- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SpecCG for spatial domain identification in spatial transcriptomics. Its main contribution is the integration of learnable spectral enhancement with joint cell-gene modeling, bringing tissue-scale expression patterns together with local spatial relationships and gene co-expression. The framework couples cell and gene representations through expression reconstruction and learns clustering embeddings using contrastive and clustering objectives. Evaluation against ten baselines on five DLPFC sections and three additional tissue datasets reports improved clustering performance, supported by component ablations and marker-gene analyses.
Critical strengths
SpecCG’s main strength is its combination of spectral enhancement and cell–gene modeling. This is well motivated for spatial domain identification, where tissue-scale expression patterns and local spatial relationships are both relevant. The reported component ablations support the usefulness of this combination, making it a promising application of spectral methods to spatial transcriptomics.
Critical weaknesses
- The evaluation protocol leaves uncertainty about the source of the reported gains. Hyperparameters differ substantially across DLPFC sections, but their selection criterion and whether baselines received comparable tuning are unclear. The released code (main_test.py, lines 524-530) also contains logic to retain the highest-ARI result across epochs using ground-truth labels, but this selection procedure is not described in Algorithm 1. If this rule was used for the reported results, the gains may partly reflect label-informed selection rather than improvements attributable to the method.
- The methodological advance of SpecCG remains insufficiently established. Its integration of spectral enhancement and cell-gene modeling is reasonable, but GFE’s core filtering operation closely resembles GFNet (Rao et al., 2021). The component-removal ablations support the usefulness of the modules, but do not isolate what the proposed design adds over simpler alternatives.
[1] Yongming Rao, Wenliang Zhao, Zheng Zhu, Jiwen Lu, and Jie Zhou. Global Filter Networks for Image Classification. NeurIPS, 2021.
Questions for authors
- Given the similarity between GFE and existing learnable Fourier filtering approaches, what is the specific methodological contribution of GFE beyond adapting spectral filtering to spatial gene expression maps? Could the authors provide controlled comparisons with simpler spatial smoothing or alternative spectral filtering methods to substantiate the necessity of the proposed design?
- The DLPFC dataset contains 12 annotated sections, whereas the evaluation includes only five (151510, 151669, 151670, 151671, and 151674). What criteria motivated this selection? Could the authors report the results on all 12 sections, including the overall mean performance, to establish the representativeness of the evaluation and facilitate comparison with prior work?
- Appendix Table 4 reports substantially different hyperparameter configurations across DLPFC sections. Moreover, Figure 9 shows considerable and irregular fluctuations in clustering performance with respect to the temperature parameter (\tau), particularly on slices 151669, 151670 and 151674. Could the authors clarify how the optimal hyperparameters were selected and whether ground-truth labels or external clustering metrics (e.g., ARI) were used during tuning? Additionally, could the authors report the clustering performance under a shared hyperparameter configuration across DLPFC slices to assess the robustness of the reported improvements?
- For the results reported in Table 1, which checkpoint was used for each run: the final epoch, a fixed pre-specified epoch, or an epoch selected using an evaluation metric? If the best-ARI checkpoint was used, please report its performance alongside the final-epoch performance and state whether ground-truth labels were involved in checkpoint selection. Epoch-wise ARI/NMI and training-loss curves would further clarify the stability of the reported results.
10 comments
Contributions of the GFE module (2)
Spatial expression patterns and frequency domain signal recovery tasks
To quantify the unique advantages of the GFE module in terms of spatial expression pattern and spectral recovery, we selected the marker gene S100A11 with a clear white matter (WM) enrichment pattern on real DLPFC slice 151671, and regarded it as an evaluation marker with clean expression and a quantitative reference. Then add noise with the following settings:
Drawing on DUSTED's edge-emphasized dropout idea [2], apply spatially correlated dropout to non-zero counts.
Table 3. Noise Configurations
| Setting | Baseline Dropout Rate | Additional Edge Dropout Rate | Affected Edge Distance (units) |
|---|---|---|---|
| - | 0.15 | 0.35 | 5 |
in The zero-setting probability outside the edge band is 0.15. Within the edge band, the basic probability and the additional probability are added together, which is 0.50. The bandwidth is 5 coordinate units. Nonzero counts were independently set to zero with location-dependent probabilities. This allows the model to face both loss of expression and stronger loss of tissue edges.
- Spatial expression pattern recovery index
- AUROC takes the target domain as positive and the remaining domains as negative, and measures whether expression enrichment can distinguish the target domain.
- Spearman’s rank correlation was computed across matched spots.
- Spectral Error Measurement
- We directly quantify the spectral recovery error by performing graph Fourier transform GFT on clean, noisy and reconstructed representations using spatial neighbor graphs to avoid gridding. (noisy-clean, reconstructed-clean)
- If the clean, noisy and reconstructed expressions are re-interpolated to a regular grid and then DFT is performed, the error will be mixed into the additional interpolation noise introduced by the gridding process.
