- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TriggerMatch, a semi-supervised 3D medical image segmentation framework that separates semantic acquisition from semantic maintenance. It introduces a class-wise supervision mechanism that dynamically removes and restores labeled supervision based on model performance, while retaining pseudo-label learning on unlabeled data. Experiments on AMOS2022, FLARE2022, and Synapse demonstrate consistent improvements in Dice scores over several semi-supervised baselines.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
The claim that medical images exhibit substantially higher intra-class similarity than natural images lacks quantitative evidence, and the examples in Figure 1 are insufficient to support this generalization. More importantly, the connection between this assumption and the proposed asymmetric decomposition into semantic acquisition and semantic maintenance remains unclear. The paper does not adequately explain why these two responsibilities should be separated in semi-supervised medical image segmentation.
-
Although the results are promising, the experiments do not fully establish whether improvements arise from the proposed semantic acquisition–maintenance principle or simply from class-wise gradient rebalancing. Comparisons with simpler class-reweighting strategies are missing.
-
The paper lacks an overall architecture or workflow diagram to clearly illustrate the proposed supervision routing mechanism. Furthermore, the experimental comparisons primarily focus on general semi-supervised learning methods, with limited comparisons against recent approaches specifically developed for semi-supervised 3D medical image segmentation.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide quantitative evidence supporting the claim that medical images exhibit significantly higher intra-class similarity than natural images? Figure 1 alone does not sufficiently justify this assumption.
-
Why does the assumed anatomical similarity necessarily motivate decomposing semi-supervised medical image segmentation into two asymmetric tasks? What theoretical or empirical evidence supports assigning semantic acquisition primarily to labeled data and semantic maintenance to unlabeled data?
-
Could the authors include comparisons with more recent methods specifically designed for semi-supervised 3D medical image segmentation, preferably under identical experimental settings, to better demonstrate the competitiveness of TriggerMatch?
-
Could the authors compare TriggerMatch against simpler class-wise loss reweighting or adaptive gradient-balancing methods to better isolate the benefit of the proposed supervision routing mechanism?
-
Is Equation (5) implemented exactly as written? If so, why does the Dice loss exclude false-positive predictions, and how does it recover the standard supervised objective?
Reviewers, please be responsive
Dear reviewers,
The authors have provided detailed rebuttal. Please respond to authors' rebuttal, If you have not done so. Thanks!
AC