- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses Cross-Domain Few-Shot Medical Image Segmentation (CD-FSMIS), focusing on the prototype representation bias introduced by distribution shifts between the source and target domains. Motivated by the observation that support and query images of the same category exhibit relatively consistent foreground statistical distributions within individual domains, the authors propose DA-Proto, a distribution-aligned prototype learning framework that leverages foreground distribution priors from target-domain support samples to improve prototype adaptation.The method is evaluated on abdominal CT/MRI cross-modality segmentation and cardiac MRI cross-sequence segmentation benchmarks. DA-Proto achieves the highest reported mean Dice scores among the compared methods across all four cross-domain tasks. The authors further provide component and loss ablations, distribution-prior substitution experiments, sensitivity analyses, and computational efficiency comparisons to support the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses the challenging problem of cross-domain few-shot medical image segmentation. Its attempt to exploit relative distribution relationships between support and query images provides an interesting perspective on domain generalization, although the underlying assumption and methodological novelty require stronger justification.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Insufficient justification of cross-domain distribution stability. Although the authors report high support-query foreground distribution similarity across several domains, these results mainly demonstrate within-domain consistency rather than a domain-invariant relationship. Stronger evidence is needed to establish the claimed cross-domain stability. W2. Limited methodological novelty. The proposed framework primarily combines foreground statistical modeling, reconstruction-based regularization, and additive prototype modulation. The methodological differences from existing prototype adaptation and feature modulation techniques remain insufficiently established. W3. Gap between motivation and method. The motivation emphasizes stable support-query distributional relationships, whereas the proposed method mainly extracts support foreground statistics and adds the learned representation to class prototypes. It is unclear how this operation explicitly achieves distribution alignment or preserves the claimed relationship. W4. Incomplete comparisons with recent methods. Although the paper includes several relevant cross-domain few-shot segmentation baselines, comparisons with more recent methods, particularly those from 2026, would better establish its competitiveness. W5. Limited analysis of the distribution prior. The prior ablations demonstrate the benefit of category-matched information, but it remains unclear whether the improvement specifically comes from distribution modeling or simply injecting additional category-specific support features. Comparisons with simpler support-feature modulation alternatives would strengthen the methodological justification.
Questions for authors
refer to the weakness
2 comments
Reply
Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications. The rebuttal addresses most of my concerns, particularly regarding W4 & W5. The new results also strengthen the generalization claim.The motivation of the unified framework also lowers my concern on novelty. Overall, I am satisfied with the response and willing to raise my rating.
Response to R3
We appreciate the reviewer’s thoughtful feedback and helpful suggestions. Our responses are provided below.
We would like to clarify that the "cross-domain stability" discussed in our paper does not imply that different imaging domains (e.g., CT and MRI) share similar absolute intensity distributions. Instead, our motivation stems from the observation that models trained on a source domain may overfit to domain-specific appearance cues, such as texture and contrast, which can vary substantially across imaging modalities.
In cross-domain few-shot segmentation, both support and query images are sampled from the target domain. The support foreground statistics can provide target-domain-specific information relevant to query segmentation. Our method leverages this information to condition the segmentation prototypes, aiming to reduce reliance on source-domain-specific appearance cues.
Therefore, our method does not assume invariant distributions across domains or identical support–query distributions. Rather, it exploits support-derived target-domain distributional information to improve prototype adaptability under domain shifts. We will clarify this distinction in the revised manuscript.
Our key contribution lies in explicitly incorporating support-derived foreground distributional information into prototype learning to improve cross-domain adaptability, rather than relying solely on semantic prototypes or conventional feature modulation.
Specifically, FDM extracts a foreground distribution prototype F_d from the support features and foreground mask. However, directly mapping statistical information into the feature space may not adequately preserve its underlying statistical characteristics. To address this, DFR introduces a statistical reconstruction constraint that encourages F_d to retain the original distributional information. DGPM then integrates the distribution-aware prototype with the semantic prototype to guide query segmentation.
We further clarify that our "distribution alignment" does not explicitly minimize the discrepancy between support and query distributions. Instead, it refers to preserving the statistical information encoded in the learned distribution prototype through reconstruction-based supervision, which subsequently enables distribution-aware prototype conditioning.
Thus, FDM, DFR, and DGPM form a unified framework that connects foreground distribution modeling, statistical information preservation, and prototype conditioning. This design enables the model to leverage target-domain distributional cues for cross-domain few-shot medical image segmentation.
We have additionally compared our proposed DA-Proto with two recent methods, GeoProto and PSP, on the Abdomen CT → Abdomen MR task. The quantitative results are presented in the table below.
As shown, DA-Proto consistently outperforms both recent methods across all four anatomical structures (Liver, LK, RK, and Spleen), achieving the best performance in terms individual-organ Dice scores . Specifically, DA-Proto achieves a mean Dice score of 74.64%, outperforming GeoProto and PSP by 6.63 and 5.83 percentage points, respectively.
We conducted experiments on Abdomen CT → Abdomen MR task to compare our DA-Proto with simply injecting additional information (SIAI) of category-specific support features. The results are presented in the table below.
As shown, DA-Proto consistently outperforms SIAI across all four anatomical structures, achieving a mean Dice score of 74.64%, which is 2.89 percentage points higher than that of SIAI (71.75%). These results suggest that explicitly modeling and preserving foreground distributional information provides additional benefits beyond simply injecting additional information of support features.