator achieves the highest mean PSNR, with gains of +0.40 to +1.39 dB over point supervision on all eight images per kernel. Even a simple box operator, without knowledge of the blur, improves reconstruction under all five kernels by +0.38 to +0.46 dB (Table R4). (Appendix I, L. 983–989, Table 14) Spatial supervision also maintains a positive mean gain when the assumed Gaussian width differs from the true width by up to 30% (Appendix B).
The practical importance of acquisition supervision is further demonstrated by improvements of +0.81 dB in SuperF and +0.44 dB in FINER's NeRF pipeline, without changing their representations (Table R8). Our contribution is therefore to establish acquisition supervision as an independent design axis for INRs and show how its effect depends on the representation and sampling density, rather than simply confirming the known importance of an accurate forward model. (Sec. 5.1, L. 358–361; Appendix J, L. 1057–1069, Table 19)
C3. Coverage and mechanistic evidence. We have extended the evaluation to ×8 super-resolution, the WIRE SISR protocol, image denoising, and NeRF novel-view synthesis (Tables R1–R3). We also evaluate five acquisition kernels and an anisotropic Gaussian (Tables R4–R5), and expand the comparison to seven INR families and a classical B-spline representation (Tables R9–R10). (Sec. 5.1, L. 317–320, 352–361; Appendices H–J)
To better understand these improvements, we provide additional spectral and spatial analyses. The Fourier residual spectrum shows that most of the error reduction occurs within the measurement bandwidth and across all orientations (Figure 5, Tables R11–R12). The spatial analysis further shows that edges and textured regions account for the overall error reduction (Figure 4, Table R13). (Sec. 5.2, L. 397–407; Sec. 5.3, L. 411–421; Appendices G and K)