- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces STAGE, a spatial transcriptomics foundation model that combines RNA expression and spatial information within cell neighbourhood graphs with hierarchical prototype learning. The model is pretrained on 32.44 million cells from 109 samples. The authors evaluate zero-shot and fine-tuned representations for spatial-domain analysis. Task-specific modules further extend the framework to masked-cell expression recovery, spatial expression completion under known perturbation conditions, and population-level response prediction for held-out perturbation targets. The results show improvements in most of these scenarios.
Critical strengths
The paper targets a meaningful problem in spatial transcriptomics: learning transferable representations across heterogeneous tissues and measurement platforms while adding cellular spatial context. The motivation for connecting tissue organisation with expression embedding is reasonable.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed STAGE mainly combines existing components: graph-attention, SwAV prototype learning, hierarchical clustering, and consistency regularisation. This paper does not show a clear technical innovation over existing ST foundation models. Basically, the core design of this work overlaps with Novae, and the changes are incremental. A controlled comparison with Novae under matched pretraining data and postprocessing, together with targeted ablations of the added modules, is needed to determine whether the gains really from these modifications.
-
The evaluation is dominated by spatial-domain consistency and embedding-separation metrics, with few assessment of general ST foundation model evaluation tasks such as cell-type annotation, cross-dataset label transfer, biologically faithful integration, and annotated spatial-niche or neighbourhood-composition prediction. UCE (Rosen et al., Nature, 2026), the SOTA single-cell FM that has been reported to perform much better than scGPT, is not evaluated. scGPT, as well as UCE, produces cell-level representations, whereas STAGE explicitly encodes spatial neighbourhoods. The paper does not clearly describe whether the scGPT baseline receives comparable neighbourhood context. Controls using scGPT and UCE embeddings aggregated over the same neighbourhoods, like using mean pooling of centre-cell and neighbourhood embeddings, are needed for fair comparison.
-
ASW of the proposed method is calculated after a domain-centroid transformation, whereas baseline scores use their respective embeddings. This transformation changes the embedding geometry whose separation ASW measures, confounding representation quality with model-specific postprocessing. The reported ASW advantage cannot be attributed solely to the proposed pretraining method.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide a comparison between STAGE and Novae using the same pretraining corpus and identical downstream evaluation and postprocessing protocols?
How does STAGE compare with scGPT and UCE when their cell embeddings are aggregated over the same physical neighbourhoods using mean pooling for example?