- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Molm treats a cell as a point cloud of transcript identities and positions. Context-dependent molecular weights define groups whose local geometric moments feed back into the cell representation. Self-supervised training is evaluated with cell-label and morphology prediction on real spatial transcriptomics data, and with subtype and localization recovery on synthetic data.
Critical strengths
The model gives molecular geometry a clear role in representation learning. The rebuttal addresses the main concerns: Molm retains its advantage over FOCUS and pyTrance at comparable GPU-hour budgets, and the additional synthetic datasets support the result across different signal strengths. The real-data validation and same-input ablations also strengthen the evidence for the learned representation.
Critical weaknesses
The new synthetic experiments change the generation seed and signal strength together, so they do not separately measure variation across generated datasets at a fixed setting. This is a remaining limitation, although the additional experiments substantially improve the original evaluation. The EGNN comparison is still preliminary, so the comparison with another geometric encoder remains incomplete.
Questions for authors
If feasible, please repeat one fixed generator setting with a different generation seed to check variation across generated datasets. Please include the complete EGNN results once the remaining runs are finished.
3 comments
(2/2)
W1a, Q1. Four datasets, each from its own generation seed
On every dataset with subtype signal, the three EGNN forms keep their subtype order seen at κ₂ = 6, and Molm (EGNN) stays ahead of FOCUS and pyTrance; its measures keep their pattern lift on all four datasets, and in the null every form is at chance (tables in our first comment; Appendix M).
W1b. "Do not yet validate recovery of real subcellular programs"
Two new appendices show the measures on single real DCIS cells. With depth, the measures move from encoding gene identity toward spatial patterns such as the nucleus and the cell outline, and single measures, each the best match for its target chosen on the training section, track the nucleus, the cell's center, the cell outline and DAPI within gene (r 0.51 to 0.73 on the test section; Appendix Q, Figure 6). Where the probe on the measures calls nucleus beyond the segmented nucleus, the DAPI stain is brighter (AUROC 0.67 against 0.50, chance level, for the baseline; Appendix R, Figures 8 and 9), so the measures follow the nucleus in the DAPI stain, which the model does not take as input.
W2b (continued). Same molecular inputs: the hand-crafted baseline
On the 20,000 cells of that comparison, Molm's subtype score is now the mean of three seeds, 0.807 (our reply gave one seed, 0.801), against 0.507 for the hand-crafted features (Appendix O, Table 26).
Pointers. The appendices of the final revision are lettered differently from those our reply cites. The synthetic data are in Appendix F, robustness is in Appendix M (the 57-class label is in Table 22), training compute is in Appendix J, and localization in real cells is in Appendix P. Appendix O, Table 2 and Figure 2 keep their numbers.
We would be glad to discuss any remaining questions.
Dear Reviewer E3AD,
Thank you for reassessing the paper and acknowledging the stronger evaluation. We would like to highlight that the EGNN comparison identified as incomplete in your updated review is now finished and included in the manuscript (Section 5; Appendices M and N).
Across the four synthetic datasets, the comparison clarifies the contributions of encoder design and the learned measurement. A strengthened EGNN recovers the subtype, while adding Molm’s measurement raises localization-pattern lift from 0.235 to 0.298 at the main setting, comparable to 0.295 for transformer-based Molm. This supports the measurement’s benefit across both encoder architectures. We also added individual real-cell visualizations and quantitative validation against nuclear geometry and DAPI imaging (Appendices Q and R).
Your point about generation-seed variation at a fixed signal strength remains valid: the existing sweep changes both together and does not isolate that source of variation.
With the EGNN comparison now complete and the additional real-cell evidence included, would you consider whether the revised paper warrants a higher score? We appreciate your consideration and would be happy to address any final questions.
Best regards,
The Authors
Follow-up: the revision is complete (1/2)
Thank you again for your review. The equivariant graph network runs that our reply (W2b) promised are complete and are now in the paper. Below are the new results and the one statement of our reply that they refine.
In brief. EGNN, trained on Molm's input with the shared terms of our objective, shows that distances in the encoder are needed but not sufficient to reach Molm's level. On a graph network as on the transformer, a capable encoder recovers the subtype on every dataset with subtype signal, and the measurement adds the localization pattern on all four datasets.
W2b. Attribution to the geometric architecture
A generic geometric encoder given the same input does not reach Molm's subtype score. A class token and pre-norm blocks recover the subtype, and Molm's measurement recovers the pattern. We train EGNN (Satorras et al., 2021) on each molecule's gene and position, with a 32-nearest-neighbor graph and the shared terms of our objective, for 220 epochs (Molm: 215). It comes in three forms: as published; with a class token and pre-norm blocks (EGNN + cls + preLN); and with Molm's measurement added after each node update, which is Molm with an EGNN encoder, Molm (EGNN). We report three training seeds at κ₂ = 6 and one seed on each further dataset.
This refines one statement in our reply. We wrote that exceeding pyTrance "takes geometry in the encoder". Geometry in the encoder is needed but not sufficient. With input, objective and epochs fixed, recovering the subtype needs a capable encoder and the localization pattern the measurement; neither depends on the transformer in particular. The paper adds EGNN to Section 5 and Figure 2, with details in Appendices G and N and its compute in Appendix J.