- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Velocity 4D Gaussian Splatting (V4DGS) for dynamic scene reconstruction and novel view synthesis. The method builds upon a HexPlane-based Gaussian deformation framework and introduces temporal and spatial velocity consistency regularization to improve motion coherence. Experiments on the Plenoptic Video and D-NeRF datasets demonstrate improvements in rendering quality while maintaining real-time performance.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important problem in dynamic scene reconstruction, where motion inconsistencies can lead to temporal artifacts and degraded rendering quality. The proposed method is relatively simple and can be integrated into an existing Gaussian deformation framework without substantially increasing inference complexity. The quantitative results are promising, particularly the 3.31 dB PSNR improvement over Deformable4DGS on the Plenoptic Video dataset.
Critical weaknesses
-
The mathematical formulation of spatial velocity consistency is questionable (Eq. 13). The authors claim that multiplying the velocity difference by a factor of 2 extends spatial consistency constraints from a single timestamp to an entire temporal interval. However, Eq. 13 is mathematically equivalent to standard neighborhood velocity smoothing multiplied by 2. This constant factor can be directly absorbed into the regularization weight without introducing any additional temporal constraint. The authors should clarify this mathematical justification and compare their formulation against standard velocity smoothing with matched regularization weights.
-
Limited methodological novelty. The overall framework closely follows existing deformation-based Gaussian Splatting methods. The main modifications are temporal velocity smoothness and local spatial velocity alignment, both of which are relatively standard motion regularization strategies.
-
Comparisons with recent methods are missing. The quantitative comparisons in Tables 1 and 2 primarily involve methods published in or before 2024.
-
Insufficient ablation studies to isolate the contributions of the proposed regularization terms. Table 3 only reports the baseline, spatial-only, and full configurations, without evaluating temporal regularization independently. Moreover, spatial regularization alone provides only marginal improvements on average and even degrades performance on two of the five reported scenes.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weakness.
V4DGS Exhibits Ample, Comprehensive, and Consistent Experiments
1. We would like to clarify that a detailed derivation has already been provided on p. 7. The proof follows a clear and logically consistent sequence of steps and is presented in a mathematically rigorous form.
2. Our contributions include an optimization method for 4D Gaussian properties that encourages neighboring Gaussians to move consistently, aiming to maintain that consistency over continuous time intervals. Furthermore, we present two theorems and give their proofs. Theorem 1 shows that, for a differentiable trajectory, finite-difference velocity converges to instantaneous velocity as the interval shrinks. Theorem 2 formulates the neighboring Gaussians penalty.
3. The Introduction (p. 2) analyzes how representative dynamic rendering methods model motion: Deformable4DGS uses a deformation field, RealTime4DGS uses native 4D Gaussian primitives, and 4D-RotorGS renders time slices of 4D Gaussians. We then present Theorem 1, which motivates our use of a local constant-velocity approximation over short time intervals. Tables 1 and 2 (p. 8) compare V4DGS with these methods on both Plenoptic Video and D-NeRF. The evaluation, therefore, includes a comprehensive comparison.
4. Table 3 gives the most direct experimental evidence supporting the claims. Holding the spatial term fixed, adding the temporal term increases PSNR in all five reported D-NeRF scenes by 0.16–0.52 dB, with a mean gain of 0.29 dB. Tables 1–2 and Figures 5–6 place this ablation alongside benchmark results and rendered examples. The supplement adds qualitative comparisons on both datasets (Figures A and C) and visualizes estimated optical flow (Figure D). These results support the benefit of our contributions.