- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GI-ACE, a camera-aware admission rule for densification in sparse-view 4D Gaussian reconstruction. It accumulates per-camera projected-gradient statistics during ordinary training. A robust core accepts a native growth proposal when its demand remains above the existing threshold after removing the strongest camera. For rejected large primitives, a geometric recovery branch admits splits supported by two sufficiently demanding and angularly separated views, using time-conditioned Gaussian positions. Experiments on Neural3DV and Panoptic Sports report substantially smaller Gaussian populations and shorter training times, alongside improved mean PSNR. Additional studies examine population-matched recovery, camera sampling imbalance, camera layout, and staggered observations.
Critical strengths
1.The paper makes a useful distinction between the magnitude of a densification request and the distribution of evidence across cameras. The strongest-camera-removal rule is simple and interpretable, and per-camera averaging avoids treating repeated observations from one camera as additional independent viewpoints. The method reuses existing backward-pass statistics without requiring another renderer, learned module, or explicit population budget.
- The reported efficiency gains are substantial across two datasets. On Neural3DV, the method reports higher mean PSNR than the published 4C4D result while reducing population and training time relative to the authors’ native-densification reproductions. On Panoptic Sports, the population and training-time reductions are particularly large. The sampling-imbalance experiments and explicit discussion of the two-observer boundary are useful analyses of how the rule behaves.
Critical weaknesses
-
In Table 2, 4C4D’s image-quality scores come from the published paper, whereas its population and runtime come from the authors’ reproductions. The distinction is clearly disclosed, but the row does not describe a single baseline model. Since these reproductions already exist, their reconstruction scores should also be reported using the same evaluator as GI-ACE. Appendix D additionally notes that official and GI-ACE runs use different software environments, so the runtime ratios do not fully isolate the effect of the admission rule. A complete paired comparison is important for establishing the claimed quality–efficiency improvement.
-
Table 4 retains the robust core and changes how additional recovery candidates are selected. This is a useful control for the geometric score, but it does not establish that the overall camera-aware policy is better than simpler ways of suppressing excessive growth. A higher native gradient threshold, a shorter densification schedule, or random admission over the full proposal pool could also reduce overfitting and population. Table 6 varies the threshold within GI-ACE rather than providing this native-densification comparison. The reported matched-count study therefore supports a narrower conclusion than the claim that the overall gains cannot be obtained by simply growing less.
-
In Table 5, the canonical-ray variant achieves higher PSNR than the proposed time-conditioned variant under staggered observations: 24.737 versus 24.614 dB, with nearly identical populations and LPIPS. The paper acknowledges this result, which supports the method’s ability to operate with asynchronous evidence but does not demonstrate an advantage from evaluating rays at camera-specific observation times. The affine-trajectory derivation establishes how to compute a representative position; it does not establish that this position provides a better admission signal. This distinction matters because time-conditioned parallax is presented as a principal contribution.
Questions for authors
-
Complete image-quality results for the native-densification reproductions in Table 2 would make the main comparison directly interpretable. Reporting quality, population, and runtime from the same runs, together with timing under a shared software environment, would clarify the contribution of GI-ACE itself.
-
A native-densification quality–population curve obtained by varying its threshold or densification duration would help establish the benefit of camera-aware admission. A population-matched random-admission control over the full proposal pool would complement the recovery-only controls already provided.
-
A broader comparison of canonical and time-conditioned rays, particularly on sequences with substantial motion, would clarify when the proposed temporal anchoring helps. The current staggered experiment supports asynchronous operation, but leaves the specific contribution of camera-dependent observation times unresolved.
2 comments
Dear Reviewer ZVqF,
I hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period is nearing its end, we wanted to follow up and ensure our response has addressed your questions satisfactorily.
To briefly recap what we provided for your concerns: the requested controlled evidence is now delivered as dedicated tables: a quality–population frontier sweeping the baseline's own operating points, and a related-criteria comparison against Pixel-GS, AbsGS, and a fixed-budget MCMC baseline. On the mechanism question, we reframed time-conditioned parallax as a lightweight consistency formulation for asynchronous capture rather than a principal contribution, and the logged decisions show the two ray conventions agree on 98.2% of admissions. The camera-aware admission rule remains the paper's central claim.
