-
[W1] Weak Novelty / Missing Relevant Semi-Supervised Segmentation Results. Applying well-known EMA, confidence-based pseudo-labeling, and auxiliary supervision to cell panoptic segmentation does not by itself establish a new contribution. Although Table 2 includes adapted CPS/UniMatch baselines, comparisons and distinctions from the cited (see L104) BASS and UniMatchv2 remain unclear. Component-wise differences from related dual-teacher fusion, reliability-weighted soft-target consistency, and mask-quality filtering methods [A, B, C] are also not compared. Please compare conceptual advances from differences in tasks and supervision, and validate teacher updates, and instance/type supervision through controlled comparisons. In the current paper, the main contribution appears limited to application novelty and empirical results.
-
[W2] Unclear Reproducibility / Comparison Protocols. Tables 1/2 must isolate semi-supervised training strategies, while Tables 3/4 must evaluate fully-supervised architectures. Details on shared encoders/decoders, pretrained backbones, dataset splits, annotation budgets, and FixMatch/CPS/UniMatch adaptation are insufficient, and no code or appendix is provided to assess reproducibility. Also, stability across seeds is important at high unlabeled ratios (e.g., >80%). Please clarify whether the fully-supervised Hover-Net/CellViT/NuLite-H results use training configurations (e.g., dataset splits). As shown in Table 4, the source of the parameter gap between NuLite-H and SPiN is unclear. Since FastViT is simply adopted, architecture choices and semi-supervised contributions must be ablated separately. Reporting comparable performance while presenting existing components as contributions further weakens the novelty claim.
-
[W3] Fixed Hyperparameters and Training Choices. Sensitivity analysis is needed for the consistency weight of 0.02 and 2000-step in Eq. 4, EMA rates of 0.99/0.995, and confidence threshold of 0.7. No experiment establishes whether this combination remains effective across annotation budgets. At minimum, compare a single teacher, two teachers with identical or different EMA rates, and uniform versus confidence-weighted fusion [A, B]. Please also justify excluding NP/HV from unlabeled consistency. The current ablation shows the experimental justification incomplete and unclear individual contributions/gains.
-
[W4] Encoder and Decoder Choices. The choice of FastViT and NuLite's decoder needs accuracy-efficiency comparisons against similarly sized (or smaller) alternatives. Mask decoders and encoder-only methods, such as EoMT [D] should be considered in terms of training and inference costs. Retaining Hover-Net-style HV prediction and watershed also requires positioning against recent alternatives (e.g., [E]).
-
[W5] Task Importance. Given the focus on annotation efficiency, please compare with training-free cell instance segmentation approaches such as CoP [F] and SPROUT [G] to justify the need for task-specific training/supervision. Specifically, CoP requires a click per cell type at inference time but performs training-free cell panoptic segmentation. SPROUT does not directly provide cell-type classification. However, that joint cell panoptic segmentation offers any advantages over a two-stage approach (cell instance segmentation -> cell-type classification) is unclear. This result will clarify and enhance when the proposed semi-supervised training offers a practical advantage beyond empirical comparisons.
-
[W6] Readability. Please improve Figure 1's spacing and plot labels, and include key baselines such as CellViT in the qualitative comparison. Also, I suggest merging figures 2/3 into an overview showing labeled/unlabeled real training and inference samples, followed by separate descriptions of individual modules.
References:
[A] Perturbed and Strict Mean Teachers for Semi-Supervised Semantic Segmentation, CVPR 2022.
[B] Dual-teacher fusion with augmented branch for semi-supervised object detection, Pattern Recognition 2026.
[C] MUST: Mean-teacher inspired and Uncertainty-aware Semi-supervised Transformer for cell instance segmentation, JBHI 2026.
[D] Your ViT is Secretly an Image Segmentation Model, CVPR 2025.
[E] The Four Color Theorem for Cell Instance Segmentation, ICML 2025.
[F] One Click per Cell Type Suffices: Training-free Group Interaction for Cell Instance Segmentation, ACCV 2026.
[G] Supervise Less, See More: Training-free Nuclear Instance Segmentation with Prototype-Guided Prompting, ICML 2026.