- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Sparse2View, a novel-view synthesis method for sparse X-ray projections using a Transformer architecture. It integrates per-view anisotropic spectral filtering with cross-view attention, leveraging Plücker ray embeddings and PRoPE transformations. The authors present MiceBoneX and evaluate projection synthesis, downstream reconstruction, and transferability to unseen skeletal anatomies.
Critical strengths
- Useful data contribution. MiceBoneX contains 1,614 real micro-CT scans with rotational projections and camera metadata. Collecting these measurements provides a useful resource for studying sparse-view X-ray synthesis
- Consistent quantitative improvements are observed. Table 1 shows PSNR gains of 2.15 dB and 2.26 dB over LVSM in the 4-view and 8-view settings, respectively, along with increases in SSIM and LPIPS.
Critical weaknesses
- The method lacks significant novelty, mainly combining existing components. The paper does not clarify HRoPE's added value beyond merging PRoPE with Plücker embeddings, and a controlled comparison with LVSM using standard PRoPE is needed to support its claims.
- Ablation results show PSNR drops when removing certain components, but lack comparisons to simpler or alternative filters, so the necessity of the proposed design is not established.
- Improved projection metrics do not guarantee better anatomical reconstruction. The reconstruction and bone morphometry experiments compare the proposed method to ground truth but exclude results from learned baselines. Similarly, the fracture experiments lack direct evaluation of fracture gap or fragment boundary accuracy.
- The framework description is incomplete. The empty ray and query boxes in Figure 1 appear to be schematic placeholders, but the figure omits the pose-conditioning mechanism introduced in Equation (3). More importantly, the formulation does not clearly explain how target-dependent filters are applied when multiple target views are generated jointly.
Questions for authors
- How does HRoPE-MSA differ from standard PRoPE with Plücker embeddings? Please provide a controlled comparison with LVSM using PRoPE, ensuring matched model capacity, training schedules, and loss functions.
- Is the proposed anisotropic filtering more effective than simpler spatial filters or non-factorized spectral filters? Please separate the effects of filter factorization and pose conditioning, rather than eliminating the entire module.
- Do improvements in projection metrics lead to better anatomical reconstruction compared to LVSM or LVSM + PRoPE? Please provide comparative bone morphometry errors and quantitative fracture gap measurements on the same test cases, rather than relying solely on agreement with ground truth.