- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SAGA for ultra-sparse-view CT reconstruction. The proposed method combines projection consistency and volumetric information to guide the Gaussian evolution. Furthermore, a two-stage schedule separates geometric stabilization from structural refinement. Experimental results demonstrate that SAGA achieves impressive performance under ultra-sparse settings. But I think the paper needs better refinement.
Critical strengths
The proposed SAGA is well motivated by the observations that unreliable gradients and residuals under ultra-sparse views can misguide Gaussian allocation. The proposed framework makes conceptual sense by coupling reconstruction objectives with structure-aware allocation and separating the early geometric from later refinement.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors introduced the projection cue (i.e., Eq.9) to guide the Gaussian evolution. However, the experiment results in Tab.14 shows a subtle improvement from adding the P cue, which only improve 0.05 in PSNR and 0.001 in SSIM compared with the G cue only. Tab.2 shows that most of the performance improvement comes from the reconstruction objective, while G+P allocation and the two-stage scheduler provide limited performance gains. This weakens the empirical support for the paper’s contributions.
- The authors propose a transition factor s (i.e., Eq.12) to control the objective terms for stage-aware optimization. However, iteration count alone may not reliably indicate whether the construction is sufficiently stable for the stage transition. A criterion based on reconstruction stability would provide a more direct justification. Although Tab.10 demonstrates improved final performance with the two-stage scheduler, the results in Fig.11 exhibit drops for PSNR and SSIM, raising questions about its claimed stabilization effect. Furthermore, the values and selection for p_a and p_b are not reported in the paper, and no sensitivity analysis is provided for these key hyperparameters.
Questions for authors
In addition to the weaknesses discussed above, I also have the following question:
- Does the adaptive Gaussian (i.e., section Adaptive Gaussian Evolution) introduce any specific operation to the standard rules? If the rules are inherited from existing methods, the authors should cite the relevant work in the corresponding section.
- The G+P variants in Tab.13 and Tab.14 appear inconsistent, reporting 31.22 and 30.50 in terms of PSNR under the same chest 6-view setting.