- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SRDF for medical image segmentation under extremely scarce scribble annotations. SRDF converts multiclass predictions into subset-relative decision fields and uses local distance calibration to represent regional structure and boundary geometry. Based on this representation, the authors design a class adjacency constraint, a scribble-anchored topology reconstruction constraint, and the Subset-Ribbon boundary geometry constraint.
Critical strengths
-
The paper unifies multiclass predictions, region-level anatomical relations, and local boundary geometry within differentiable decision fields. The method is structured and targeted to the problem setting.
-
Subset-relative decision fields preserve consistency with the final multiclass prediction while supporting constraints at different levels, including tissue relations, connectivity, and boundary geometry. This provides a certain degree of methodological novelty.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method highly depends on manually specified anatomical relations, class adjacency, and subset hierarchies. The paper designs different priors for the cardiac and prostate tasks, so the gains may partly come from dataset-specific knowledge. It remains unclear whether the method can be applied to other organs, pathological conditions, or tasks with unstable anatomical relations.
-
The paper presents the method as a structured learning framework under sparse scribble supervision, but the class adjacency and topology reconstruction constraints are mainly applied to scribble-annotated images. Unlabeled images are primarily used through Mean Teacher, local distance calibration, and boundary constraints. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the main gains truly come from structured utilization of the large amount of unlabeled data.
Questions for authors
-
Do the anatomical subsets, class adjacency relations, and topology targets need to be manually designed for each dataset? How does the method perform when the prior relations are incomplete, incorrect, or partially removed?
-
The boundary geometry constraint searches only near the teacher-predicted boundary. When the teacher substantially misses the target or has a large boundary deviation, can this constraint correct the error, or does it mainly refine an already accurate boundary?