- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
While machine learning has shown promising results for isolated stages of the analog design flow, an automated back-end optimization methodology that exploits a layout's multi-block hierarchy while leveraging parasitic-aware feedback remains largely unexplored. To address this, the authors present H-OSIRIS, a deep reinforcement learning methodology for post-layout optimization of multi-block analog circuits. Experimental results show joint feasibility rises from 0–9% to 72–99%, median area falls 3–8%.
Critical strengths
It uses genuine post-layout feedback (DRC/LVS-clean layouts, real extraction), not a parasitic proxy, which is very important. So the results are convincing.
Targeting an underexplored problem: back-end, parasitic-aware closure gets far less ML attention than front-end sizing or topology work.
Performance is strong, and the results are promising.
Critical weaknesses
The evaluation tasks are a little weak for the claims. Mostly target the Op-amp with one level of 2–3 blocks, yet “scalable” appears in the conclusions.
No variance is reported in the evaluation results.
The transfer and generalization capabilities are weak.
It is still a sizing work by considering physical feedback. The more challenging design automation part, i.e., placement and routing, is not addressed in this work.
Questions for authors
What is the relationship of this work with “OSIRIS: Bridging Analog Circuit Design and Machine Learning with Scalable Dataset Generation” ?
Can one trained policy handle a new target set, or a new initial sizing distribution?
Can you add more diverse designs?
What is the training cost (e.g., time) of this RL-based layout design method?
How is place-and-route addressed? Can you provide more details? If it is an open-source layout generator, no blind is needed.
2 comments
Response to Reviewer 1qko - Part 2
Q2, W3. To strengthen the experimental campaign, three additional batches of experiments have been conducted and added to Section 4 “Experimental Results”. First, Table 5 reports a greedy-Manager ablation that preserves the hierarchy, learned H-OSIRIS Workers, legal Manager action space, held-out starts, physical-design/simulation backend, and per-start action budget. Replacing the learned Manager with a fixed greedy rule reduces joint success from to on 2-Stage Amp , from to on 3-OpAmp InAmp , and from to on Amp-Filter Comp . Together with the flat comparison in Table 4, this shows that the hierarchical decomposition alone is insufficient: learned Manager decisions provide additional value. Second, Table 6 compares H-OSIRIS with flat Bayesian optimization (BO), a non-RL baseline that directly searches legal circuit-wide sizings without Manager or Worker RL policies. BO uses the same held-out starts, layout-generation and post-layout simulation backend, and matched maximum per-start post-layout evaluation caps as H-OSIRIS: evaluations for Dual-OTA and for Amp-Filter Comp $\mathcal{S}_F$. These demanding tasks respectively contain the largest constraint set and a heterogeneous amplifier-filter hierarchy. Flat BO attains joint feasibility on starts and starts, compared with and for H-OSIRIS. This comparison is framed as a matched test-time evaluation-budget comparison. Third, Table 7 evaluates transfer across sizing ranges and metric assignments. Under sizing ranges wider than those used during training, the evaluated policies achieve success for 3-OpAmp InAmp and for Dual-OTA . For metric transfer within Dual-OTA, the source policies are fine-tuned on the target metric set before held-out testing. Transfer from to achieves success after fine-tuning episodes, while transfer from to achieves after episodes. The corresponding cold-start H-OSIRIS policies achieve and , respectively.
Q3. We added a new topology (Cascode), extending the evaluation beyond amplifier-based designs. It introduces two voltage targets, and , alongside the global area constraint. H-OSIRIS achieves joint feasibility on held-out starts and a median area reduction. The topology, and its targets are detailed in Section 4.1, Table 2, and Appendix Figure 7. Table 3, Table 4, and Figure 10 report its results.
Q4. Table 4 reports the training time in hours for each topology-metric-set pair, for both H-OSIRIS and the matched flat baseline. H-OSIRIS requires - hours, compared with - hours for the flat baseline, corresponding to - less training time. At the same time, H-OSIRIS achieves - joint terminal success, compared with - for the flat baseline.
Q5. Place-and-route is handled by an existing open-source layout generator. Its reference was anonymized as a precaution to preserve double-blind review. The complete citation will be restored in the camera-ready version. The generator receives the updated device parameters and the block-footprint bounds selected by H-OSIRIS, and performs placement and routing under these constraints. The resulting layout undergoes DRC and LVS verification, parasitic extraction, and post-layout simulation, providing the electrical and area measurements used for the optimization feedback. H-OSIRIS does not propose a new placement or routing algorithm. Its contribution is the learned coordination of block-footprint constraints and local device sizing. To this end, in the revised paper, we expanded the state-of-the-art discussion in Section 2 “Related Work” and provided further evaluation in Section 4.2 “Experimental Results”.
Response to Reviewer 1qko - Part 1
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the importance of genuine post-layout feedback, the relevance of the targeted problem, and the strength of the experimental results. We appreciate the questions concerning evaluation breadth, generalization, computational cost, and the role of place-and-route, which help us clarify the methodology’s scope and strengthen the supporting evidence.
W1. The benchmarks evaluate the targeted coordination problem: jointly optimizing block footprints and device sizing under coupled post-layout electrical constraints. They now cover five circuit compositions across seven metric sets. Amplifier-based benchmarks are also used in post-layout optimization studies such as OSIRIS [1] and Gao et al. [2]. The demonstrated result is improved optimization efficiency within these multi-block circuits: hierarchical training is 1.7-9.6× faster than the evaluated flat formulation.
W2. We have added Section A.4.3 and Table 15, reporting 95 Wilson intervals for terminal joint success and interquartile ranges for area ratios across the held-out starts. Terminal success ranges from 72 to 99 across the seven metric sets, and every set has a median area ratio below one. The new statistics show the spread behind the aggregate results and characterize variability for each trained policy.
W4. The proposed ϵ-sizing mechanism is motivated by analog design workflows, where meeting post-layout performance targets requires close coordination between circuit designers and layout engineers. H-OSIRIS supports this process through an automated back-end optimization framework that connects device-sizing and block-footprint decisions with extracted post-layout performance feedback.
Q1. OSIRIS [1] and H-OSIRIS share the use of extracted post-layout feedback, but differ in their primary contribution, optimization variables, and coordination mechanism. OSIRIS presents a layout-dataset generation framework accompanied by an RL baseline that explores transistor fingers configurations and component displacements, using response discrepancy (pscore) and area as optimization objectives. H-OSIRIS, instead, targets joint electrical feasibility and footprint reduction in multi-block circuits. Its Manager adjusts block footprint boundaries, while block-specific Workers perform local ϵ-sizing of device groups. This interface coordinates two complementary decisions: changing the geometric constraints of a block and adjusting its device parameters within those constraints. Their combined consequences are evaluated through full-circuit parasitic extraction and simulation. H-OSIRIS aligns two optimization levels with the circuit’s block structure and couples footprint control with local ϵ-sizing, while requiring simultaneous satisfaction of explicit electrical-metric bounds and a global area constraint.
[1] Chiari, G., et al., “OSIRIS: Bridging Analog Circuit Design and Machine Learning with Scalable Dataset Generation”, ICLR, 2026.
[2] Gao, X., et al. "Post-layout simulation driven analog circuit sizing", Science China Information Sciences, 2024.