- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DGP-HPCL for multimodal brain tumor segmentation. The method uses label-derived center and interior-distance priors to select decoder features, applies Soft-KNN aggregation, and performs prototype contrast between high- and low-center-response groups. Auxiliary prior prediction and bidirectional structural consistency provide additional training supervision. Experiments are conducted on BraTS 2019 and 2021.
Critical strengths
-
Using geometric information to guide feature selection and auxiliary representation learning is a reasonable direction.
-
The auxiliary branches are used only during training, without requiring labels or hypergraph construction at inference.
-
The paper includes comparisons of sampling, aggregation, and prototype supervision strategies, and achieves good results on public benchmark datasets.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing focuses on implementation, with limited discussion of design motivations.
-
For the endpoint hyperedge–prototype contrast, the priors are derived from the whole-tumor mask (), without distinguishing tissue classes. Why should separating high- and low-center-response features improve tissue segmentation if the same tissue class may appear in both groups?
-
The proposed hypergraph aggregation appears to be standard similarity-weighted KNN pooling. What higher-order interactions does it capture beyond conventional neighborhood aggregation? Since the neighbors are already highly similar to the anchor, please clarify what the benefit of this aggregation step is.
-
The method introduces several loss weights. In particular, the sensitivity analysis does not cover lambda_c, lambda_d, and lambda_b.
Questions for authors
-
Why should center-response-based grouping improve tissue discrimination despite its possible mismatch with semantic classes?
-
What distinguishes the proposed hypergraph operation from standard KNN attention pooling?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer pF5s (Part 2 / 3)
Q4: The proposed hypergraph aggregation appears to be standard similarity-weighted KNN pooling. What higher-order interactions does it capture beyond conventional neighborhood aggregation? Since the neighbors are already highly similar to the anchor, please clarify what the benefit of this aggregation step is.
A4: Thank you for this insightful question. Soft-KNN uses similarity-weighted neighborhood aggregation, which is closely related to conventional KNN attention pooling.
The central contribution of DGP-HPCL is how geometry-guided selection, multi-node contextual aggregation, and endpoint prototype contrast are coordinated.
The mechanism contains three stages.
1) Geometry-guided candidate selection. The Gaussian center and interior-distance priors select 256 decoder locations, determining which intermediate features participate in relational learning.
2) Feature-relational aggregation. For each selected feature, cosine similarity identifies its eight most similar candidate features. Temperature-scaled softmax weights, using a temperature of 0.10, determine their contributions to the aggregated embedding.
Each hyperedge embedding jointly summarizes information from multiple feature-related decoder locations.
This addresses why aggregation is useful even when neighbors are similar: the contrastive objective operates on a neighborhood-contextualized embedding rather than an isolated node representation.
Feature similarity determines the aggregation neighborhood, while the geometric priors determine the candidate pool.
3) Endpoint prototype supervision. The aggregated representations are ranked according to their center-prior responses. The two ranking tails construct subject-specific prototypes and receive direct contrastive supervision.
Middle-ranked candidates continue contributing information through relational aggregation.
The framework therefore combines geometry-guided sampling, contextual multi-node representations, and selective geometric supervision.
Q5: What distinguishes the proposed hypergraph operation from standard KNN attention pooling?
A5: The similarity-weighted pooling operation is related to standard KNN attention. The methodological distinction is its integration into a geometry-conditioned representation-learning objective, where dual priors select candidates and endpoint-specific prototypes supervise their contextual embeddings.
The multi-node aspect is represented by each hyperedge embedding aggregating several selected features. Our experimental comparisons evaluate the practical value of this contextualization relative to other relation mechanisms.
Experimental Evidence. The original Table 4 and Appendix F.7, Table 22 compare four relational mechanisms under fixed geometric candidate selection.
R3-Table1: Relation-mechanism comparison on BraTS 2019.
| Relation mechanism | DSC ↑ | SDC ↑ | HD95 ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Identity node | 81.25 | 71.92 | 7.84 |
| Pairwise KNN graph | 81.52 | 72.12 | 7.43 |
| Hard-KNN hyperedge | 81.99 | 72.99 | 7.58 |
| Soft-KNN hyperedge | 82.38 | 73.54 | 6.91 |
Results Analysis.
