- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes GPS for cross-domain few-shot medical image segmentation (CD-FSMIS). Motivated by the observation that organ geometry and peripheral-background distributions stay stable across domains, it treats them as “anatomical anchors”. Three modules follow: GAI, which modulates feature channels via a dual-ring radial contour descriptor of the support mask; PPM, which mines multi-prototypes for the foreground and for the peripheral region inside the bounding box; and PSR, which fuses both similarity maps for coarse-to-fine refinement. On abdominal CT/MR, cardiac LGE/b-SSFP, cross-institution prostate, and two extreme-shift tasks, GPS achieves the best mean Dice under 1-way 1-shot at lower cost than C-Graph.
Critical strengths
1.Comprehensive and controlled evaluation: seven public datasets, nine baselines retrained under a shared backbone and identical data splits, plus efficiency and hyperparameter-sensitivity analyses.
2.Clear figures and a readable narrative: Figures 1/2/5 chain motivation → architecture → validation, making each module's purpose easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
1.Limited novelty: the central observation (geometric and peripheral-background invariance) was already proposed and methodized by contemporaneous work that the paper neither cites nor compares against (e.g., GeoProto, arXiv:2605.10885; PSP, MICCAI 2026), so claiming it as the primary contribution does not hold.
2.Unverified critique: the introduction singles out Robust-EMD as failing under drastic appearance change, yet it never appears in the main experiments (Tables 1–2) and is reported only in the appendix.
-
Mechanism description does not match the implementation: GAI's channel weights are derived solely from the support set and are spatially uniform, contradicting the "dynamic/adaptive" framing, which also undercuts the DGAA comparison.
-
Ablations do not support the paper's central claim: the largest single gain (+10.40 Dice) comes from an auxiliary BCE loss unrelated to geometry or peripheral background, and the module ablations never state their loss configuration, so per-module contributions cannot be separated.
Questions for authors
1.How does GPS relate to and differ from GeoProto and PSP, which share the same insight and were public before submission, and can you provide direct comparisons?
2.Why are Robust-EMD, MAUP, and Fob-SAM absent from the main tables, and can you add them?
3.What is the loss configuration of each row in Table 4, and what are the net gains of GAI and PPM&PSR once the auxiliary loss is removed?
4.Your retrained baselines differ from the published values by up to 12+ Dice points and your protocol description differs from FAMNet's — how do you explain this?
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for taking the time to respond to our rebuttal. We hope that our responses and additional experiments have adequately addressed your concerns. If you have any remaining questions or concerns, please let us know. We would be happy to provide further clarifications or additional evidence to address them.
We sincerely appreciate your time and constructive feedback.