- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work presents LAMBDA, a large language model based analog physical design framework that uses B* graph connects circuit-derived constraints, placement and routing in same search space for joint Place-and-Routing. Also, multi-fidelity optimization couples low-cost physical and parasitic models with evaluation feedback to balance exploration efficiency with post-layout performance. It improves performance on experiments with commercial 28-nm circuits, evaluated by geometric mean full layout area and wirelength and the composite analog electrical score.
Critical strengths
- It focuses on a practical and valuable problem, which pushes the boundary of LLMs/agents.
- The proposed framework makes sense to me. Each module within the framework is introduced clearly with explanation for what it is and why it should be added to the framework.
- The overall writing is easy to follow. I'm not an expert for circuit design. While it is still difficult for me to understand some circuit-related terms, I can easily follow how LLM is used to solve the problem.
Critical weaknesses
- Is there any performance gap between different LLMs/MLLMs, especially open-sourced models vs. close-sourced models and different family of LLMs/MLLMs (e.g., GPT, Claude, Qwen, Kimi, etc.)?
- How many test cases are used in the evaluation? Does nine commercial circuits mean nine test cases? If that is true, the evaluation results may not be that reliable since the number of test cases used is too small.
- It would be better if there is a separate Related Work section to introduce how LLM is used in circuit design more comprehensively.
- Actually, the proposed framework is a LLM harness for circuit design. Is it possible to rollout data under this harness and then internalize this capability into LLMs by SFT or RL? I know it is not the core idea of this work, but such discussion is valuable for judging the future impact and potential of this work.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.