1) Compared with identity-node representations, Soft-KNN improves DSC by 1.13 percentage points (pp) and SDC by 1.62 pp, while reducing HD95 by 0.93.
2) Compared with the pairwise KNN graph, DSC improves by 0.86 pp, SDC by 1.42 pp, and HD95 decreases by 0.52.
3) Compared with hard-KNN hyperedges, DSC improves by 0.39 pp, SDC by 0.55 pp, and HD95 decreases by 0.67.
These comparisons demonstrate the empirical value of similarity-weighted multi-node contextualization within our geometric prototype-learning framework.
We have expanded Appendix F.7 to explain this relationship more precisely and clarify the contribution of the full geometry-guided relational representation-learning objective.
Response to Reviewer pF5s (Part 3 / 3)
Q6: The method introduces several loss weights. In particular, the sensitivity analysis does not cover lambda_c, lambda_d, and lambda_b.
A6: Thank you for this important suggestion. We conducted additional sensitivity experiments for the three geometric supervision weights and incorporated the results into Appendix F.5, Table 19.
The original Appendix E already examines the candidate budget, neighborhood size, contrastive temperature, endpoint fraction, prior-fusion coefficient, and HPCL loss weight.
The new analysis specifically examines center-prior supervision, interior-distance supervision, and bidirectional structural consistency (BSC).
Implementation. We use a fixed BraTS 2019 fold-1 setting.
The default weights are 0.30 for center supervision, 0.30 for distance supervision, and 0.20 for BSC.
Each weight is independently halved or doubled while the remaining configuration is held fixed.
New Experiments.
R3-Table2: Geometric loss-weight sensitivity on BraTS 2019 fold 1.
| Center weight | Distance weight | BSC weight | DSC ↑ | SDC ↑ | HD95 ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.30 | 0.30 | 0.20 | 82.95 | 74.81 | 6.34 |
| 0.15 | 0.30 | 0.20 | 82.88 | 74.82 | 7.14 |
| 0.60 | 0.30 | 0.20 | 83.04 | 74.42 | 6.92 |
| 0.30 | 0.15 | 0.20 | 82.87 | 74.40 | 6.86 |
| 0.30 | 0.60 | 0.20 | 82.79 | 74.15 | 6.90 |
| 0.30 | 0.30 | 0.10 | 83.15 | 74.35 | 6.66 |
| 0.30 | 0.30 | 0.40 | 83.12 | 74.70 | 6.47 |
Results Analysis. DSC ranges from 82.79% to 83.15%, spanning 0.36 percentage points (pp), while SDC ranges from 74.15% to 74.82%, spanning 0.67 pp.
The established default configuration achieves the lowest HD95 (6.34) and remains within 0.20 pp of the highest measured DSC and 0.01 pp of the highest SDC.
These results demonstrate stable overlap and surface agreement under the tested local changes and support the selected default as a balanced configuration.
Further Evidence. The revised manuscript now includes several complementary experiments addressing your methodological concerns.
1) Independent loss ablations (Appendix F.1). Removing BSC decreases BraTS 2021 SDC by 0.69 pp, while removing HPCL decreases it by 1.10 pp.
2) Matched-budget endpoint comparison (Appendix F.2). With the same 102 supervised anchors, endpoint selection achieves better five-fold mean DSC, SDC, and HD95 than random-half sampling.
3) Relational aggregation comparisons (Appendix F.7). Soft-KNN achieves the best means among identity-node, pairwise KNN graph, hard-KNN hyperedge, and similarity-weighted hyperedge alternatives.
Together, these experiments support the central contribution of DGP-HPCL: dual geometric priors guide decoder feature selection, Soft-KNN constructs contextual representations, and endpoint prototype contrast provides targeted structural supervision.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's constructive questions regarding design motivation, geometric and semantic supervision, relational aggregation, and loss-weight sensitivity.
