- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SageProto, a semantic-anchor prototype framework for semi-supervised multi-organ segmentation. The method aims to mitigate class-wise learning disparity by introducing textual anatomical knowledge into visual representation learning, prototype estimation, and decoding. Specifically, semantic anchors are constructed from anatomical descriptions and used to modulate visual features, initialize and rectify class prototypes, and guide cross-modal feature interaction. Prototype regularization is further introduced to encourage semantic consistency and preserve inter-class relationships. Experiments on Synapse, FLARE22, and AMOS demonstrate improvements over several existing semi-supervised segmentation methods, particularly for some challenging anatomical structures.
Critical strengths
- Class-wise performance disparity is particularly important in multi-organ segmentation, where anatomical structures vary substantially in size, appearance, and segmentation difficulty. Introducing anatomical semantic information to support poorly learned classes is a reasonable direction, and the proposed framework provides a systematic way to incorporate such information into prototype learning.
- The authors evaluate SageProto on Synapse, FLARE22, and AMOS, with comparisons against several recent semi-supervised segmentation methods. The reported improvements on challenging structures are encouraging. The component ablations and training analyses also provide useful initial evidence for the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
- SageProto combines semantic modulation, iterative prototype rectification, cross-modal decoder interaction, and multiple regularization terms. Although the ablation studies indicate that these components improve performance, it remains unclear whether the improvements primarily arise from the anatomical semantics or from the additional modeling capacity and feature interactions. A more controlled comparison with non-semantic or randomly initialized anchors would help establish the specific value of the proposed semantic guidance. This is important because the central contribution of the paper is the use of semantic anchors to alleviate class-wise learning disparity. 2.There are inconsistencies in the reported experimental results, and the evaluation protocol needs clarification. For example, the Synapse result is 65.85% DSC in Table 1 but 65.29% in Table 2. Similarly, the FLARE22 result is 86.63% in Table 1 but 86.21% in Table 8. Table 8 is labeled as using 10% annotated data, whereas the same DSC value is discussed in connection with the 50% supervision setting. These discrepancies make it difficult to determine which results correspond to the final configuration. Furthermore, the paper does not clearly establish the variability of the reported improvements across different random seeds or labeled-data selections, which is especially important under limited supervision.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors explain the inconsistencies in the reported results across Tables 1, 2, and 8?
- Could the authors clarify how the experimental results demonstrate that the proposed semantic anchors are responsible for mitigating class-wise learning disparity?