If there are any additional points or feedback you'd like us to consider, please let us know; we are happy to provide further details or controls. Your scrutiny on experimental protocol genuinely improved the rigor of the revision.
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our work.
Best regards, Authors
Response to Reviewer ZVqF
We thank the reviewer for the precise, actionable requests; we ran every control asked for. All numbers use the full held-out protocol. In short, no 4C4D operating point, at any threshold or schedule, reaches GI-ACE's quality at its population.
Z1. Complete paired comparison
The published rows keep the published 4C4D scores; the controlled comparison runs released 4C4D and GI-ACE on the same views and evaluator.
Our re-runs of the released code are close to the published 4C4D results; G counts are our reproductions. Uncapped 4C4D densification ran out of memory on 32 GB for 2 of 3 cook seeds and on salmon.
The controlled comparison gives better quality at 3.4x fewer Gaussians. GI-ACE exceeds 4C4D's quality (+0.84 dB mean, winning PSNR on all five scenes and LPIPS on four) with ~2x less training (5.0 h vs 2.2 h mean), and unrestricted 4C4D densification does not fit in 32 GB for 2 of 3 cook seeds: the removed capacity is the difference between trainable and untrainable on commodity hardware. Where a scene favors more capacity, the camera-evidence bar is a tunable tightness parameter: on cook, half-threshold admission reaches 24.928 dB at 3.13M, +0.68 dB above the 4C4D result (24.25 at 4.19M); on salmon it wins both axes outright (20.43/0.179 vs 19.15/0.205) and the loose bar improves LPIPS further to 0.155. The reverse, growing far less at fixed quality, 4C4D cannot do (Z2).
On the software stack: training time follows population. The 4C4D 2x-threshold run at 1.53M takes 8,782 s vs GI-ACE 8,861 s at 1.38M, so the advantage comes from admitting fewer Gaussians.
Z2. "Simply growing less?"
No. At no threshold or schedule does a 4C4D operating point reach GI-ACE's quality at its population. Below are the 4C4D threshold and schedule curves (also: stopping growth at 10k/5k gives 23.845/22.404; 1.0M cap 23.409; 8x threshold 21.563), plus the full-pool random control:
Every 4C4D point under 1.9M is worse than GI-ACE by at least 0.39 dB, and even at 3.0x more Gaussians (4.19M) the full 4C4D run still trails it. At half threshold GI-ACE exceeds the 4C4D endpoint on both PSNR (+0.68) and LPIPS (0.102 vs 0.116) at 75% of its population: the GI-ACE frontier lies strictly above the 4C4D frontier.
Drawing the same number of proposals uniformly at random from the full proposal pool, without the robust core, loses 0.77 dB and 0.032 LPIPS with 22-35% more points (sear: -1.09 dB, 55% more). Under matched counts, the result depends on which proposals are admitted: camera-aware selection, not capacity.
Camera-imbalance stress test. Oversampling cam01 4x makes 4C4D quadruple its population to 4.79M while GI-ACE matches its quality at 4.2x fewer Gaussians (24.446 vs 24.482 dB). At 8x its population stays flat near 1.2M and the loss is only ~0.15 dB (24.29-24.32); dropping the normalization recovers the margin at +60% points (24.49 at 1.99M), a trade the loose bar dominates (24.93 at 3.13M).
Z3. Canonical versus time-conditioned rays
The two rules agree on 98.2% of admissions across the 294 events of an asynchronous run (7.5M evaluations): the ray convention barely changes which proposals are admitted, so the choice is second-order next to the admission rule itself (Z2). Temporal anchoring is what makes the score well-defined in the asynchronous regime, where each camera observes a different scene state and a canonical ray has no single instant to evaluate.
In the revision, time-conditioned parallax is reframed as a lightweight consistency formulation for asynchronous capture; the principal contribution is camera-aware admission, which Z2 shows drives the result.
In the revision we will separate the two tables and report the controls above.