- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MPR-Flow reconstructs a fixed image as measurements accumulate. It combines acquisition-dependent warm starts with reflected noise coupling, which refreshes noise in measured directions and reverses it in the measurement nullspace. Experiments on progressive inpainting, random sensing, synthetic DNA AFM, and retrospective MRI report substantial improvements over independently restarted flow solvers at matched per-stage network budgets, alongside runtime savings.
Critical strengths
- Substantial empirical gains across several operators without retraining the prior. With ten evaluations per stage, MPR-Flow improves 30% inpainting from 26.1 to 32.0 dB and noiseless MRI from the strongest baseline’s 32.2 to 36.1 dB. Shared priors, component ablations, and measured runtime comparisons make the efficiency results promising.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution beyond straightforward continuation is insufficiently isolated. All main baselines restart at every acquisition. It shows that ADWS accounts for most of the improvement, e.g., for random sensing, 14.7 to 24.2 dB, versus 25.1 dB for the complete method. There is no tuned fixed-start continuation control or empirical comparison with continued FLOWER, despite Appendix A.2 describing that adaptation. Consequently, the benefit of the proposed acquisition-dependent schedule over simpler state reuse remains unclear.
-
The data-consistency update is not reproducible as written. The fidelity divides by measurement-noise variance, yet experiments include zero noise, where this expression is undefined. For noisy experiments, the reported step schedule also lacks an explicit normalization compensating for this variance scaling. This may be an omitted implementation convention rather than an implementation error, but it needs clarification because it directly determines the algorithm.
Questions for authors
-
Clarification: What exact fidelity loss, noise floor, and gradient scaling were implemented, particularly for MRI with sigma=0 and 0.03?
-
Assessment-critical comparison: How does MPR-Flow perform against tuned constant-time continuation and ADWS applied to FLOWER under matched computation? These comparisons would materially affect my assessment of the methodological contribution.
4 comments
W2 + Q1. Concerns about the data consistency step
Thank you for identifying this inconsistency. In the manuscript the data-fidelity term was incorrectly reusing the noise-normalized fidelity from the inverse-problem introduction. The implementation, uses the the unnormalized least-squares fidelity to compute the data fidelity.
with gradient
The implemented data-consistency update is therefore a gradient step in the direction of the data consistency
x_{s,n} - \eta(\tau_{s,n}) A_s^\ast(A_sx_{s,n}-y_s).$$ There is no inverse-variance factor, variance floor, or additional gradient normalization applied, and the same expression is used for noiseless and noisy measurements, including both MRI problems.Response to the rebuttel
Dear authors,
Thank you for the clarification and additional experiments.
The unnormalized data-fidelity formulation resolves my concern afbout the update specification.
The added fixed warm-start and continued FLOWER comparisons support incremental benefits from ADWS and RNC, although the acquisition-dependent schedule contributes relatively modest gains in MRI. One clarification remains useful: whether the fixed starting time was independently tuned using a comparable search budget. Could you clarify how the fixed starting time was selected and whether it received comparable tuning.
Clarification on the warm start selection
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your response, the fixed starting time was tuned and selected using the same grid as ADWS, as we now clarify on Table 3, for both alpha and time with the same parameter grid was used on a different held out set of 128 images.
In general we observe the best performing value of the fixed warm start solver be equal or lower than the best performing value for ADWS, with the biggest differences in PSNR coming from the problems where the values of the warm starting time differ, which might hint at some of the benefit being due to ADWS allowing later stating times to retain stability.
Also we suspect the reason why we might not see a big difference for the MRI problem might be due to the fact that the initial MRI measurement carrying more information, due to the initial calibration contributing 31 lines in the k space, while subsequent stages add only 10 each.
W1 + Q2. Isolation of contribution beyond continuation.
We thank the reviewer for allowing us to clarify this point. First, we agree that warm start brings the biggest performance increase. However, as detailed in the theoretical guarantees added to the appendix, warm start shows great synergy with RNC, which is illustrated by the consistent gains brought by ADWS+RNC compared with ADWS alone cf. Tab. 2 of the manuscript: +1 PSNR on inpainting 10%, +1.8 on inpainting 30%, 0.8 PSNR on noisy MRI. To further illustrate ADWS's good properties, we also added the following comparison between fixed warm start and ADWS both including RNC and using the settings from Tab. 2.
To further detail the gain brought by ADWS, we present the following ablation comparing PnP-Flow with a fixed warm start, with and without RNC, to MPR-Flow.
ADWS shows consistent gains over a fixed warm start. ADWS brings more gains on inpainting 10% (+0.77 PSNR) and random matrix unmixing (+0.6 PSNR). MPR-Flow improves PSNR over fixed time warm start by 1.64, 1.30, 1.11, 0.81, and 0.92 dB for each of the inverse problems respectively.
In addition we expanded our experiments to FLOWER under matched computation.
Here also, the same conclusion remains: warm start brings large gains compared to Flower only, while ADWS and RNC both add consistent gains over each task.