- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CoSGF, a 4D Gaussian representation for reconstructing high-resolution scientific fields from coarse numerical measurements and scientific visualizations. Both observation types constrain a shared physical field, while physics-guided refinement is restricted to weakly observed directions to preserve the available evidence. The method is evaluated on four scientific datasets at 4x and 8x reconstruction, showing improvements over existing methods, particularly at 8x, with supporting ablations and qualitative comparisons.
Critical strengths
Combining coarse numerical observations and scientific visualizations to reconstruct a shared physical field is an interesting idea. The use of Gaussian primitives to represent physical variables rather than appearance is also meaningful, particularly for scientific reconstruction where fine-scale information is often unavailable. The sensitivity-based approach to prevent physics-driven updates from overriding observed information is a useful contribution. The quantitative results are encouraging, especially at 8x reconstruction. For example, isotropic turbulence improves from 20.99 dB to 25.99 dB over PINGS-X. The ablations also show that physical refinement and observation protection contribute to the method.
Critical weaknesses
CoSGF uses both numerical measurements and scientific visualizations, while it is unclear whether the compared baselines receive equivalent information. Since the visualizations are generated from the high-resolution reference field, they provide additional information beyond the coarse numerical observations. This is a reasonable reconstruction setting, but the comparison should make this distinction clearer. Moreover, removing visualization supervision decreases 8x PSNR only from 30.66 to 30.54 dB in Table 4. This raises a question about how much of the reported improvement comes specifically from complementary observations rather than the representation or optimization.
Questions for authors
-
Do the compared baselines have access to the same visualization observations? If not, could the authors clarify how much of the improvement is attributable to the additional information versus the proposed reconstruction method?
-
Table 2 reports results over 20 runs. Are these independent runs, and can the authors provide the corresponding variability? Also, could the authors clarify the missing Tangaroa configuration in Table 1?
-
How is the observation sensitivity operator in Eq. (13) computed in practice? Is the constrained update solved directly or approximately, and how are the observation leakage thresholds selected?
2 comments
Thanks for your detailed response. It addresses some of my concerns. I will maintain my positive score.
Response to Reviewer c4VS
W1 / Q1. Do baselines receive the same visualizations, and how much of the gain comes from additional information?
In the original submission, baselines used LR numerical observations only and did not receive the retained visualization images. Their native network formulations do not support the differentiable-rendering input used by CoSGF. The current comparison is limited to the completed LR-only baseline results and the CoSGF ablations.
Table 4 measures the incremental effect of visualization within the same representation and optimization. The 8× PSNR changes from 30.66 to 30.54 dB, and the 4× result changes from 33.07 to 32.99 dB. LPIPS changes from 0.142 / 0.168 to 0.176 / 0.203. The relative contribution of each modality depends on the dataset and metric. LR measurements and physical constraints can dominate field-level PSNR, while visualization supplies complementary information about fine-scale structures. The shared-field and protection ablations provide the completed method evidence.
Q2a. Are the 20 runs independent, and what is the variability?
The 20 runs use independent random seeds, with the data, Gaussian budgets, optimizers, schedules, stopping rules, and evaluation frames held fixed. HR data are used only for evaluation.
The revised Table 2 reports mean ± standard deviation and 95% confidence intervals. The ranges are 0.05–0.14 dB for individual datasets and 0.04–0.08 dB for the four-dataset aggregate. We use Welch t-tests. The p values are:
The Sphere 4× and Isotropic 4× differences are within the observed run-to-run variation.
Q2b. Missing Tangaroa configuration
The revised Table 1 lists Tangaroa as an incompressible velocity sequence with variables u, v, and w, an HR grid of 300×180×120 over 201 time steps, 4× and 8× grids of 75×45×30 and 38×23×15, and evaluation frames 196–200. We remove the provisional wording and use this verified configuration in Table 2.
Q3. How is Eq. (13) computed?
The implementation answers the reviewer’s questions in two parts.
The code will be released after acceptance, consistent with the paper’s current availability statement.