- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Aiming at the problem of confusion between similar cell types and the lack of constraints on local spatial variations when predicting cell abundance directly from H&E images, this paper proposes two training constraints: KGSC uses marker genes from single-cell references to generate six-field descriptions via GPT-5.5, which are then processed by a frozen PubMedBERT to obtain cell semantics, and selects easily confused cell pairs based on abundance correlation in the training set to supervise their relative abundance differences. RSGC defines enriched regions and boundaries based on label abundance, supervising reliable spatial gradients only on the local GATv2 branch. Experiments on multiple datasets show that the proposed method outperforms existing methods in cell abundance prediction.
Critical strengths
Compared to independent regression for each cell type, the relative differences of easily confused pairs in KGSC and the regional gradients in RSGC have certain biological significance.
Critical weaknesses
- The related work section analyzes one-stage cell abundance prediction methods HP-Cell and CUCA, but there is no comparison with them in the experiments.
- The main contribution of the paper is the proposal of two training constraints, but the current ablation experiments cannot rigorously prove the effectiveness of these two constraints.
Questions for authors
- The ablation experiments seem to be based on single-run results. Have you tried running multiple experiments and averaging the results? If it is a single run, have you considered the impact of randomness on the results?
- If the two losses proposed in this paper are added to the backbone of Hist2Cell, would similar improvements be obtained? In other words, does the improvement in this paper depend on a specific backbone structure?
- The semantic descriptions are generated by GPT-5.5. Is Table 3 the complete prompt? The generated description text is not disclosed, nor is the code. If the model output is changed, could and the set of easily confused pairs change? Would this affect the final prediction?
- Were the slices partitioned by donor? If not, please explain whether there is a potential data leakage issue.
- What is the rationale for equally averaging the features and predictions in formulas 1 and 2? Could summing them dilute the contribution of certain features or predictions?
- It is recommended to add some demo figures to illustrate the process and effects of KGSC and RSGC.
- How is the semantic-confusion pair defined?