- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CellBridge, which uses paired H&E images and spatial transcriptomic profiles to learn cell-level image representations. It combines conformal prediction with the Cell Ontology to return fine-grained labels when supported by morphology and broader labels otherwise.
Critical strengths
The method performs consistently well across multiple external datasets, and its Cell-Ontology-Fallback design provides a practical way to return broader cell labels when H&E morphology does not support a fine-grained prediction.
Critical weaknesses
The claim that low reliability scores identify incorrect predictions is supported mainly by qualitative case studies. A quantitative analysis across the test sets would strengthen this claim.
Questions for authors
Can the authors quantitatively evaluate whether low reliability scores consistently identify incorrect predictions across the test set?
3 comments
We thank Reviewer 5wkR once again for the time and effort they put into our work. As the discussion period approaches its end, we would kindly like to ask if there are any further comments or concerns that we could address.
Thank you for the authors' response. I decide to keep my original score.
Our Rebuttal to Reviewer 5wkR (W1 & Q1)
Thank you for reviewing the paper. We appreciate that you find the empirical performance strong and our COF module practical. We address your remaining comments below, which we hope will help clarify and improve your evaluation and confidence in our paper’s contributions.
W1 & Q1: Quantitative evaluation of reliability scores
We thank the reviewer for this comment. In addition to the case studies wherein misclassified cells receive low reliability scores across eight expert-reviewed regions (all five errors in Figure 8 receive near-zero reliability), we conducted two quantitative analyses:
This is consistent with underlying biology. For example, separating discrete labels such as T vs. B vs. NK cells based on their small round shapes identified from H&E is less reliable in the absence of corresponding molecular markers such as CD4+ and CD8+ [1]. That is when COF returns the most specific supported ancestor, such as lymphocyte.
References
[1] Sheibani, K., et al. (1988), Variability in interpretation of immunohistologic findings in lymphoproliferative disorders by hematopathologists. A comprehensive statistical analysis of interobserver performance. Cancer, 62: 657-664.