- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
SILTA proposes a two-stage reference-based spatial transcriptomics deconvolution framework. Stage I learns cell-type composition mappings using structured and diffusion-augmented pseudo-spots, while Stage II adapts the learned representations to unlabeled target tissues through spatial information, expression alignment, and reference replay. A quasi-negative-binomial objective and hierarchical post-hoc calibration are used to improve composition estimation. Compared with the other submissions, this paper provides relatively extensive experimental evidence, including matched ablations, perturbation recovery, reference-retention analysis, and downstream validation.
Critical strengths
-
The problem is defined fairly accurately. Given the sparse, long-tail composition of cell types and the shift in the reference-to-target distribution, the challenges identified are genuine and significant.
-
The experiments are fairly comprehensive. The method is compared with 10 other approaches, and four key metrics are reported for Moffitt, osmFISH, and seqFISH.
Critical weaknesses
-
Although the approach is effective overall, it is overly complex, resulting in a lack of clear attribution to the core innovative contributions. While each module is valid in its own right when considered in isolation, the authors have not sufficiently explained which one constitutes the true major algorithmic breakthrough. In particular, the matched experiment in Table 1 shows that, on the Moffitt dataset, the structured curriculum yields only a limited improvement over random aggregation. In contrast, the effects of qNB and Stage II adaptation, as described in the appendix, are more significant. The authors need to clarify what the truly indispensable core innovation is.
-
Cell-type deconvolution is inherently an ill-posed problem. For example, OSM contains 33 genes and 31 cell types. For cell subtypes with similar expression profiles, this setup may suffer from a severe lack of distinguishability. While a seemingly reasonable prediction rate can be achieved using only a sparse composition prior, spatial smoothing, and qNB reconstruction, this does not guarantee that different cell types will be correctly separated.
-
Appendix A.2 clearly states that the known proportion assessments for OSM and seqFISH are based on constructing spots by aggregating imaged cells into spatial bins. While this approach is reasonable for obtaining ground-truth composition, its data generation mechanism is not equivalent to that of actual technical platforms such as Visium. Real sequencing-based spots also involve complex factors such as capture efficiency, RNA diffusion, variations in sequencing depth, and platform-specific biases. Therefore, although the authors provide marker concordance and pathology-region classification in real tissue, these are indirect validations and cannot substitute for quantitative cell proportion assessments based on real sequencing-based spots.
Questions for authors
see the weaknesses
2 comments
Dear Reviewer c7f8,
Thank you for your constructive comments and suggestions. Our revised manuscript clarifies SILTA’s core contribution and includes quantitative deconvolution experiments on real sequencing-based spatial spots. We also provide additional evidence supporting SILTA’s ability to correctly distinguish similar cell types.
We would appreciate your review of our responses and revised manuscript when you have a chance. Please let us know whether any concerns remain; we welcome further questions and suggestions.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the importance of the problem and the breadth of the experimental evaluation, and for thoroughly reviewing our paper. We hope to address each of your questions.
Thanks for your valuable suggestion! SILTA's core algorithmic contribution is to construct complementary training signals from reference single-cell data and target spatial data, and to coordinate target adaptation and reference supervision through role-specific parameter updates.
Compared with adaptation methods such as AddaGCN (Ding et al., 2026), which use domain-adversarial feature alignment, SILTA uses qNB on the target side to measure the discrepancy between expression explained by the predicted composition and observed expression. Together with spatial information, this guides proportion predictions to adapt to the target tissue. On the reference side, pseudo-spots labelled with cell-number fractions provide direct composition supervision. Parameter protection, differentiated branch updates and configuration-dependent reference replay control how target expression and spatial information modify the reference-learned proportion mapping, thereby implementing target adaptation constrained by reference composition supervision.
Matched experiments validate the roles of target correction and reference supervision.
This shows that reference supervision can continue to constrain the expression-to-proportion mapping during target adaptation, and its role needs evaluation separately from target accuracy.
Structured pseudo-spots strengthen reference supervision in this framework by expanding labelled composition coverage. They actively increase training examples of balanced, near-pure and confusable compositions, providing more complete proportion supervision for Stage I to learn different types and composition boundaries, and continuing to participate in adaptation when replay is enabled. Matched experiments show gains on seqFISH.
Please refer to the blue-highlighted content in Section 1, Tables 1 and 16, and Appendices F.8–F.9 in the revised manuscript.
Thanks for your valuable suggestion! Direct evaluation against target cell-composition ground truth supports improved recovery of similar and low-abundance types. We evaluate the ability to distinguish cell types using per-type spatial PCC, rare-type average precision, and ordering accuracy for reference-defined similar-type pairs.
These results support improved discrimination of similar and low-abundance cell types under the measured gene panels.Pathology-region classification also supports the utility of these predictions.
Please refer to the blue-highlighted content in Section 3.1 and Appendix F.7 (Table 48) in the revised manuscript.
Thanks for your valuable suggestion! We evaluate quantitative deconvolution on real sequencing spots from the DBiTplus human lymph-node dataset and visualize the results.
We evaluate deconvolution on this dataset, and SILTA achieves the best mean on each of the four metrics compared with ten methods.This experiment directly compares sequencing-based proportion estimates with imaging-derived compositions. Independent scRNA-to-MERFISH and scRNA-to-osmFISH experiments test cross-platform transfer; controlled expression, RNA and capture perturbations test recovery under observation changes, and input-gene exclusion tests recovery with less expression information.
Please refer to the blue-highlighted content in Section 3.2 and Appendices F.2 and F.9–F.10 (Tables 36–38 and 50–52) in the revised manuscript.