- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper talks about a problem of identifying visually non-evident tumors by leveraging the secondary structural effects on adjacent slices. This scenario is particularly relevant in clinical settings with low-resolution or thick-slice CT/MRI scans, where subtle lesions are frequently missed. To simulate sparse sampling in real-world practice, the authors construct a dataset from public 3D brain MRI scans, designating non-visible slices within 1–3 slices of a lesion as positive, and those 4, 6, or 8 slices away as negative. The experimental evaluations demonstrate that the proposed approach effectively reduces the rate of missed diagnoses.
Critical strengths
A positive aspect of this work is its effort to formulate a new problem, specifically detecting non-visible tumors via secondary structural manifestations in adjacent slices. This attempts to model real-world clinical scenarios involving sparse sampling and thick-slice scans. While I have concerns regarding other parts of the paper, the authors' initiative to observe such a clinical scenario is appreciated.
Critical weaknesses
The authors explore a novel and clinically meaningful question, which is commendable. However, the link between the experimental setting and the intended clinical scenario requires further clarification. Tumors most likely to be missed because of slice thickness, interslice gaps, or partial volume effects are generally those with a limited extent along the axial direction. It remains unclear whether such small lesions produce sufficiently consistent and detectable secondary effects, such as edema, mass effect, or tissue deformation, on adjacent slices that do not directly contain the lesion. Conversely, larger tumors with prominent secondary effects typically span multiple slices and may therefore be less likely to be completely missed under sparse acquisition. This is the main concern regarding the research question of the paper.
Questions for authors
-
Although the research question is interesting, the technical novelty of the proposed approach is not convincingly established. Most of its components are standard and have been widely adopted in existing studies. The authors should clearly identify the methodological contribution beyond the combination of established techniques and substantiate it through rigorous comparisons and ablation studies.
-
The current description of the methodology is insufficiently detailed. The manuscript does not provide a clear and formal account of the complete workflow from data input to the predictions generated by the four classification heads. Based on Figure 2 and the accompanying text alone, it is difficult to determine how features are extracted and propagated, how the classification heads are defined and supervised, and how their outputs are combined. The authors should substantially revise this section by providing explicit mathematical formulations, notation, feature dimensions, and complete details of the training and inference procedures.
-
Figure 3(b) is not sufficiently clear to allow a meaningful interpretation of the results. It should be redrawn with improved resolution, clearly labeled axes and legends, distinguishable colors or line styles, and a more readable overall layout.
-
The English presentation requires some improvement. The authors may want to substantially revise the article to allow the technical content to be communicated accurately.