The expanded explanations and new experiments substantially strengthen the technical justification and empirical foundation of DGP-HPCL.
We respectfully hope you would consider revisiting your rating in light of these additional results and clarifications. Thank you again for your time and thoughtful feedback. We would be happy to address any remaining questions.
Dear Reviewer,
I hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period is nearing its end, I wanted to ensure we have addressed all your concerns satisfactorily. If there are any additional points or feedback you'd like us to consider, please let us know. Your insights are invaluable to us, and we’re eager to address any remaining issues to improve our work.
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper!
Response to Reviewer pF5s (Part 1 / 3)
We sincerely appreciate Reviewer pF5s for the detailed and constructive feedback. We are pleased that you recognize geometry-guided feature selection and auxiliary representation learning as a reasonable research direction.
Your concerns about design motivation and the relationship between geometric endpoint groups and tissue semantics are particularly valuable. We have expanded the corresponding explanations in Appendix F.7 and provide additional experimental evidence below.
Q1: The writing focuses on implementation, with limited discussion of design motivations.
A1: Thank you for this suggestion. The motivation of DGP-HPCL is to incorporate geometric information into intermediate decoder representation learning, complementing the dense tissue segmentation objective.
Accurate brain tumor segmentation requires both tissue discrimination and representations that capture irregular lesion geometry.
Our framework addresses two connected questions.
1) Where should relational learning occur? The Gaussian center prior captures global position relative to the whole-tumor centroid, while the interior-distance prior captures local foreground depth. Their fusion guides decoder feature selection.
2) Which contextual representations should receive direct supervision? Soft-KNN constructs contextual hyperedge embeddings from the selected features. The two center-response ranking tails provide geometric prototype targets, while intermediate candidates contribute relational context.
The resulting design connects geometric feature selection, relational aggregation, and endpoint-specific contrastive supervision.
Q2: For the endpoint hyperedge–prototype contrast, the priors are derived from the whole-tumor mask ((Y>0)), without distinguishing tissue classes. Why should separating high- and low-center-response features improve tissue segmentation if the same tissue class may appear in both groups?
A2: We appreciate this important conceptual question. The central idea is that geometric organization and tissue identity provide complementary supervision signals.
Our geometric priors are derived from the whole-tumor foreground. The center-response ranking characterizes relative geometric position within each subject.
Meanwhile, the dense segmentation objective supervises individual tissue labels. Both objectives update the shared decoder.
A tissue class may occur in either endpoint group because these groups encode relative geometry rather than semantic tissue categories.
The dense segmentation loss encourages tissue discrimination, while the prototype objective encourages contextual features to preserve geometric organization.
This joint representation learning provides a structural signal that complements tissue-specific supervision.
Q3: Why should center-response-based grouping improve tissue discrimination despite its possible mismatch with semantic classes?
A3: The benefit comes from learning semantic identity and geometric context together.
With 256 selected candidates and an endpoint fraction of 0.20, DGP-HPCL uses 51 low-response and 51 high-response anchors for direct prototype supervision. The remaining 154 candidates contribute to relational aggregation.
The endpoint groups provide geometrically separated targets, while the dense segmentation loss maintains the tissue-specific learning objective.
Experimental Evidence. The original Table 4 compares pairwise contrast, all-node hard prototypes, fixed-threshold endpoints, and quantile endpoint supervision.
The proposed quantile endpoint strategy achieves the best mean DSC (82.38%), SDC (73.54%), and HD95 (6.91).
We additionally conducted a matched-budget random-half experiment (Appendix F.2). With the same 102 supervised anchors, endpoint selection achieves 82.38% DSC, 73.54% SDC, and 6.91 HD95, compared with 82.22%, 73.40%, and 7.23 for random-half selection.
The regional evaluation (Appendix F.3) also shows particularly strong improvements in tumor-core and whole-tumor Surface Dice.
Together, these results support geometry-guided endpoint contrast as a complementary structural learning signal for the shared segmentation decoder.
We thank the reviewer for encouraging a clearer explanation of the motivation and mechanism.