- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper propose GaussTrace, a monocular 4DGS method combing the feedforward model with the per-scene optimization. Their method have 3 main stages: TBMM to initialize Gaussian and simplify the groping representation, MRTC to differentiate the dynamic region, static region, and ambiguous dynamic boundaries, and PGO to stabilize the scene and refine motion separately. The experiments demonstrate the fast optimization and best metrics compared with baselines.
Critical strengths
- This paper propose a very close desgin based on the priors obtained from OmniX and achieve much faster per-scene optimization than the other baselines. The typical time cost is 2-4 min compared with 19min-6hours. Also, instead of relying on multiple standalone foundation model for post estimation, depth estimation, maksing, and trackings, the close couping make the initialization workflow to be neat and simple.
- The ablation studies, limitation, budget discussion are sufficient. The logics of the paper is smooth and the figures are intuitive.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper directly inherits the limitation of the priors and does not solve it. The foundation model such as OmniX perform well on SEEN regions but is limited under the occlusion. Although the NVS near the input views is qualitatively and quantitatively better than baselines, the performance obviously drops when camera has a large shift. The proposed method can neither fill the NEVER UNSEEN regions nor recover the temporally occluded dynamic region from other available frames. Although the paper partially admit some limitations (where we thank for the honesty of the authors), these unsolved issues restrict the novelty and contributions.
- The paper does not fully discuss the influence of foundation model. The baselines such as SoM and MoSca utilizes much earlier visual/geometry foundational models while GaussTrace utilize OmniX (2026). Since the main contribution which this paper claimed is the three stages for per-scene optimization, the paper needs to validate the effectiveness of these three stages with a fair comparison. Although the author replaced the foundation model with others with the same GaussTrace pipeline, the performance becomes worse than baselines which is not persuasive to validate the effectives of the GaussTrace pipeline and, on the contrary, shows the quality seems to come from OmniX. Also, even if GaussTrace utilizes the SOTA foundation model, GaussTrace gains a marginal improvement and even LPIPS is worse than the best baselines in Tables 1 and 2.
Questions for authors
Besides the weekness above, there are some additional questions:
- In the demo video, each case is very short compared with the raw clip. It is necessary to show the long-sequence results since the current GaussTrace is claimed to support longer video with Exact-Stream engineering. Could the authors update the long-sequence resutls?
- There are clear Gaussian artifacts on the Gaussians' scene boundaries which should be handled individually. Is it possible for the method to solve this issue?
Dear Reviewer vUyT, if you have any further comments regarding my paper or my responses, please feel free to share them. This will allow me to provide additional clarifications before the deadline. Thank you.