- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PointSplatV2 is a feed-forward framework for reconstructing dynamic scenes from sparse multiview videos. It uses geometry-guided spatiotemporal queries to aggregate observations into a compact, continuous 4D Gaussian representation. The method also introduces boundary-aware sequential training to encourage consistency between neighboring temporal chunks. Experiments demonstrate a promising balance between rendering quality, representation compactness, and reconstruction efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
PointSplatV2 produces detailed reconstructions while substantially reducing redundant Gaussian primitives. The reported results demonstrate a useful trade-off between visual quality, storage requirements, and reconstruction efficiency, particularly for dynamic foreground reconstruction.
-
Geometrically anchored queries provide a sensible way to aggregate observations across views and time into a shared dynamic representation. The supplementary boundary analysis and robustness experiments help characterize the method’s behavior, while explicit accounting of preprocessing and prediction costs makes the efficiency evaluation more informative.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is insufficiently differentiated and experimentally isolated. TokenGS [1] is particularly relevant because it already combines Gaussian queries with dynamic reconstruction, yet it is neither discussed nor evaluated. AnchorSplat [2] and C3G [3] also establish closely related approaches to geometry-supported and compact token-based Gaussian prediction, respectively. Furthermore, the motivation should distinguish pixel-aligned prediction from independent per-frame outputs: 4DGT [4] demonstrates that pixel-aligned primitives can still define continuous temporal representations. Although these methods do not subsume PointSplatV2’s complete formulation, the current comparisons do not establish how much improvement comes specifically from the proposed spatiotemporal queries, rather than the pretrained backbone, geometric support, or output parameterization. Comparisons using matched inputs, backbones, and Gaussian budgets would clarify the significance of the remaining contribution.
-
The evidence for the central temporal-consistency contribution is not sufficiently controlled. In Table 3, “No BAST fine-tuning” is the Stage-1 checkpoint, whereas the full model receives another 100k training steps with multichunk batches. Consequently, the 2.24 dB improvement cannot be attributed specifically to the overlap-consistency loss. Appendix A.4 varies inference overlap using the same trained model and does not resolve this confound. Temporal evaluation also needs stronger validation. The standard VBench Temporal Flickering implementation measures adjacent-frame pixel differences and explicitly assumes static videos; it does not compensate for genuine motion. Higher scores can therefore reflect reduced motion or detail rather than more accurate dynamics. The paper acknowledges smoothing bias, and its overlap MSE is useful, but agreement between two predictions does not establish motion accuracy. Ground-truth-relative or motion-compensated temporal errors are needed.
[1] Jiawei Ren et al. “TokenGS: Decoupling 3D Gaussian Prediction from Pixels with Learnable Tokens.” CVPR, 2026.
[2] Xiaoxue Zhang et al. “AnchorSplat: Feed-Forward 3D Gaussian Splatting with 3D Geometric Priors.” CVPR, 2026.
[3] Honggyu An et al. “C3G: Learning Compact 3D Representations with 2K Gaussians.” CVPR, 2026.
[4] Zhen Xu et al. “4DGT: Learning a 4D Gaussian Transformer Using Real-World Monocular Videos.” NeurIPS, 2025.
Questions for authors
-
How does PointSplatV2 compare with TokenGS under matched multiview inputs and training conditions? What benefit comes specifically from predicting explicit 4D parameters once per chunk instead of decoding time-conditioned 3D Gaussians?
-
Can you report ground-truth-relative temporal errors or motion-compensated consistency, including actual chunk transitions and held-out intermediate timestamps? How exactly was VBench Temporal Flickering applied to moving scenes?
-
Please specify the Neural3DV training/test split. Are evaluation scenes unseen during model training, or are only views or frames held out?
Summary of Revisions
We deeply appreciate the time and effort you have dedicated to providing detailed and insightful feedback on our work. We have carefully addressed each comment and revised the manuscript accordingly. The main revisions are summarized below:
These revisions were made in response to the reviewers' valuable suggestions, including broader baseline comparisons and discussion of related methods (Reviewers uT12 and 7J2k), more controlled ablations (Reviewers uT12, boVD, and 7J2k), additional evaluations of temporal accuracy and intermediate-timestamp reconstruction (Reviewers uT12, boVD, and 7J2k), long-sequence performance (Reviewer boVD), and cross-dataset generalization (Reviewers uT12 and 7J2k). We sincerely thank all three reviewers again for their constructive feedback, which has helped us improve the clarity and rigor of our evaluation and better demonstrate the strengths and limitations of our method.