- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FuzzyCell, an ontology-aware framework for cell type annotation that incorporates Cell Ontology constraints into training and inference. It combines neural candidate retrieval with differentiable fuzzy logic re-ranking and introduces a Sigmoidal Reichenbach implication operator. Experiments on three single-cell datasets report improved Macro-F1, particularly for rare and zero-shot types, and substantially reduced Axiom Violation Rate (AVR).
Critical strengths
1. Meaningful research direction. The paper integrates structured biological knowledge from the Cell Ontology into cell type annotation, potentially improving biological consistency beyond conventional expression-based predictions.
2. Promising empirical results. The method reports consistent improvements across multiple datasets and foundation model backbones, with particularly notable gains for rare and zero-shot cell types.
Critical weaknesses
1. Insufficient justification of the claimed full ontology reasoning.
The consistency score in Section 3.2 primarily relies on binary subsumption indicators. How disjointness, existential restrictions, and tissue context are incorporated remains unclear. Moreover, treating non-entailed relationships as zero may conflict with open-world semantics. Notably, is independent of , raising questions about how positive semantic evidence contributes to consistency scoring.
2. Theoretical and evaluation inconsistencies.
Proposition 3.1 does not establish a clear advantage over the original Reichenbach implication, which also has a nonzero gradient norm on . The proposed operator still exhibits vanishing antecedent gradients as .
More seriously, the subsumption violation definition in Appendix C.1 appears incompatible with the argmax prediction rule, making this violation term identically zero under the stated definitions, contrary to Figure 2. The reported Wilcoxon significance () also appears inconsistent with an exact test based on five paired runs.
Questions for authors
Q1. How are disjointness axioms, existential restrictions, and tissue context explicitly incorporated into the reasoning module? How does the scoring function distinguish non-entailed from incompatible relationships and reward positive semantic evidence, given that is independent of ?
Q2. In what precise mathematical sense does the proposed implication eliminate gradient degeneracy compared with the original Reichenbach implication? The antecedent gradient still contains the factor and approaches zero as .
Q3. How is the subsumption violation in AVR calculated? According to Section 3.2, the predicted type is selected by maximizing the final score. Its score therefore cannot be lower than that of the ground-truth type when both are candidates, contradicting the violation condition in Appendix C.1. When the ground-truth type is absent, the violation is explicitly set to zero. Could the authors reconcile this with Figure 2 and explain why some AVR values exceed classification error rates?
Q4. How were the reported p-values below 0.01 obtained from five runs using Wilcoxon signed-rank tests with Bonferroni correction? For five paired observations, the minimum two-sided exact p-value is 0.0625. Please clarify the statistical unit and test procedure.
4 comments
Dear Reviewer VxFA,
Thank you again for such careful questions. Two of them caught real inconsistencies in the submission, and we wanted to say plainly how each one was fixed, in case that helps when you look at the paper again.
- Q3 (subsumption term in AVR). You were right: the definition as written could not produce the values in Figure 2. App. C.1 (p. 33) now matches the sentence that follows it, so the term counts predictions that are a proper subtype of the true type. The same passage explains why AVR can exceed the error rate.
- Q4 (significance). You were right here too: five paired runs cannot give p < 0.01. We removed the claim. The caption of Table 1 (p. 8) now reports that every gain is at least twice the sum of the two standard deviations.
- Q1 and Q2. The full scoring function is written out in Sec. 3.2 (pp. 5-6), and Proposition 3.1 (p. 6) is restated as an exact gradient formula.
One more change since our response. Following a comment from Reviewer 4ZrZ, the paper now says the graded scores are "scored according to their consistency with CL", not that they are consistent with it. That is a more accurate description of what the scoring function in Q1 does.
If any of our answers missed what you were really asking, or if you still have doubts about soundness, please tell us. We would be glad to address them in the time that is left.
Thank you for your time and dedication!
Best regards,
The Authors
Thank you for your detailed response and for your efforts in revising the manuscript. I greatly appreciate the clarifications provided by the authors, as well as the revisions to the theoretical analysis, evaluation metrics, and implementation details. These revisions have addressed my main concerns.
Therefore, I am raising my rating to 3.
Dear Reviewer VxFA,
Thank you for your support and for raising your rating! Your questions made the statement of Proposition 3.1 more precise, and the paper is better for them. We will keep strengthening it.
One small note, in case it is helpful: on our side, the review form still displays the earlier rating (2), while the confidence shows as updated. It may simply be a display delay. If it is not, the rating can be updated through the "Edit" button on the official review whenever it is convenient for you.
Thank you again for your time and for such a constructive discussion. It has meant a lot to us.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response to Reviewer VxFA
We thank the reviewer! Q2 is answered in the general comment; Q1, Q3 and Q4 follow.
Q1. The full scoring function
(a) How disjointness and tissue act (s=10). Take a liver cell with epithelial membership 0.9.
(b) Open world. τ(Cj)=0 means "not entailed", not "false". For example, "T cell" does not entail "regulatory T cell", because a T cell need not be regulatory. Formally, a satisfiable EL⊥ concept has a canonical model that is a model of T, and T⊨C⊑τ iff its root lies in τ (Baader et al., 2005; Lutz & Wolter, 2010, Lemmas 12 and 13). So (τ(Cj))τ is the profile of a genuine model, which commits Cj to what is entailed and nothing more.
(c) Positive evidence, and why Iσ(a,1) is independent of a. Evidence rewards a candidate relative to its competitors. If two candidates differ only in whether they entail τ, their score ratio is Iσ(a,1)/Iσ(a,0):
Stronger evidence for τ therefore strictly favors the candidates that entail it. The neural term of sfinal and Ltype add positive evidence directly.
Q2. What the sigmoid changes
See the general comment (parts 2 and 3).
Q3. The AVR definition
The subsumption term. Thank you for catching the typo. As the sentence after the definition says, the term counts over-specification, that is, predicting a proper subtype of the true type.
AVR above the error rate. vrole never uses the label, so it can flag a correct prediction whose type's location restriction fails in the recorded tissue. An example is conjunctival epithelial cells sampled from the cornea in Tabula Sapiens. AVR is therefore not bounded by the error rate.
Q4. Statistical significance