- Create GFT on the orthogonal eigenbase of the same graph Laplacian. The low frequency on the graph represents the slower changing mode between adjacent spot, so the global changes can be compared on the original tissue geometry.
Specifically, is taken for the same gene with clean, noisy and reconstructed expression, respectively, and the mean contains zero expression positions. Compute the signed coefficients using the same orthonormal basis . For each pattern and each marker gene, according to the frequency of the graph from low to high, and select the number of frequency bands that cumulatively cover 60%, 80% and 100% of non-zero frequency energy (the number of frequency bands is determined according to clean expression. This reference selection is shared by noisy and reconstruction, and we use the relative error of frequency domain recovery:
Here, the two vectors contain the first K nonzero-frequency GFT coefficients of the evaluated signal and clean reference. Their discrepancy is normalized by the reference norm, with lower error indicating better recovery.
Conclusion: The listed examples show that GFE not only effectively helps the model restore the spatial expression pattern and frequency domain signal masked by noise (DFT cannot restore the expression pattern at all and the frequency domain restoration error becomes large, graph Laplacian filtering improves layer discernibility, but the correspondence with the clean expression order has declined, and the frequency domain signal cannot be restored), but also is better than other simple spatial smoothing baselines in many aspects, indicating that the GFE module has a unique value that is different from other simple spatial smoothing baselines.
- Experimental results:
- The results shown in Table 4 show that the GFE module can achieve effective recovery of spatial expression patterns and frequency domain signals while improving clustering performance.
- The other two filtering baselines did not achieve effective improvements in all indicators. The graph Laplacian filter improved the layer discriminability, but the correspondence with the clean expression order declined. The data reconstructed by DFT worsened, indicating that it not only failed to restore the original signal, but also could not solve the impact of gridding.
- The comparison between the GFE module and DFT once again illustrates the important value of learnable frequency domain modulation and the necessity of design.
- The results in Table 5 once again demonstrate the above observations. DFT not only fails to restore the frequency domain signal, but also further increases the error. The GFE module uses the learnable frequency domain modulation module to effectively re store the original expressed frequency domain signal from the noise, significantly reducing the frequency domain recovery error.
Contributions of the GFE module (3)
Table 4. Quantification of Spatial Expression Pattern Recovery on Real Datasets
| METHOD | AUROC (%) ↑ | Spearman ↑ | ARI (%) ↑ | NMI (%) ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Noisy input | 56.40 | 0.3092 | - | - |
| DFT + KNN interpolation | 49.53 ± 23.91 | 0.1120 ± 0.1201 | 42.04 ± 7.45 | 55.89 ± 0.97 |
| Laplacian filtering | 86.40 | 0.1996 | 51.74 | 57.01 |
| SpecCG | 99.41 | 0.6433 | 71.29 | 74.05 |
Table 5. Relative Spectral Error on Real Datasets
| METHOD | RSE: 60% Energy ↓ | RSE: 80% Energy ↓ | RSE: 100% Energy ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Noisy input | 0.9213 | 0.9647 | 1.0738 |
| DFT + KNN interpolation | 1.0112 | 1.0086 | 1.0070 |
| Laplacian filtering | 0.9715 | 0.9787 | 0.9831 |
| SpecCG | 0.7605 | 0.9415 | 0.9535 |
References
- Paper Revision: We have added the corresponding material to Sections 4.3–4.4 of the main text..
Contributions of the GFE module (1)
Response.
Thank you for your suggestion. We agree that the two methods share the same operation principle, namely two-dimensional Fourier transform, frequency domain element-wise complex multiplication and inverse transform. We will add additional references in the methods and related work.
Methodological contributions of the GFE module
Our GFE module and GFNet [1] differ significantly in specific motivations and methodological details, GFNet learns arbitrary filter weights on image feature channels. In SpecCG, each channel of the input corresponds to a gene expression map with a biological identity. For frequency (u,v) and gene g, we learn Zg′(u,v)=W(u,v)Zg(u,v), where<strong>same one</strong>Complex response W(u,v) acts on all genes. Each gene retains its own spectral amplitude and phase, so shared responses can also produce different spatial outputs.
Extended ablation experiments with simple spatial smoothing methods
We performed comparisons in conventional clustering and spatial expression pattern with reference and frequency domain signal recovery tasks respectively, and conducted them under the same parameter adjustment and training conditions to illustrate the unique advantages of the GFE module in recovering biological expression patterns compared with simple spatial smoothing alternative methods.
General clustering tasks:
Conclusion: Relevant empirical evidence shows that the GFE module is superior to the simple spatial smoothing method in improving the overall clustering performance of the model.
Table 1. ARI of Different Spatial Smoothing Methods (%) ↑
Table 2. NMI of Different Spatial Smoothing Methods (%) ↑