- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies how to extract cell-level representations from existing pathology foundation models. It proposes spatial indexing: encode a cell-centered tile and average the patch tokens at the cell’s location, preserving both cell-specific information and surrounding context without retraining the encoder. The authors curate 111 H&E-registered Xenium samples and evaluate four foundation models on cell-type classification and single-cell gene-expression prediction. Spatially indexed tokens improve classification by approximately 0.10 macro-F1 over the CLS token of the same tile and also improve expression prediction. The paper further shows that multiple cells can be represented in one encoder pass and that explicit neighbor aggregation can be removed in its expression-prediction setup with little loss of performance.
Critical strengths
-
A consistent and consequential finding across models. Spatially indexed tokens outperform the CLS token by about 0.10 macro-F1 across four pathology foundation models, with gains also observed in gene-expression prediction. This shows that read-out choice materially affects cell-level performance without requiring a new encoder.
-
Practical value and a substantial data resource. The authors curate 111 H&E-registered Xenium samples and show that reading multiple cells from one encoder pass reduces forward passes by roughly 70× with only a small classification drop. Both the resource and the efficiency result make the finding useful beyond the reported benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. Reading cell embeddings from spatially indexed ViT tokens has appeared in prior cell-level pipelines, and concurrent work reports advantages over tile-level pooling. This paper provides a valuable systematic evaluation, but its central method is a simple read-out choice rather than a new representation-learning approach. That limits its contribution at ICLR.
-
Narrow evaluation relative to the paper’s claims. Although the curated resource contains 111 samples, the main benchmarks use only 7 pan-cancer, 5 colon, and 15 lung slides, with classification restricted to five broad cell types. The evidence is therefore limited for claiming that this read-out should be a general default across tissues and finer cell-level tasks.
Questions for authors
-
Novelty (clarification): How does spatial indexing differ from token-based cell feature extraction in CellViT++, CellSymphony, and CellPath-Bench? Which part of the proposed read-out is new, rather than newly evaluated here?
-
Evaluation scope: How were the 7 pan-cancer, 5 colon, and 15 lung slides selected from the 111-sample resource? Do the read-out gains hold on additional available slides and with finer-grained cell-type labels?
-
Additional baselines: Could the authors add a matched comparison with the coordinate-sampling read-out used in CellPath-Bench, using the same frozen encoders, data splits, and downstream classifier? This would help establish whether the proposed four-token read-out offers a benefit over the closest existing approach.