- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CoroNeRF, which jointly reconstructs 3D coronal electron density and temperature from multiview, multiline observations through a differentiable atomic-emission model. It demonstrates that low image error can coexist with inaccurate physical fields and evaluates cross-seed variability as an error-localization signal, including its limitations under shared forward-model mismatch.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an important scientific reconstruction problem by directly evaluating physical-field accuracy and demonstrating the limitations of image-space validation.
-
The error-localization analysis includes meaningful controls for signal strength, radial structure, and seed stability. The explicit model-mismatch experiments also help establish when ensemble disagreement becomes unreliable.
Critical weaknesses
-
All experiments use a single synthetic scene that also guided architecture and loss selection. The shared numerical renderer for data generation and inversion further limits evidence that the findings extend beyond this tuned simulation setting.
-
The main representation comparison supplies ground-truth temperature and reconstructs only density. It therefore does not establish the effectiveness of the proposed joint density–temperature reconstruction relative to reasonable joint-inversion baselines.
Questions for authors
-
With the architecture and loss fixed, do reconstruction accuracy and error-localization performance persist on an independent coronal scene? This would substantially affect my assessment of the robustness of the findings.
-
How does CoroNeRF compare with a joint grid-based or MLP baseline under the same four-channel observations, when both density and temperature are unknown?
2 comments
Followup to LoFS
Hi Reviewer LoFS,
Since the discussion period closes tomorrow, we wanted to follow up. You wrote that independent-scene results would substantially affect your assessment on the robustness of the results in your first Question: we reported them in our reply above, in Section 5.3 of the updated manuscript, and also Tables 21-22 in the Appendix. And we also reported joint baseline results (your Question 2) where both density and temperature are unknown, in Section 5.1 and Appendix D.2 of the updated manuscript. We would be grateful to know whether or not these address your concerns, and are happy to clarify any points before the discussion period ends. Thanks again!
Response to Reviewer LoFS
Hi Reviewer LoFS,
Thanks for the two precise requests! We ran both experiments you asked for. Below, we first summarized the 4 main changes in our revision, and then detailed how they relate to each of your two points. The Sections here refer to the latest revised PDF.
Summary of the revision
Held-out scene (Sec. 5.3, App. D.9): the noiseless and η=9 ensembles are repeated on a second ground truth MAS cube (CR2290) with the rest of the pipeline frozen. The inner-band MAE rises by 16-29%, and the correlations and nAUSE change by at most 0.05.
Quadrature mismatch (Sec. 4, App. D.8): We rerendered the observed data at 4x finer step than the inversion (1/1024 vs 1/256). The field MAE rises by around 2%, and every localization metric stays within the matched 95% interval.
Joint baselines (Sec. 5.1, App. D.2): a grid (w/ and w/o Tikhonov regularization) and an MLP now invert density and temperature jointly (we removed the density-only baselines and briefly mentioned it at the end of App. D.2). The inner-band MAEs for the baselines are as follows (ne / Te): hash grid is 0.039 / 0.014 dex, MLP is 0.063 / 0.022, and regularized grid is 0.145 / 0.046. At approximately matched training time, the hash grid is still 1.3x and 2.5x more accurate for density.
Deployable control (Sec. 5.2, App. C.1): we implemented b^E, the inverse emissivity of the reconstructed ensemble mean (as opposed to bE, which is the GT inverse emissivity). The nAUSE is 0.11-0.30 for σens vs 0.48-1.11 for b^E across the matched-model conditions.
Weakness 1 / Question 1, independent scene (item 1 in summary; Tables 21-22). We also summarized the values below in a compact table for you, for density / temperature. CR2283 is the original development scene, and CR2290 is the new scene.
Note: both scenes share the same solar-cycle phase by design, but are separated by about 7 rotations with largely unrelated density structures.
Weakness 1, shared numerical renderer (item 2 in summary; Tables 19-20).
Weakness 2 / Question 2, joint baselines (item 3 in summary; Table 13).
You noted that Question 1 would substantially affect your assessment of the robustness of the findings. We hope that these revisions address it, and we would be very grateful if you could take them into account in your updated assessment. Thanks again!