- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors proposed a medical image semi-supervised segmentation method, CHCL-Seg. The network is composed of ABCP, UnCL loss function with hierarchical contrastive learning. Experiments prove the effectiveness of the proposed modules, especially on boundary-wise metrics.
Critical strengths
- Semi-supervised learning in medical imaging segmentation is a difficult problem for a long time. This method addressed the problem by introducing dual students, and significantly improves the boundary accuracy.
- The experiments are abundant to prove the effectiveness of CHCL-Seg.
Critical weaknesses
- The UnCL chooses the student branch with higher confidence, while higher confidence does not necessarily indicate higher accuracy, particularly when both students make wrong predictions. The paper lacks sufficient analysis to prove that this competitive strategy effectively reduces confirmation bias.
- V-DACL assumes that low-density features correspond to informative hard samples near object boundaries, but such features may also represent noises. Furthermore, confidence-based filtering may exclude uncertain boundary voxels. The paper lacks enough evidence of this sampling strategy.
- The paper claims that ABCP is a prerequisite for feature-level contrastive learning. However, the ablation results do not fully support this conclusion. As to LA, HCL alone improves Dice from 89.53 to 89.96, and similarly on BraTS-2019 where Dice increases from 85.05 to 85.81. Furthermore, adding HCL to ABCP improves Dice on LA (90.82 to 91.69) but slightly decreases Dice on BraTS-2019 (87.09 to 86.97). The combination of UnCL and HCL without ABCP also shows opposite trends across the two datasets. These inconsistent interactions suggest that ABCP is not necessarily a prerequisite for HCL, and the claimed dependency requires further justification.
- Since the pipeline contains students using shared parameters but different Dropouts, it is necessary to validate across different random seeds settings to prove the robustness and consistent improvements of this method.
Questions for authors
- How does UnCL ensure that selecting the student branch with higher confidence leads to more reliable predictions, especially when both branches make incorrect predictions? It is suggested to provide quantitative evidences.
- How do the authors verify that the low-density features selected by V-DACL correspond to informative boundary samples rather than noise or outliers? Additionally, does the confidence threshold exclude potentially useful uncertain boundary voxels?
- The ablation results need more clarifications, like is ABCP truly a prerequisite for HCL, or does it only provide complementary benefits under certain conditions?
- How stable is the method under different initialization settings?